During the week leading up to Saturday’s game, Canon-McMillan coach Rick Bell kept telling his team the magic number to beat Allderdice was 55.

Bell had noticed that Allderdice was 19-1 when scoring above 55 points, but only 2-4 when held to 55 or less.

Canon-McMillan kept Allderdice below 55 in regulation. But the Dragons got an extra four minutes, and that’s when Allderdice showed some of its postseason magic.

Allderdice, the six-time City League champion, needed overtime before defeating Canon-McMillan, 61-58, in a PIAA Class 6A first-round game at Mt. Lebanon High School.

Advertise with us

Canon-McMillan (16-10), the No. 3 team from the WPIAL, took a 53-50 lead with 1:18 left in the game, but Allderdice (22-5) came back and tied the game at 53 after regulation. Allderdice had the final shot in the fourth quarter, but a 3-pointer by Bobby Clifford missed. Allderdice opened up a five-point lead in overtime with 40 seconds left and Canon-McMillan couldn’t recover.

Allderdice beat Canon-McMillan, 61-58, in PIAA playoffs

This was Allderdice’s sixth PIAA playoff game in the past three years. This was Canon-McMillan’s third in school history. The Big Macs have yet to win a PIAA game.

“Most of our victories have been by double digits,” Allderdice coach Buddy Valinsky said. “So, for our team, it really was a good victory in that aspect because we had to foul, we had to make some free throws and we had to change defenses. For our kids, it’s significant to win a close one.”

Allderdice survived a 3-point fest by the smaller Big Macs. Canon-McMillan took 46 shots for the game, and 34 were 3-pointers. The Big Macs made 12 behind the arc, and Ethan Beachy, a 6-foot-3 forward, made six 3-pointers and scored 20 points.

Valinsky acknowledged the difference in the game was Dalen Dugger, a 6-foot-7 senior who didn’t even play basketball a year ago. Dugger, who averages 12 a game, had 27 points and 11 rebounds. He made 12 of 14 shots – none farther than 8 feet.

Advertise with us

Allderdice needed Dugger because leading scorer Jackson Blaufeld (18 ppg) scored only four points and took three shots. Canon-McMillan played a box-and-one defense on Blaufeld, a 6-3 guard, and it was rare when Blaufeld touched the ball, let alone shot.

But Dugger dug in, consistently getting the ball in the lane in excellent position to score. Bobby Clifford, an Allderdice senior guard who also averages 18, scored 11.

“You have to pick your poison with them,” Canon-McMillan coach Rick Bell said. “The big kid hurt us, but I wouldn’t want the kids averaging almost 20 a game to beat us. Our tallest guy is 6-3, so [Dugger] was just going over top of him. But still, we had a chance to win the game.”

Leading 53-52, Canon-McMillan’s Louis Waller missed the front end of a one-and-one with 52 seconds left. Clifford made one of two free throws to tie it with 32 seconds remaining. Canon-McMillan was working for the last shot, but turned the ball over with 7.3 seconds left.

With 12.8 seconds remaining in OT and Allderdice holding a 61-58 lead, Clifford missed the back end of a two-shot foul. Beachy missed a long 3-pointer past the top of the key, Canon-McMillan rebounded, but Thomas Samosky had to throw up a prayer near half court that was nowhere close to the basket.

Advertise with us

“Canon-Mac is very underrated,” Clifford said. “If they’re off on their shots, you’ll beat them by 15 or 20. But if they’re on, they’re tough as anyone to beat. They were on this game.”

Mike White: mwhite@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mwhiteburgh