HERSHEY, Pa. — Oakland Catholic’s Madi Pullen shot the lights out Saturday, drilling 3 after 3 as her team got little else offensively.
Unfortunately for the Eagles, it just wasn’t enough, as defending champion Neumann-Goretti turned the lights out Oakland Catholic’s run at a PIAA title.
Reginna Baker scored 17 points and Philadelphia Catholic League power Neumann-Goretti used its superior speed to power to consecutive titles by defeating Oakland Catholic, 53-48, in the PIAA Class 4A championship at Giant Center.
Oakland Catholic (25-3), which recently won a second WPIAL title in a row, was seeking its first PIAA championship since 2005. That would have made Oakland Catholic just the third WPIAL school to win five titles. Neumann-Goretti (20-10) claimed its seventh title, all since 2015.
Pullen nearly pulled Oakland Catholic to the win. A 5-foot-8 junior guard, Pullen knocked down six 3-pointers among her game-high 24 points, which included 14 of her team’s 20 first-half points.
“The first shot went in and everything else was feeling good off the hands from there. I was just in a rhythm, I guess,” said Pullen, whose team saw an 18-game win streak come to an end.
Read More
The problem was that she got very little help in the scoring department. Not only did Pullen account for more than half of the Eagles’ points, but she was responsible for eight of the team’s 14 field goals. Standout forward and Richmond recruit Josie Fontana added eight points, but foul trouble forced her to miss a large portion of the second quarter, one in which the Eagles were outscored, 16-5.
“They sped us up,” Oakland Catholic coach Henry Schechter said. “One team we played in Florida was maybe just as quick or similar, but certainly their speed made a difference [Saturday].”
Neumann-Goretti’s edge in speed and athleticism also was evident in its play offensively, with the Saints tagging Oakland Catholic — the WPIAL’s stingiest defensive team at 27.8 points per game — for the most points it had given up during the postseason and the second-most it allowed the entire season.
Oakland Catholic trailed, 49-39, with 2:13 remaining before using a late surge to make things interesting. But after Savanna Daye scored a bucket with 43 seconds left, the Eagles would get no closer.
“We never wanted to give up and wanted to fight all the way through,” Pullen said. “We just wanted to give it our all.”
Game flow
The first half was a tale of two quarters, with Oakland Catholic landing a big first-quarter blow before Neumann-Goretti countered with a punch in the second.
Pullen set the tone early, connecting on three 3-pointers among her 11 points to propel Oakland Catholic to a 15-7 advantage. The Eagles made five of their first nine shots while holding Neumann-Goretti to 2-of-13 shooting.
It was a big bounce-back game for Pullen, who struggled with her shot in recent games. She had not scored more than 14 points in any of Oakland Catholic’s four previous PIAA games. Pullen made her first five shots, including her first four 3-point attempts.
“It really did bother her the last couple of games that she wasn’t shooting as well. But she put her mind to it, stepped up and just had a tremendous game, as good of a game a kid can play in this environment,” said Schechter, who guided a team in Virginia to a state final in 2024.
As for the second quarter, well, it was a much different story. Oakland Catholic led by nine points before Neumann-Goretti used a 16-1 run to surge ahead, 23-17, with 3:13 left in the half. Pullen’s fourth 3 would pull Oakland within, 23-20, at the half, but it was a nightmare of a quarter for the Eagles, who made only 1 of 11 shots.
“They’re the best team in the state, so that kind of hurt us,” Schechter said. “But I think that speed [really hurt us], and it’s a big environment. We got up early and had a lot of confidence and they came back. And I think there were some times in the middle of the game where it waned a little bit.”
Having its star player on the bench for most of the second quarter didn’t do Oakland Catholic any favors. One of the WPIAL’s top talents, Fontana picked up her third foul with 4:53 left and didn’t return until the second half. She finished 2 of 7 from the field and 4 of 8 from the free-throw line.
Neumann-Goretti never relinquished the lead in the second half. And after leading by five after three quarters, the Saints began the fourth on an 8-2 run to take a double-digit lead with 3:58 remaining.
Baker, a 5-7 junior guard with Division I offers, played well and went 9 of 9 from the free-throw line, while freshman guard Azzure O’Connor chipped in with 16 points.
Key stats
• Each team played only six players, and Oakland Catholic freshman Brooklyn Rozier (four points) was the only reserve to score in the game.
• Oakland Catholic had not given up more than 44 points in any postseason game.
• Neumann-Goretti finished 18 of 28 from the free-throw line, while Oakland Catholic was 14 of 24.
Quotable
“I’m super proud. This is a great team. It’s sad to end it this way, but it’s been a great year.” — Pullen




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.