Natalie Wetzel remembers being in the sixth grade and going to Petersen Events Center in 2019 to watch Makenna Marisa lead Peters Township to its first WPIAL championship in a 43-40 overtime win against North Allegheny.
“I remember watching them get their medals,” Wetzel said. “Ever since then, it’s been a dream of mine.”
But after Marisa graduated, the Peters Township program dropped off significantly. The year after the Indians won WPIAL and PIAA Class 6A titles, they went 7-15, then 6-9 in 2020-21.
What Peters Township needed was another marquee player like Marisa to resurrect the program. Little did anyone realize at the time, she was about to take the stage.
In 2021-22 as a gangly 6-foot-3 freshman, Wetzel teamed with Journey Thompson to get Peters Township back over .500 and into the playoffs. And this season, she culminated her high school career by helping to resurrect the program back into a champion.

Wetzel picked up the mantle Marisa left behind. Wetzel became the most feared player at both ends of the court in the WPIAL this season, as she averaged 18.7 points, 9.5 rebounds, 2.4 assists and 1.7 blocks per game, and she led the Indians to the WPIAL Class 5A title with a 40-36 victory against South Fayette.
Read More
For her efforts, Wetzel once again joins Marisa as Wetzel has been selected the 2025 Post-Gazette Girls Basketball Player of the Year. Marisa won the award in 2019.
“I feel like Peters Township, after Makenna’s year, kind of had a bad rep and wasn’t doing too well,” said Wetzel, a Miami (Fla.) recruit. “I just think that, our team, we were able to bring Peters Township back to having the same rep as when Makenna was playing, and I’m just happy we were able to do that for the program.”
The championship was only the second in Peters Township girls basketball history.
“I think the thing that’s most rewarding from my end is how she got better every season,” Peters Township coach Steve Limberiou said. “I started with her the summer going into her sophomore year, but she progressed every season. There was something that she added to her game every year. By her junior year, she became a great shooter, her senior year a great defender, and put it all together.”

Wetzel completed her career with 1,692 points, 806 rebounds, 23 assists and 125 blocks, but more impressive may be the improvement in the team during her tenure.
In both her freshman and sophomore years, the team was 13-11 and won its first-round postseason games against Butler. But last year, the Indians took a big leap forward as they won the Class 6A Section 2 title before losing to North Allegheny in the WPIAL semifinals.
This year, the team dropped to Class 5A and soared. Peters Township finished the season 26-4, won the WPIAL title and did not lose to a team from Pennsylvania until South Fayette avenged its WPIAL finals loss with a victory in the state semifinals.
“It definitely really stung after our loss, but I mean, over the last couple of days, I think I’ve been able to reflect on how good of a season we actually had,” Wetzel said. “It’s always been a dream of mine to win a WPIAL title, and it was my last year and my last chance to do so. I think I put a lot of pressure on myself and on my team and, for us to accomplish that, I’m so proud of us.”
Now, Wetzel is preparing for the next stage of her academic and basketball sojourns as she will head to Miami on June 14 to open summer classes and summer workouts.
“It’s starting to get really real, but I’m really excited,” Wetzel said. “It’s going to be like going to school at a resort. I really like the campus down there, the coaching staff, and I can’t wait to meet my teammates. I’m going to miss everyone here, but it’s not a bad place to visit.”
She’ll also be walking into another reclamation project as the Hurricanes were 14-15 this season, just 4-14 in the ACC and are rebuilding under Tricia Cullop.
“This year was the coaching staff’s first year coming from Toledo, so there were a bunch of transfers and they didn’t have their recruits,” Wetzel said. “But this year, I hope my recruiting class can build something great over the next four years, and I’m looking forward to it.”




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.