Paige Morningstar proved time and time again to be a big-time talent in her four years at North Allegheny.
Call her a “North Star.”
There were all-section, all-WPIAL and all-state honors. State player of the year recognition, too. MaxPreps even named her its national high school female athlete of the year a few weeks ago.
But for this teen from Franklin Park, personal accolades were never a priority.
Morningstar was team-first all the way, her biggest goal being to go 4-for-4 in a school year by winning WPIAL and PIAA volleyball titles and WPIAL and PIAA basketball titles.
During her senior year, Morningstar accomplished the lofty goal. That combined with her performance on the court in both sports has earned her Post-Gazette Female Athlete of the Year honors. The award takes into consideration all WPIAL and City League athletes.
Read More
“It couldn’t have gotten any better,” Morningstar said. “My goal every year was 4-for-4. To do it my last year was really special.”
“Special,” “great teammate,” and “a winner” are words used to describe Morningstar by her high school coaches, Heidi Miller (volleyball) and Spencer Stefko (basketball). Those two witnessed first-hand the unique ability of an athlete who helped North Allegheny reach great heights in her career.
Consider these accomplishments:
• In her four years, Morningstar won five PIAA titles (four volleyball, one basketball) and six WPIAL titles (three in each sport). Her teams compiled a ridiculous overall record of 191-9 (95%). The volleyball team went 88-1 and the basketball squad 103-8.
• Those teams combined to go 45-1 during Morningstar’s senior year — 18-0 in volleyball and 27-1 in basketball. The only loss was a non-section setback to Trinity in basketball.
• In volleyball her senior year, Morningstar was selected Post-Gazette Player of the Year and Gatorade Pennsylvania Player of the Year. In basketball, she was a third-team all-state pick in Class 6A, the state’s largest class.
Volleyball is Morningstar’s top sport and she’s headed to play at Louisville, both of which might come as a surprise considering her dad, Darren, was a standout basketball player at Pitt who was taken in the NBA draft (1992) before playing in that league and then internationally.
But the youngest of Darren and Kim Morningstar’s three children followed in the footsteps of the oldest. Meg Morningstar was an outstanding volleyball player herself, capturing Gatorade Pennsylvania Player of the Year honors her senior season at North Allegheny before going on to be a four-year starter at Notre Dame.
“Before Meg picked up a volleyball, none of us knew anything about it,” said Paige, who will major in business at Louisville. “When she committed to Notre Dame, she showed me [making it in that sport] was possible.”
Like her sisters, Paige (6 feet tall) was blessed with great size. That height and her special skillset helped her stand out in volleyball, and she jumped into North Allegheny’s starting lineup her sophomore year. As a senior, the standout setter led the Tigers in assists. She collected 42 against Shaler in the WPIAL championship and 30 against Unionville in the PIAA championship.
“The position that she’s in forced her to be the captain, a quarterback type of role,” Miller said. “I think she’s been playing the game at a high level. She has a great awareness on how to distribute the ball quickly. Her size allows her to be offensive. Not all setters can do that.”
North Allegheny became just the third school in PIAA history to win four consecutive titles.
Miller, who stepped down after the 2020 season, had at least one Morningstar on her team each of her nine seasons as head coach. Piper, the middle sister, also played for the Tigers and is now playing basketball at Washington & Jefferson.
Even though volleyball is Paige’s No. 1 sport, she’s an outstanding basketball player, as well. And as great as it felt to win her fourth PIAA volleyball championship in a row, it wasn’t her most memorable moment of her senior year.
“The highlight was the state championship for basketball because it was the first in the history of the school,” she said. “It put me up a notch for my resume in my senior year, and I got to do it with Lizzy.”
Lizzy Groetsch was one of the top senior basketball players in the state, and she and Morningstar are best friends. Groetsch, the Post-Gazette Player of the Year and state player of the year in Class 6A, will continue her career at Penn this fall.
Playing on a team with Groetsch and talented sophomore Jasmine Timmerson, Morningstar wasn’t expected to produce big point totals night in and night out. Stefko described her as a Swiss army knife who made an impact doing everything from defending any position on the floor to grabbing rebounds and setting traps.
“She understood her role,” Stefko said. “She didn’t have a problem being Robin to their Batman.”
A two-year starter, Morningstar averaged 11 points and 5.8 rebounds her senior season and came up with some of her best performances in the biggest games. She scored 16 points against Upper St. Clair in the WPIAL championship, 14 against Cumberland Valley in the PIAA semifinals, and 16 against previously undefeated Spring-Ford in the PIAA championship.
“Best teammate in the world and completely selfless, but still supremely confident,” Stefko said.
When taking into account Morningstar’s talents and penchant for winning, it’s no wonder she caught the eye of Louisville women’s volleyball coach Dani Busboom Kelly, who guided the Cardinals to an ACC title and Sweet 16 berth last season.
“One thing that’s always stuck out to me about Paige is her leadership,” Kelly said. “I love the way she plays and competes and I’m excited for her to be in our program. We love to recruit proven winners. Developing a winning mentality is very important, no matter what level. We want athletes that have high expectations for our program and I know Paige does. I believe Paige can have a very successful career here at Louisville.”
She certainly had an unforgettable one at North Allegheny.
Brad Everett: beverett@post-gazette.com and Twitter: @BREAL412.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.