We understand why the WPIAL conducts its championship games on the same day at the same site. It is great for the players to have an opportunity to play on the same sand as the Steelers and great for the hard-core fans because one ticket affords an opportunity to watch four games.

The day has become a happening ... a celebration of high school football in Western Pennsylvania. But it certainly isn't perfect.

The playing surface at Heinz Field is being re-sodded this week because it is in such bad shape. The re-sodding process would have probably started immediately after the Pitt-West Virginia game last Friday if the WPIAL finals had not been Saturday.

OK, so the field conditions were the same for all eight of the teams involved in the championships, which is the way it should be. But the field conditions shouldn't be so terrible that the field is replaced after the finals.

Advertise with us

We still don't understand why the WPIAL makes sure to play its quarterfinals and semifinals at high school stadiums with artificial turf and then takes teams to a sandbox for the most important games of the year. It's a good thing the storm that dropped close to 2 inches of rain in the area last week didn't last until Friday and Saturday. Think muddy mess.

Yes, we understand there isn't any other venue large enough and attractive enough for the one-day WPIAL extravaganza. Where is Pitt Stadium when you need it? It would just be nice if, for once, the Steelers re-sodded Heinz Field before the WPIAL finals.

Either that, or the WPIAL should play its semifinals at high school stadiums that have fields that are void of grass and patched together to get teams ready for the finals.

The other problem with playing the title games at Heinz Field is that there is no atmosphere with the small crowds the individual contests attract. Heck, there isn't a lot of atmosphere there with the size of the crowds Pitt attracts.

It's too bad there isn't a nice, cozy 25,000 seat stadium in the area somewhere.

Advertise with us

Nice touch

Perry quarterback Greg McGhee led the Commodores to a 32-0 victory against Brashear in the City League championship game two weeks ago and received the Jeron Grayson Most Valuable Player Award for his efforts.

It was a nice touch by City League officials to name the championship game's MVP award after the former Schenley High standout who helped the Spartans to the City title in 2009. Grayson was killed at a party at California University of Pennsylvania in October.

The folks at the WPIAL office should pick up on that idea.

We have said for years that a most valuable player should be selected for each of the WPIAL championship games, either by the league or the hord of media types who show up for the games. The Class AAAA final MVP award could be named after Charles "Ace" Heberling, the former WPIAL executive secretary whose idea it was to have all four finals at Three Rivers Stadium in 1986.

Advertise with us

The others could be named after former WPIAL greats such as Ringgold quarterback Joe Montana, Turtle Creek lineman and Heisman Trophy winner Leon Hart, Aliquippa tight end and former Chicago Bears coach Mike Ditka, former Braddock coach Chuck Klausing, Connellsville quarterback and a Heisman winner Johnny Lujack, Beaver Falls quarterback Joe Namath, Hopewell running back Tony Dorsett or Central Catholic quarterback Dan Marino, to name a few.

Our choices

Since there were no MVPs selected again this year, here is who we would have voted as the most valuable players in each of the championship games.

• Class A -- This was easy. Clairton quarterback/defensive end Desimon Green, who ran 26 yards for a touchdown and threw a 21-yard pass for another score, is our choice.

• Class AA -- A tough one because a lot of individuals performed well for South Fayette. Our choice is Lions quarterback Christian Brumbaugh, who completed 12 of 23 passes for 147 yards and two touchdowns.

Advertise with us

• Class AAA -- Another toughie. We are going with Central Valley sophomore sensation Robert Foster who scored on a punt return and a 70-yard reception. He rushed six times for 56 yards, completed a pass for 17 yards and caught two passes for 75 yards.

• Class AAAA -- We have never been big on co-MVPs, but in this case we are making an exception. Our co-MVPs are North Allegheny linebacker Kevin Cope and defensive end/tight end Rob Kugler. Cope had nine tackles in the final, three for losses, and two sacks. Kugler had five tackles, all for losses, and a sack. Plus he caught a 3-yard pass for a touchdown.

Check it out

For those looking for highlights and interviews from the WPIAL finals check out the Highmark High School Sports Practice show on Pittsburgh CW. The show features Rob Pratte and Tad Makowiecki. Ryno Production cameramen Scott Devinney, Justin Philips, Josh McCullough and Matt Barba captured all the color and pageantry from the finals. The show is 11-11:30 a.m. Sunday.