Picture a basketball rolling around the rim several times before falling out.
That’s the kind of misfortune Mt. Lebanon and Upper St. Clair have had in the WPIAL playoffs in recent seasons.
Close calls in their quests for WPIAL titles. Both have had quite a few. Entering this season, Mt. Lebanon had reached the WPIAL semifinals four of the past five seasons and had advanced to at least the quarterfinals eight of the past nine. Upper St. Clair reached the semifinals in 2020 and made it to the final last season.
But Mt. Lebanon hasn’t been to a final since winning its third title in four years back in 2012, and Upper St. Clair hasn’t won one since 2008.
The archrivals will have opportunities to end long title droughts Friday.
It will be an all-South Hills final when top seed Mt. Lebanon (22-1) takes on No. 3 Upper St. Clair (20-4) in the WPIAL Class 6A championship 7 p.m. at Petersen Events Center. Mt. Lebanon will try to add to its three titles and Upper St. Clair its six.
Read More
“I’m just really excited for this team and really excited for the players who have come before this team,” Mt. Lebanon coach Dori Oldaker said. “We’ve been knocking on the door for so many years.”
Upper St. Clair took down the giant known as North Allegheny in the semifinals, 46-42. North Allegheny was the two-time defending champion and had won titles four of the past five seasons. The Tigers had eliminated Upper St. Clair from the WPIAL playoffs each of the past four seasons, including a 70-36 defeat in the 2021 final.
“It’s really rewarding to be back,” said Upper St. Clair coach Pete Serio. “We’re in a very hard section. It’s been a tough year. Being able to beat NA was rewarding, and it’s been really rewarding to see how much these kids have grown up.”
Serio is in his eighth season at Upper St. Clair, but he also coached Mt. Lebanon for three seasons from 2000-03. His replacement? Oldaker, who is now in her 19th season.
Upper St. Clair and Mt. Lebanon are meeting in the WPIAL championship for the first time. The two have not met in the postseason since Mt. Lebanon beat Upper St. Clair in the 2012 WPIAL Class 4A playoffs.
But these teams know each other well due to them playing in the same section. They split a pair of regular-season meetings, with each team winning on the other’s home court. Mt. Lebanon claimed a 44-37 win on Jan. 17. Upper St. Clair then handed Mt. Lebanon its only loss of the season, 58-53, Feb. 10. Mt. Lebanon had to beat two other Section 2 foes, Peters Township and Bethel Park, to get to this game.
“I think it’s phenomenal for girls basketball to have a great championship between rival schools that know each other so well,” said Oldaker.
Speaking of phenomenal, Mt. Lebanon has a player who fits that description in senior guard and Saint Louis recruit Ashleigh Connor, a four-year starter and one of the WPIAL’s top scorers (21 points per game).
“They’re built on causing chaos with their defense and trying to make you uncomfortable,” Serio said. “We know that we have to be prepared for that. On top of that, they have the best player in the WPIAL. At times, she can put them on her back and take them wherever they want to go.”
Senior guard-forward Reagan Murdoch and freshman guard Payton Collins join Connor at Mt. Lebanon as players who regularly find themselves scoring in double figures.
One of Collins’ AAU teammates is Upper St. Clair freshman guard Rylee Kalocay, the star of the Panthers’ semifinal win. Kalocay, the sixth man, scored her team’s final nine points, including the winning basket with five seconds left.
Kalocay, along with junior forward Katelyn Robbins and junior guard Mia Brown, all average 13 points per game. With Robbins (6 feet 1), Brown (5-10) and senior forward Molly James (5-10), the Panthers aren’t short on height. Robbins’ mom, Kim (Seaver) Robbins, was a star player at Mt. Lebanon in the mid-90s.
“They’re loaded with talent,” Oldaker said. “They have so many scoring threats. They have great size, and they can finish on the inside and outside. It’s a really tough matchup.”
STARTING LINEUPS
Mt. Lebanon
4 Anna Streiff, 5-4, Jr., G
5 Gina Smith, 5-7, Jr., G
13 Brooke Collins, 5-9, Sr., G
15 Ashleigh Connor, 5-10, Sr., G
24 Reagan Murdoch, 5-9, Sr., G
Upper St. Clair
14 Sam Prunzik, 5-6, Jr., G
20 Paige Dellicarri, 5-6, Jr., G
22 Molly James, 5-10, Sr., F
42 Katelyn Robbins, 6-1, Jr., F
44 Mia Brown, 5-10, Jr., G
Brad Everett: beverett@post-gazette.com and Twitter @BREAL412.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.