Upper St. Clair and New Castle have led the conversation about Class 6A boys basketball all season.

So it was no surprise Monday when the WPIAL announced the brackets for the 2026 playoffs that there was immense interest in the decision of the committee about which one-loss team would be the No. 1 seed in the tournament.

As it turned out the committee went with the two-time defending champion Panthers.

“It just means that we’ve had a good year and the committee respects what you’ve done, so we appreciate that,” Upper St. Clair coach Danny Holzer said. “But at the end of the day, this tournament’s going to be tough and there are a lot of good teams.”

Advertise with us

Upper St. Clair (20-1) ties Central Catholic (19-2), the No. 3 seed, for the Section 2 title as the Vikings handed the Panthers their only loss of the season, 48-46, in overtime on Dec. 12. Since that time, Upper St. Clair has reeled off 16 consecutive victories, including a 48-47 win against Central Catholic in their rematch on Jan. 16, a triumph against City League favorite Allderdice and three victories against Florida teams during a weekend swing to the Sunshine State in December.

New Castle (19-1) also won 16 consecutive games, but it accomplished the feat from the start of the season until it suffered a 51-49 loss to Pine-Richland on Jan. 30. Though the Red Hurricanes rebounded with three consecutive wins to close out their resume prior to the committee meeting, it was only good enough to earn the team the No. 2 seed.

“Obviously Upper St. Clair was dominant during the regular season, they’re the two-time defending champion, and New Castle dropped a game recently to Pine-Richland. I think a lot of their games have been really close,” Bethel Park athletic director and WPIAL basketball committee member Laura Grimm said. “At this time of the year, we’re all aware that sometimes losses can be a good thing, but obviously theirs came more recently. When in doubt, when they’re that close, I think St. Clair being the back-to-back defending champ put them over the edge.”

There were a couple of other decisions that the committee made that might have people scratching their heads. Perhaps the most surprising was in Class 2A where Sewickley Academy (21-0) finished as the only undefeated boys team in the WPIAL but was relegated to the No. 2 seed behind defending champion Jeannette (19-1).

“It could have gone either way, but I figured we’d be 1 or 2. My statement this whole season was they immediately put Sewickley ahead of us at the start of the season and we’re the defending champ and we beat them last year,” Jeannette coach Adrian Batts said. “The only way we would have met them was in the championship, so whatever side [of the bracket] would have worked.”

Advertise with us

Jeannette was the No. 3 seed last year and upset No. 2 Sewickley Academy, 45-25, in the WPIAL Class 2A semifinals at Fox Chapel. The Jayhawks, who have all five starters back from last year, suffered their only loss this season to a team from Kentucky.

“Jeannette is the defending champ and we did go back and forth on it. We did have a pretty intense conversation,” Grimm said. “Keeping consistent with what we did before, Jeannette is the reigning champ, but we did wrestle with that.”

About the only other surprise on the boys side was in Class 5A where Section 4 with Chartiers Valley, Lincoln Park and Moon garnering three of the top four seeds. The section-champion Colts (19-2) are No. 1, the Leopards (16-5), who lost two of their five games to Chartiers Valley, are No. 2 and the Tigers (18-3), who lost to Lincoln Park twice and handed Chartiers Valley its only section loss, was No. 4.

“That just shows how strong we think that section is and a credit to them,” Grimm said. “We do like to keep some reward for section champs, so Thomas Jefferson and Penn Hills are up there, but when it comes down to it, we feel if those teams play today, this is how they would stack up in that order.”

Quaker Valley (17-3), which did not lose a game in Section 2, earned the No. 1 seed in Class 4A and a first-round bye after No. 2 North Catholic (17-4), which was given the other bye, and No. 3 Knoch (18-4) split their season series. The Trojans won the most recent meeting last week.

Advertise with us

As far as the girls, there were no real surprises as to the No. 1 seeds. Canon-McMillan (17-4), which won its first section title in a decade, is the top seed in Class 6A, defending PIAA Class 5A champion South Fayette (21-1) was the top pick in that classification, while Class 4A went to undefeated Blackhawk (20-0) over defending champion Oakland Catholic (18-2), which goes in as No. 2 behind the Cougars for the second consecutive year.

In Class 3A, a late-season overtime loss to Class 2A No. 1 Neshannock (18-3) possibly cost Beaver Falls (20-1) the top spot and a first-round bye in Class 3A. Instead, it was 2025 WPIAL and PIAA finalist Shady Side Academy (19-2) that took the top spot, while Aquinas Academy (19-2) is the No. 1 seed in Class 1A.

Though the top seeds were fairly straightforward there were a couple of interesting decisions.

In Class 6A, the committee opted to give the top three seeds to Canon-McMillan, No. 2 Norwin (16-4) and No. 3 Upper St. Clair (11-10) out of Section 2. It then matched up Section 1 co-champions Pine-Richland as the No. 4 and Seneca Valley at No. 5 to play each other in the first round of the nine-team field.

“Canon-Mac and Norwin were the top two teams. That was pretty undisputed,” Grimm said. “There was lots of conversation about Upper St. Clair — and I anticipate it to be one of the most criticized decisions the committee made — but we felt that head-to-head was the best metric of how to seed those teams and St. Clair beat both of those teams.”

Geibel in Class 1A was probably the other decision that opened a lot of eyes. The Gators are 20-1 with their only loss coming in a 51-50 decision to Serra Catholic, but that loss was enough to drop them into the No. 4 spot behind Aquinas Academy, Serra Catholic (15-5) at No. 2 and three-time defending champion Union (18-4) at No. 3.