In the first 46 years of PIAA girls basketball championships, only three teams managed to complete an undefeated season while capturing both WPIAL and PIAA titles.
In 2019, two teams accomplished the extraordinary feat on back-to-back nights — Peters Township in Class 6A and Chartiers Valley in Class 5A. So could the Post-Gazette pick between one or the other as the 2018-19 girls Team of the Year? Of course not.
Despite going 30-0 in the state’s highest classification and finishing the season ranked No. 24 in USA Today’s national rankings — all while bringing Peters Township its first WPIAL and PIAA title in girls basketball — Indians coach Bert Kendall was perfectly fine sharing the distinction with the Colts.
“They run such a great program over there,” Kendall said. “[Chartiers Valley] is a great basketball team. You can’t be selfish like that. We did what we did, they did what they did, and both teams deserve all the credit they received.
“You’ve got to share it. There’s no other way. That’s the way it is.”
For Chartiers Valley coach Tim McConnell, who won six WPIAL titles in 25 years as the school’s boys coach but came up short in two previous trips to the PIAA championship game, making the switch to the girls game turned out to be a better decision than he ever could have imagined.
Read More
“It’s something I think about every day,” McConnell said about going undefeated. “I think it’s pretty amazing what these girls did and how they came to play every night. It just wasn’t one night that they took off. Usually when you have a team, you can expect one or two nights when they’re not ready to play, and that was not the case.”
Having coached both of his sons to WPIAL titles, McConnell has now coached all three of his children to WPIAL titles. He achieved that feat and crossed one more off his bucket list in his first year with his daughter, Megan, as his starting point guard.
“It was special,” Tim McConnell said. “I’m very goal-oriented, and one of my goals was to win a state title. And to have my daughter be a part of it and help win it made it that much more special.”
Megan McConnell averaged 10.9 points, 4.3 assists and 2.8 steals per game as a junior — receiving first-team all-state honors in the process — and she’ll be back to run the offense once again for the Colts next season. But she’ll have to do so without the help of Post-Gazette Fab 5 selection and fellow all-state honoree Mackenzie Wagner, Chartiers Valley’s leading scorer from last season who averaged 16 points, 5.7 rebounds and 1.5 steals per game.
“Mackenzie had a special year,” McConnell said. “We knew she was a really good scorer, but she really came out and defended. She just played a total game. We’re definitely going to need someone to step up like her.”
Meanwhile, Peters Township will have even bigger shoes to fill next season as it tries to account for the graduation of one of the best guards in WPIAL history, Makenna Marisa.
Marisa is a two-time Post Gazette Player of the Year, 2019 Pennsylvania Class 6A Player of the Year and a certified stat-sheet-stuffer. She averaged 20.8 points, 6.1 rebounds, 4.3 assists, 2.6 steals, and 1 block per game while shooting 53 percent from the field, 42 percent from 3-point range and 87 percent from the free-throw line.
“You’ve really got to have a top player if you’re going to have an undefeated season, because there are occasions where things aren’t going right where a top player will bail you out of a situation,” Kendall said. “There’s no doubt that having the player of the year on our team certainly aided us in the undefeated season.”
Marisa and fellow senior Isabella Mills, who averaged 13.8 points, 5.8 rebounds, 5 assists and 1.5 steals per game and earned second-team all-state honors, made for one of the WPIAL’s most lethal scoring tandems in quite some time.
Incredibly, 27 of the Indians’ 30 wins came by double digits, while the Colts won by 10 or more in 26 of their 30 victories. But while their teams appeared to be unstoppable 9 times out of 10, it’s in the rare moments of vulnerability they faced where the coaches learned the most about their players.
“I just remember we’re at [Thomas Jefferson] and it’s a rivalry game, they’re really good, and with two minutes to go, we’re down five. When we came back and won that game, it just showed me a lot of character in our girls,” McConnell said. “Our Oakland Catholic game in the state playoffs, we were down six, and they were playing really well, and we came back and won that game. There were just some key games that really put us over the top.”
Kendall, meanwhile, has fond memories of the way his team responded to adversity in winning three overtime games, none bigger than the 43-40 win against North Allegheny in the WPIAL championship thanks to rising senior Mackenzie Lehman’s late-game heroics. And although his team had to share the spotlight with Chartiers Valley back in March, he knows there’s plenty of room for both legendary teams in WPIAL basketball lore.
“At the end of the day, girls basketball in Western Pennsylvania was represented at the highest level,” Kendall said. “We’ll both be in the record books forever, right?”
Steve Rotstein: srotstein@post-gazette.com and Twitter @SteveRotstein.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.