It was June of 2009 and Matt Clement had just retired a few months earlier after nine years as a Major League Baseball pitcher. He said he felt like he had fulfilled a childhood dream of being a professional athlete.
On Monday, Clement acknowledged he felt like he had fulfilled another dream — and it was again time to walk away.
Clement has been the boys basketball head coach for the past 17 seasons at Butler High School, his alma mater. He gathered his players together Monday and told them he was stepping down as coach.
Clement enjoyed plenty of success at Butler, winning one of only two WPIAL titles for the Golden Tornado’s basketball team in the past 100 years. He made it to a WPIAL title game two other times, made the WPIAL playoffs 14 of 17 seasons in the largest classification and had a record of 248-148.
“When I was in spring training in 2009, I was coming off arm surgery, but I felt maybe I could’ve maybe made it back to the major leagues in time,” Clement said. “But I remember a veteran player telling me, ‘There comes a time when somebody else deserves to get a chance.’ I feel a little that way about basketball.
“Besides family activities, coaching at Butler has been as rewarding as getting to play baseball. I’ve so enjoyed seeing the community and fans we always had at games, the atmospheres at games, the relationships with the kids and so many people. It’s been great and it’s hard to walk away. But maybe it’s time to give someone else a chance to do it their way. Maybe some freshness can really help the program. As a coach, I re-evaluated every year, especially the past few years. Are the kids still listening to me? Are things still working?
Read More
“I have two sons who will be playing college baseball next year. I want to see them play. I might get into some other things. I just think it’s time.”
Clement did his share of winning at Butler, but his story can’t be fully appreciated in just numbers and statistics. I say his is one of the best feel-good stories in the WPIAL over the past 40 years.
He was a most unlikely player to make the major leagues, being discovered by accident by a few major league scouts during his senior year at Butler. Heck, he pitched a total of 18 innings his senior year. Also, consider that it’s not often you see players with fairly long pro careers come back to be a head coach for a high school team. Sure, it happens, but Clement came back to coach at his alma mater. How often does that happen — and in a sport he didn’t play professionally? He built a house in Butler and started a family with his high school sweetheart, Heather.
Who does this? Matt Clement.
“I didn’t want to get pushed out or be miserable when I left and I’m not,” said Clement. “I still had as much fun this season [when Butler went 6-14] as I did a lot of other seasons.”

Clement’s story is somewhat of a folk tale of the boy who grew up, pitched in the Major League Baseball playoffs and made the American League All-Star team once, all before he came back home to coach where he played two sports.
The story started when Clement was a senior at Butler and he was pretty certain he would play basketball in college. He was the starting point guard on a Mark Jula-coached Butler team that lost in the 1993 WPIAL 4A title game. (Clement credits Jula with inspiring him to be a coach and also helping him in various ways). Lafayette, Bucknell, Robert Morris and Duquesne were showing interest. Then on April 20, 1993, exactly 33 years prior to Clement telling his Butler basketball team that he was stepping away, he got his baseball break.
Butler was to play a non-section game that day against Franklin Regional. A few scouts came to see talented Franklin Regional shortstop Kirk Taylor. Butler coach Ron Zawrotuk wanted to save his best pitchers, so he asked Clement, the starting third baseman, to pitch this game. Clement always had a decent arm, but he started throwing pitches in excess of 90 mph, which was exceptional for a high school pitcher back then. Scouts’ jaws dropped.
Word spread. The next time Clement pitched, there were about two dozen scouts there. Even though Clement pitched only 18 innings his senior year, he was selected by the San Diego Padres in the third round of the draft. He signed with San Diego later that summer and was in the majors by 1998. He pitched for the Padres, Chicago Cubs, Boston Red Sox and Florida Marlins in his nine years and won 87 games. With the Cubs in 2002, he finished fourth in the National League in strikeouts. He won 14 games with the Cubs in 2003 and was 13-6 with the Red Sox in 2005, when he made the All-Star Game.

Through it all, Clement kept tabs on Butler and WPIAL basketball. When he was with the Cubs, I sat in a Wrigley Field dugout with him before a game and listened to him express his desire to coach basketball in the WPIAL — and Butler would be his dream job. About five years later, the dream became true.
“The Butler job opened up when I was still in spring training in 2009 [with the Toronto Blue Jays],” Clement said. “I didn’t decide to go for it until I retired. It was just luck that it worked that way. I needed something when I retired to kind of substitute the adrenaline of playing pro baseball. The question I have been asked most is why did I coach basketball and not baseball? At that time, coaching basketball was more exciting to me. Coaching baseball was going to be more boring to me because I really didn’t understand then all of the strategy in coaching baseball.”
Through his success in the Major Leagues, Clement was known for his humility. And so was his family. Heck, his father, Paul, continued to work in sporting goods at a Butler K-Mart even after his son signed a big contract with the Red Sox. Paul and Lois Clement continued to live in their small ranch house in Butler through much of their son’s MLB career.
Clement was 16-5 his first season as Butler’s coach. He won 15 games or more nine times. He lost in the WPIAL final in 2017 and 2019 before winning it in 2020 with star guard Ethan Morton, one of the WPIAL’s most accomplished players in the past few decades.
Clement and his wife have three sons and a daughter and he coached all of his sons in basketball. He is still a volunteer pitching coach for the Butler baseball team and said he would like to continue coaching baseball. One son, Madden, is a pitcher at Virginia Tech. Youngest son, Mavrik, is a senior catcher at Butler who has signed with Pitt.
“I didn’t get into this [basketball coaching] to coach my sons,” Clement said. “I never thought I’d last 17 years.”
This spring, Clement also has started doing weekly segments about the Pirates for The Fan 93.7. He might get more into the media in the future.
Clement gave some interesting thoughts and answered some questions on a variety of other subjects about his coaching days:
• On what he might miss most: “How important Butler basketball was to the community, but the player relationships are so special. One of the things I take pride in is I had seven of my players end up coaching with me. But I’ll miss the relationships with other coaches, too, and just the strategy of the game.”

• His best player: “That’s easy. It’s Ethan Morton. But one of his greatest attributes other than his talent was how important the town of Butler was to him and how important Butler basketball was to him.”
• Best opposing player he coached against: “This may be surprising, but it’s Pine-Richland’s Phil Jurkovec [who was a star football quarterback at Pine-Richland]. He was such a winner. Were there more talented hoopers? Yes. But no one affected a game more than him and he was the hardest player to game plan for.”
• Best opposing team: “The two New Castle teams [from 2012-14]. It’s not even close. They lost one game in two years. They were one of the few teams where when we walked into a gym, I knew we were in major, major trouble before the ball was tipped.”
• Changes in high school basketball these days: “When I first started, you could win games defensively. Defense can still win games, but nowadays you better have shooting and offense. You better figure that out. The other difference is you had a player maybe transferring to another school or going to a prep school here and there. Now, you aren’t even sure when you have your year-end banquet, which kids you’ll have back. It’s to the point where kids freely go on social media and announce what high school they’re transferring to. That’s one of the craziest things I’ve seen.”
• A person worth a big ‘thank you’: “My wife. To do this 17 years, you better have family support, especially from your wife. Something I’ll kind of miss is me coming home from games and hearing her perspective of the game and maybe what she thought of the officials or why I didn’t hold the ball. This coaching became such a part of both of our lives.”
Like a dream.
Mike White: mwhite@post-gazette.com and @mwhiteburgh on X.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.