Spencer Stefko talks a lot about culture.

He teaches World Cultures to 10th graders at North Allegheny High School.

He has also helped build a culture of winning with the Tigers’ girls basketball team — one he credits predecessor Sherri McConnell for creating — which he has guided to a tremendous amount of success in his five seasons as coach.

This season, Stefko produced one of his finest coaching performances yet, leading a team that started four underclassmen and had just three seniors to a WPIAL Class 6A championship, the program’s third title in four seasons. The Tigers were 24-3 and had advanced to the PIAA quarterfinals before the COVID-19 pandemic halted the season in mid-March.

Advertise with us

For his efforts, Stefko is the Post-Gazette Coach of the Year. The award takes into consideration all coaches in the WPIAL and City League.

“We were super young at the beginning of the year,” Stefko said. “But this goes back to the culture. The kids are super respectful of each other. They worry about what they can do to get medals, not bickering about four minutes of playing time in December. Yeah, we were young, but I don’t think we were young when it mattered.”

Having Stefko at the helm undoubtedly played a big part. Few coaches in the WPIAL win like the 43-year-old who studied pre-law at Notre Dame. He has won 90% of his games at North Allegheny, leading the Tigers to a 129-14 record. In 14 seasons overall, he’s 316-77 — good for a winning percentage of .804 — has guided his teams to the playoffs each of those seasons, claimed 11 section titles, in addition to capturing five WPIAL titles and a PIAA title.

Oh, and then there’s this: Stefko has led teams to the WPIAL final eight years in a row. The only other girls coach to do that was the legendary Don Barth, who helped North Catholic reach the title game 18 consecutive times from 1979-1996. Stefko’s eight trips have come at three schools: One at Chartiers Valley, two at Seton LaSalle and five at North Allegheny.

What does that say about Stefko?

Advertise with us

“I think it sounds like I can’t hold a job because I’ve been at three different schools,” Stefko said, tongue-in-cheek.

North Allegheny was expected to be good this season, but winning a WPIAL title was far from a given, especially after graduating three starters, one of them being Post-Gazette Athlete of the Year Rachel Martindale.

Senior Kat Balouris and junior Lizzy Groetsch started a season ago, giving Stefko a solid nucleus. But he also knew he would need players such as junior Paige Morningstar and sophomores Taylor Rawls and Emma Fischer to thrive in bigger roles. Having promising freshman Jasmine Timmerson adjust to varsity basketball quickly would be huge, too.

“Honestly, coming in, the only thing we knew for sure was Kat Balouris. We knew we’d get a ton of minutes from her, and a ton of leadership and a ton of grit,” said Stefko. “But that was the only on-court known quantity. How do you replace seven kids who graduated, four of them rotation players?”

Getting a huge season from Groetsch was gigantic. A 5-foot-11 combo guard and Penn recruit, Groetsch averaged 17.4 points, 7.7 rebounds and 4.1 assists per game on her way to Post-Gazette Player of the Year honors. She made the winning basket late in overtime to help the Tigers beat Bethel Park, 54-50, in the WPIAL championship.

Advertise with us

Just as Stefko expected, Balouris had a strong senior season, and the Tigers also saw important contributions from the team’s other two seniors, Abby Glass and Maddie Chevalier. Morningstar, Rawls and Fischer took their game up a notch, and by the time the playoffs came around, you wouldn’t have guessed Timmerson was just a freshman.

Of course, Stefko doesn’t do all of the coaching alone. Assistants Eric and Rebecca Braithwaite have been by his side since his days at Chartiers Valley.

“We’ve been really blessed with really great longtime assistants,” Stefko said. “The kids have as much confidence in Eric Braithwaite and Rebecca Braithwaite as they do in me, sometimes more. I’ve been with them since Chartiers Valley, and they round out the places where I’m lacking.”

Stefko is a 1995 Vincentian graduate. He started on the basketball team, describing himself as a “mucker and a grinder.” By the time he got to Notre Dame, Stefko knew he wanted to pursue coaching. He’d help out at camps, saying it was the week or two of the summer he looked forward to most.

Stefko continued to cut his coaching teeth at an all-boys prep school near Detroit before returning to Western Pennsylvania to earn his master’s degree from Duquesne. He spent a number of years as an assistant coach. Among those he credits molding him are late Shaler coach Howie Rupert and Hampton’s Joe Lafko.

Advertise with us

In 2006, Stefko got his first shot as a head coach, and guided the Chartiers Valley girls to a 13-12 record. In his second season, he led the Colts to the WPIAL semifinals. He compiled a 137-51 record in seven seasons.

Stefko spent two years with the Seton LaSalle girls, guiding the Rebels to two WPIAL titles, a PIAA title and a PIAA runner-up finish before taking over at North Allegheny in 2015 after McConnell resigned in order to spend more time with her family after a successful eight-year run.

“I could have stayed at Seton LaSalle for another 35 years, but the opportunity to be closer to my family was important, and this is a really great job with really great people,” said Stefko, who lives in McCandless.

Stefko has also been a coach with the Western Pa. Bruins AAU program for the past 18 years.

Despite his extended success, Stefko doesn’t believe much of it has to do with coaching ability.

Advertise with us

“Everything has fallen into place. I’m a really lucky guy,” he said. “If the basketball gods even things out, I’m in trouble over the next 15 years. No one should have the level of luck and talent that I’ve been blessed with, even with this year’s team.”

Brad Everett: beverett@post-gazette.com and Twitter: @BREAL412.