When the PIAA basketball playoffs started, the field included 46 WPIAL boys and girls teams that didn’t make it to the WPIAL championships. History indicated those teams had little chance of making it to a PIAA final, especially on the girls side.
An examination of championship games shows the best way to make it to a state title game is to travel through the WPIAL finals. And it is much harder for a girls team to make it to a PIAA title game without playing for a WPIAL championship first.
The PIAA boys championships have been around since 1920 and the girls championships since 1973. But the PIAA only took one or two WPIAL teams to the PIAA playoffs until 1972. Consider these numbers:
• Ninety-five WPIAL boys teams have made it to a PIAA title game since 1972, and only 27 percent (26 teams) did not play for a WPIAL title.
• Seventy-five WPIAL girls teams have made it to PIAA title games, and only 11 percent (eight teams) did not play for WPIAL championships.
• Only 11 WPIAL boys teams have won state championships without making it to a WPIAL title game.
Read More
• Only three teams in the history of WPIAL girls basketball have won a PIAA championship without making a WPIAL title game. Brentwood did it in 1982, Upper St. Clair in 1999 and Mars last year. All three lost in the WPIAL semifinals.
• Five WPIAL boys teams have made it to a PIAA title game after losing in the WPIAL quarterfinals. They are Greensburg Salem (2009), Penn Hills (2004), Aliquippa (1989), Hampton (1984) and Valley (1979). Penn Hills, Aliquippa and Valley all won PIAA titles.
• No WPIAL girls team has ever lost in the quarterfinals and then made it to a PIAA championship.
What do all the numbers say? One thing is it takes a special team to get over a loss in the WPIAL semifinals or quarterfinals and come back to win a state championship. Never mind whether a team has enough talent to accomplish such a feat, it can be hard for a team to rebound mentally after a loss in the WPIAL quarterfinals or semifinals.
The previous boys team to win a state title without getting to a WPIAL championship was South Fayette in 2010. The Lions lost in the WPIAL semifinals to North Catholic, but came back and beat Strawberry Mansion in the PIAA Class 2A final.
South Fayette’s coach then was Rich Bonnaure, and he remembers the way he got his team to rebound mentally from the WPIAL semifinal loss.
“I could’ve written a book on that year,” said Bonnaure. “The first practice after we lost in the WPIAL, the players got dressed, got taped and were warming up on the court. I called them all into the locker room. They knew if they got called to the locker room before practice that something was wrong. All I said was, ‘You guys did it this time.’
“Honest to God, two of them started confessing to something. I said, ‘Just stop. You seniors get up and pick teams. We’re going bowling.’ So right from there we took them bowling and we never lost again.”
But it’s not like South Fayette was a mediocre team that won a PIAA title.
“We played so bad in the [WPIAL] semifinals and just lost,” said Bonnaure. “But I knew that group was good enough to still win something.”
Bonnaure resigned at South Fayette a few years ago, but still follows WPIAL basketball. He believes it is harder for any WPIAL team to win a PIAA final now because of the addition of the Philadelphia Public and Catholic League teams.
The Mars girls shocked many last year in winning a WPIAL title. The Planets lost to Oakland Catholic in the WPIAL semifinals.
“My kids biggest hangup has been Oakland Catholic,” said Mars coach Dana Petruska. “If we would’ve ran into Oakland Catholic again last year in the PIAA playoffs, I’m not so sure we would’ve been able to beat them.”
Petruska gave her team a week off after losing in the WPIAL semifinals. After last year’s experience, Petruska believes a team’s attitude is key to coming back from a WPIAL loss. And it helps to have a special player who leads with a special attitude. Mars had that last year in senior Lauren Wasylson, who averaged 7.1 points a game this season as a freshman at Xavier University.
“Wasylson just wasn’t ready to move on yet. She was ready to finish and finish big,” said Petruska. “I think she was very instrumental in our practices and every game.”
Petruska acknowledges that players like Wasylson don’t come around often. But neither do teams like Mars and South Fayette.
Mike White: mwhite@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mwhiteburgh

BOYS STANDINGS: WPIAL | City League
Team Pages | Schedules and results
GIRLS STANDINGS: WPIAL | City League




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.