For the vast majority of the second half in an action-packed WPIAL Class 3A quarterfinal clash at Mt. Lebanon High School on Wednesday night, it seemed like it was Mimi Thiero’s world, and we were all just living in it.

Then Casey Davis decided to steal the show.

Following a barrage of buckets and blocks by Thiero, Quaker Valley’s coveted senior superstar, Seton LaSalle’s little-known sophomore guard Davis drained a game-winning 3-pointer in the final 10 seconds to lift the No. 5 Rebels (16-8) to a thrilling 57-54 victory. The triumph snapped a nine-game winning streak for the No. 4 Quakers (17-7).

“I couldn’t be happier for the team in general,” said Seton LaSalle coach Joe Michalski. “I knew in a moment like that, [Davis] would be ready.”

Advertise with us

The WPIAL’s scoring champion with an average of 29.4 points per game during the regular season, Thiero finished with 27 points and eight blocked shots in Wednesday’s loss. Sophomore guard Keira Watson added 14 points for Quaker Valley. Sophomore Natalie Pascarella led the Rebels with 15 points to go with 13 from freshman guard Kayla Deasy and 12 from freshman guard Ava Maroney.

“Win or lose, in those tight games, a thousand different things during the game play out differently, either way, back and forth,” said Quakers coach Ken Johns. “A made shot here, a bounce there, a turnover there, a steal there. I think that was the case for both teams. I was proud of how hard our kids fought.”

Game flow

Quaker Valley jumped out to a 6-3 lead despite Thiero going scoreless for nearly the entire first quarter. The towering 6-foot-4 center made her presence felt on the defensive end instead, tallying five blocked shots in the first four minutes alone. Of course, it was only a matter of time before she drained a 3-pointer for her first bucket of the game to give the Quakers an 11-8 lead going into the second quarter.

After a nice steal-and-score in transition for a three-point play by Maroney gave Seton LaSalle its first lead of the game at 17-15, Pascarella followed with a 3-pointer to make it 20-15 midway through the second. Watson then came right back with a nice driving layup to tie the game after converting a pair of free throws for Quaker Valley.

A putback by Thiero gave the Quakers a 24-22 lead going into the break following a back-and-forth opening half.

Advertise with us

“It’s really hard to prepare when you see someone on the other side that’s as skilled and talented as Mimi Thiero is,” Michalski said. “I knew they would find ways to get her the ball. … We knew that we were going to have our work cut out for us.”

Quaker Valley stretched its lead to 28-24 early in the third on back-to-back baskets by Watson, then a 3-pointer from the top of the key by Davis put the Rebels back on top. After a go-ahead layup by Thiero, Maroney answered with a tough layup of her own while drawing a foul, then freshman Julia Piaggesi buried a 3-pointer in the corner to make it a 36-32 lead for Seton LaSalle.

That only sparked the fire inside Thiero, though, who knocked down back-to-back 3s to give the Quakers a 40-38 advantage going into the fourth.

“She was upset [after the game],” Johns said. “She takes all of that personally. She cares a lot about the team.”

An and-one layup by Thiero broke open a tie game with 6:12 to play, giving Quaker Valley a 45-42 lead. Pascarella then hit her fourth 3-pointer of the game to put the Rebels back on top, 46-45, before Thiero responded with another layup to give the lead back to the Quakers.

Advertise with us

After Seton briefly regained the lead on two free throws by Maroney, Quaker Valley simply went right back inside to Thiero for another easy layup. The next time down the floor, she banked in a go-ahead 3-pointer to make it 52-49, but Pascarella’s fifth 3-pointer put the Rebels back up, 54-52.

The Quakers tied the score at 54, on a jumper by Watson, setting up the dramatic finish in the final minute. Following Thiero’s eighth block of the game, the ball found its way to a wide-open Davis, who came through in the clutch with the biggest shot of her life to send Seton to the semifinals.

“We had 10 seconds left, and I knew how bad we wanted this,” Davis said. “It feels so great. … We came out confident and we worked together, and we won.”

Key stat

Seton made eight 3-pointers, while Thiero was the only player to make a 3-pointer for Quaker Valley, finishing with four 3s on the evening.

Quotable

“I thought Seton played really hard. They made shots. Give them credit. They made the shots they had available to them. They’re young and they’re good.” — Johns

Advertise with us

What it means

The Rebels will now move on to take on top-seeded Shady Side Academy in the WPIAL semifinals on Saturday at a site and time to be determined.