There may have been a few more surprising WPIAL championship matchups than Shady Side Academy vs. Avonworth, but not many.

It’s one thing for a No. 3 seed and a No. 8 seed to meet at Petersen Events Center for the WPIAL Class 3A championship game at 5 p.m. Friday — but for these two programs? Nobody could have seen this coming.

Shady Side’s run to the title game is slightly more believable — after all, it finished last season 14-3 overall and took the eventual WPIAL champion Ellwood City to overtime in an 81-73 WPIAL quarterfinal defeat. Not only that, the Bulldogs returned every starter from last year’s team, including two promising freshmen — Eli Teslovich and Peter Kramer — who have blossomed into one of the most elite sophomore tandems in the WPIAL.

Still, it has been 21 years since Shady Side (18-6) last played for a WPIAL title, and 23 years since its only WPIAL championship victory in the 1999 Class 2A title game.

Advertise with us

“I don’t care what the seeds are — [Avonworth] is playing really, really well,” said Shady Side coach David Vadnais. “Seeds don’t matter. We thought we had a really good chance to make a run last year, and we lost in the quarters. And we didn’t want that to happen this year. So I know our guys won’t be taking them lightly.”

On the other hand, the Antelopes have absolutely no business being here — at least from a historical perspective.

Avonworth (18-6) used a dramatic second-half comeback to stun No. 5 seed South Allegheny in Monday night’s semifinal matchup, 46-43. That was after defeating top-seeded Ellwood City, 66-55, in the quarterfinal round. Now, the Antelopes will be playing in the WPIAL finals for the first time in 60 years.

“Last year was my first year and we said, 'Hey, how can we turn this thing around and how can we be where we want to be in the future,’ which is at ‘The Pete,’” said Avonworth coach Mike Mancuso. “We talked about a couple things, but one of them was 'Why not us?' We're in a great school district, we have a great community and we do a lot of really good things in other sports, so why not us?”

Last time Avonworth played for a WPIAL championship, the game took place at Pitt’s Fitzgerald Field House in front of 2,759 fans, with the Antelopes losing to Edgewood in the 1962 Class B final. Three years prior, Avonworth won its only WPIAL title in school history when it defeated McDonald, 77-63, in front of 2,480 fans. Dave Sauer had 22 points and 19 rebounds in the championship win.

Advertise with us

Mancuso is only in his second year as head coach, but he knows a thing or two about ending long championship droughts. He was the Antelopes’ defensive coordinator when the school won the 2019 WPIAL Class 2A championship for its first WPIAL football title in 60 years.

Now, Mancuso has the basketball program one win away from the proverbial mountaintop — and in order to get there, he’ll be largely relying on a talented freshman to finish the job.

Senior Jordan Kolenda leads Avonworth with an average of 19 points per game, but freshman Rowan Carmichael (16 ppg) has been turning heads all season, and he came up big again on Monday night. Carmichael scored a team-high 18 points in the comeback win to help punch his team’s ticket to “The Pete.”

"When you see a special talent, you sort of gravitate to it,” Mancuso said. “Not only personality-wise, but athletically. He's special and when you see that, I think kids have a tendency to deflect and trust him."

In order to take down a talented and hungry Shady Side team, though, the Antelopes will need to dig deep and rely on their slogan printed on their T-shirts this year — ”Earn it.”

Advertise with us

"We put on the back of shirts, 'Earn it.' We got up at 6 a.m. in the summer time to run hills,” Mancuso said. “Even in the season we've worked hard. But we just said, 'Hey, you have to earn it. No one is going to give it to us.'"

STARTING LINEUPS

Shady Side Academy

1 Rian Fitzgerald, 6-3, Sr., G

3 Eli Teslovich, 6-1, Soph., G

Advertise with us

4 Ethan Salvia, 5-11, Jr., G

21 Thompson Lau, 6-4, Sr., F

24 Peter Kramer, 6-4, Soph., G

Avonworth

2 Rowan Carmichael, 5-9, Fr., G

Advertise with us

3 Jordan Kalenda, 6-3, Sr., G

5 Colin Crawford, 6-1, Jr., G

10 David Kujawinski, 6-3, Sr., F

22 Peyton Faulkner, 6-4, Jr., C

Steve Rotstein: srotstein@post-gazette.com and Twitter @SteveRotstein.