Payton Collins will be the first to admit some doubts went through her mind early in the fourth quarter against Chartiers Valley.

“Honestly, I thought for a second we were out of it,” Collins said. “But there’s always a possibility and we were all on the same page.”

It’s hard to blame her. Mt. Lebanon girls basketball was down 16 to the Colts with 3:30 remaining in regulation Thursday. The Blue Devils offense had been stagnant throughout, and they hadn’t really been able to solve the Chartiers Valley defense.

Then Collins hit two free throws. Then a 3-pointer. And another.

Advertise with us

By the time it was all said and done, Mt. Lebanon had pulled off one of the greatest comebacks in WPIAL playoff history.

Collins scored 17 of her game-high 25 points in the final 3:28, including the game-winning free throw with 0.4 seconds left in regulation, to give No. 4 Mt. Lebanon (17-6) a dramatic 47-46 come-from-behind victory against No. 5 Chartiers Valley (12-10) in the WPIAL Class 6A quarterfinals.

“We were kind of cold the first three-and-a-half quarters,” Collins, a sophomore, said. “But then our defense started picking up, we started getting steals and we started scoring.”

Mt. Lebanon outscored Chartiers Valley, 20-3, in the final 3:28 and 23-14 in the fourth quarter. The Blue Devils scored only 23 points in the first three quarters.

“It was pretty unreachable, especially the way (the Colts) were playing,” Mt. Lebanon coach Jackie DelSardo said. “I’ve never seen them play better, which is a shame. But it’s also a great way to end the season because they gave everything they had.”

Advertise with us

Chartiers Valley was solid at both ends of the floor until the very end. Although the Colts had a 43-27 lead after a Lilah Turnbull hoop with 5:16 left, they committed 10 turnovers in the fourth quarter.

“We were just looking to get layups at that point and we pulled it out when we didn’t have wide-open hits,” Chartiers Valley coach Mike Semplice said. “I made a bad coaching decision going back to a zone and we gave up two 3s when we got out of man.”

Even so, Chartiers Valley still had a 46-40 lead after Collins’ basket with 40.6 seconds left. But a Colts turnover ended up being a four-point play when Collins ripped a 3-pointer from the right of the key, was fouled and made it a one-possession game, 46-44, with 27.9 seconds left.

“I think that fouled 3, that was one of the best plays I’ve seen,” DelSardo said. “Especially from a sophomore.”

Collins tied it at 46, on a layup with 12.3 seconds left and the Mt. Lebanon defense turned it up another notch. The Blue Devils forced the turnover in the backcourt, Collins grabbed it and was fouled with 0.4 seconds remaining.

Advertise with us

“Honestly, I was just thinking that I could never forgive myself if I miss these,” Collins said. “I was just imagining it was me and my dad and me and my sister.’

With Mt. Lebanon in the double-bonus, all she had to do was make one of two from the stripe. And she missed the first.

“When the first one didn’t go, I was like ‘Oh my gosh,’ and I knew I had to make the second one,” Collins said. “As soon as that one left my hand, I knew it was in.”

For more than 28 minutes, it never looked like it would get to that point.

After Mt. Lebanon scored the first five points of the game, Chartiers Valley took over. The Colts tandem of Emma Reynolds and Turnbull, both of whom finished with 15, pressed the attack and kept the Blue Devils at bay.

Advertise with us

Chartiers Valley opened up a 21-13 lead with 5:19 left in the first half. The Blue Devils were befuddled by the Colts defense and committed 10 first-half turnovers and shot just 35 percent (7 of 20) from the floor. Mt. Lebanon looked like it would make a game of it in the third quarter when it went on a 6-0 run to cut its deficit to 30-24 with 2:12 left in the period. But Chartiers Valley countered with a 9-2 run to take a 39-25 lead with 6:38 remaining in regulation.

Keith Barnes: kbarnes.pg@gmail.com and Twitter @kbarnes_pghsprt