Tim McConnell is entering his 29th season as a high school basketball coach, his fourth with the Chartiers Valley girls. McConnell has had many talented teams over the years, and has coached against lots of them, too.
But when it comes to an abundance of next-level talent on one team, McConnell can’t recall seeing a group like the one he has this season.
Chartiers Valley’s entire starting five — all seniors — have signed to play basketball at Division I or II schools, including three at the Division I level.
“To be honest with you, I haven’t seen anything like this,” McConnell said. “I’ve seen teams with two or three Division I players, but not five all going Division I or II.”
Chartiers Valley, which had its state-record 64-game win streak snapped last season, is looking to win its fourth consecutive WPIAL Class 5A title and its second PIAA title in four years. Considering the amount of talent the Colts possess, it probably wouldn’t be wise to bet against them.
The Fabulous 5 includes:
Read More
• Sharpshooting guard Aislin Malcolm, a Pitt recruit who is considered one of the top 100 seniors in the country. Malcolm was the state’s Class 5A Player of the Year last season.
• Guard-forward Perri Page, a Columbia recruit who like Malcolm was named to the Post-Gazette’s Fabulous 5 team last season. She was a second-team all-state pick as a junior.
• Guard Marian Turnbull, who will play at Northeastern. She will be eligible to participate in the playoffs this season after sitting out last postseason due to transfer rules.
• Guards Hallie and Helene Cowan, twins who are nearly inseparable and won’t even be separated in college. They have signed with Division II Seton Hill.
Oh, and the senior talent extends beyond those five, too. Sixth-man Abby Vaites, a guard who started in place of Turnbull during last year’s playoffs, plans on playing at a Division III school. Vaites said she is considering Westminster and Muskingum.
That’s six future college players on one team. Add all of them together, and it’s clear to see why this is one of the most talented teams — boys or girls — the WPIAL has seen in quite some time.
“It’s almost hard to believe,” Page said. “To have that amount of talent on one team, we’re so lucky.”
McConnell was well aware of the talent and potential this senior class had when he took over prior to the 2018-19 season, and said it became even more apparent when he watched them practice.
“This is a special group,” said McConnell, who has a record of 82-4 in his four seasons. “Coaching a group like this, it’s very special to me. I knew they had talent, but I didn’t know they worked as hard as they did. And that’s why they’re so successful.”
Another reason is unselfishness. Having all that talent is great, but there is only one ball to go around. Working together as a team and not worrying about personal accomplishments has been crucial. It helped these seniors go undefeated in both their freshman and sophomore seasons.
By season’s end, three of those players could be 1,000-point scorers. Malcolm (1,270 career points) is already there, while Page (819) and Hallie Cowan (726) are closing in on the milestone. Malcolm has a good shot of becoming the school’s all-time leading scorer. Mackenzie Wagner, a 2019 graduate, currently holds it with 1,670 points.
Malcolm is the only member of Chartiers Valley’s Fabulous 5 who has started all four years. Page and the twins joined her in the starting lineup their sophomore seasons. Malcolm, who is 5 feet 11, hit the court running her ninth grade season and hasn’t stopped. A terrific shooter, Malcolm has made 197 3-pointers in her career, including 65 last season when she averaged a team-high 16.8 points a game.
“Aislin is so talented,” Hallie Cowan said. “She can shoot from halfcourt and make six in a row. Playing with Aislin, I just always want to get her an open shot. When I pass it to her, it feels like it’s guaranteed to go in.”
McConnell has coached many outstanding shooters during his coaching career, one being his son, T.J., who plays with the NBA’s Indiana Pacers. So when he says Malcolm is one of the top shooters he’s ever coached, it holds a lot of weight.
“Boys or girls, she’s one of the top five. And she might be one of the top three,” McConnell said.
Like the rest of the bunch, Malcolm is a tremendous student as well. She carries a 4.9 GPA.
At 6 feet and ultra-athletic, Page is one of the toughest players to defend in the WPIAL. She can do damage inside and out, as she showed last season when she pumped in an average of 15 points, 11.3 rebounds and 3 steals a game. She had 18 points and 15 rebounds against Trinity in the WPIAL championship.
“She’s honestly the most athletic person I’ve ever seen,” said Malcolm. “The other day at practice, she dunked a tennis ball.”
Page has also dunked a volleyball in practice, and hopes to eventually dunk a basketball sometime this season. Her dad was pretty good at that in his playing days. Julius Page scored more than 1,500 points in his career at Pitt, when he was one of the top players in the Big East Conference. Perri credits her dad for molding her into the player she has become, but at the same time is happy that she has made a name for herself. Instead of “that’s Julius Page’s daughter,” it’s “that’s Perri Page.”
“I believe that I have [made a name for myself],” Perri said, “but I believe my name can become a lot bigger. I haven’t reached my full potential.”
Turnbull has athletic genes, too. Her mom, Mandy Yustak Turnbull, played college basketball at Wheeling Jesuit and is in the school’s athletic hall of fame. Marian played at Mt. Lebanon her freshman season. She then played at Episcopal High School in Virginia her sophomore season before coming to Chartiers Valley. An excellent ball-handler, Turnbull averaged 6.9 points and 3.9 assists a game a season ago.
“She’s really shifty,” Hallie Cowan said. “She can really break down the defense and kick it out to our shooters.”
Turnbull and Malcolm are particularly close, as they are first cousins. Their moms are sisters. Malcolm is older than Turnbull by just eight days.
“We are very close. And honestly, we can’t be separated,” said Malcolm. “We always try to convince people that we are twins.”
The Cowans don’t need to convince anybody of that. They literally are twins. If you don’t know them, they are difficult to tell apart. But get to know them, and their personalities are much different. Helene is the more outgoing of the two. She’s also the more scrappy one on the court and an excellent defender, while Hallie might not be far behind Malcolm when it comes to being the best shooter on the team. Hallie averaged 11.3 points a game and knocked down 54 3-pointers last season. Helene chipped in 8.5 points and 5.2 rebounds.
“Hallie is more of a shooter, and Helene plays more of the scrappy, underdog role,” said Page.
Off the court, the Cowans do basically everything together.
“We’re very close,” Hallie said. “We have the same friends and all the same hobbies.”
The two have always talked about playing together in college, a dream which next season will become reality. McConnell said both are good enough to play Division I, but said the fact that they wanted to play together made that tough.
Next season, the twins won’t be playing for a McConnell. Instead, they’ll be playing against one. Seton Hill is in the same conference as IUP, which is coached by Tim McConnell’s brother, Tom.
“They’re a steal for Seton Hill,” Tim McConnell said. “I feel bad for my brother because he’ll have to play against them every year.”
Vaites gives Chartiers Valley a veteran presence off the bench, one who started seven playoff games last season. She averaged 3.7 points and 3.6 rebounds and was third on the team with 29 3-pointers.
“She’s such a team player,” McConnell said. “She never says, ‘What about me?’ She was going to start last season, but then Marian came in. [Abby] never pouted. She accepted her role, and I commend her for that. She really helped us win that WPIAL title.”
This senior class now hopes to go 4 for 4 when it comes to winning WPIAL championships. They would also like to get back to Hershey for the PIAA final after losing to Philadelphia Catholic League power Cardinal O’Hara in last year’s title game.
Sparked by its own Fab 5, you have got to like Chartiers Valley’s chances.
“This is our last go-around,” said Page. “We can’t hold back. Last year was a total fluke. No one expected that to happen. We know it will be different this time.”
Brad Everett: beverett@post-gazette.com and Twitter: @BREAL412.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.