Imagine one of the most successful coaches in the history of WPIAL boys basketball all of a sudden becoming the girls coach at the same school. It could happen with Tim McConnell and Chartiers Valley.
In a coaching move that would drop jaws around the Western Pennsylvania high school sports world, McConnell could be named Chartiers Valley’s girls coach Tuesday night. McConnell, who has won six WPIAL titles and more than 500 games, is one of two finalists for the job along with girls assistant coach Jordan Burkes. McConnell had a second interview Monday with Chartiers Valley School District superintendent Johannah Vanatta and assistant superintendent Scott Seltzer.
“I did interview and I was told they were going to make a recommendation [Tuesday] night, but I don’t know who it’s going to be,” said McConnell.
McConnell declined further comment on the situation because of the school board meeting.
Seltzer would only say, “We will make a recommendation to the board, but it’s up to the board. You never know.”
A natural question is why would McConnell give up the boys job to go for the girls position when he has been ultra-successful with the boys? McConnell again said he preferred not to comment until the school board makes a decision.
Read More
But McConnell’s daughter, Megan, will be a junior on the Chartiers Valley girls team. She is one of the top junior guards in the WPIAL and made all-state as a sophomore. Her father coached his two sons on the boys team — T.J. and Matty. Tim McConnell won WPIAL championships with each of his sons. T.J., a 2010 graduate, now plays for the NBA’s Philadelphia 76ers while Matty, a 2015 Chartiers Valley graduate, plays for Robert Morris.
Tim McConnell, though, has experience training girls players. He does individual training on the side with boys and girls. Over the years, he has trained a number top WPIAL girls players. Makenna Marisa, a standout senior guard at Peters Township who was the Post-Gazette Player of the Year in 2018, trains with McConnell. Heck, go back almost three decades and he trained his sister, Suzie, when she was trying to make the U.S. Olympic women’s team for the second time.
Still, many are surprised that Tim McConnell would be the Chartiers Valley girls coach. When told that McConnell was a finalist for the girls job, but possibly might not get it, one successful WPIAL boys coach said Monday, “Why, who else applied, Geno Auriemma?”
With the job McConnell, 54, has done with the Chartiers Valley boys, you could make a case for him being one of the most successful coaches of any sport in WPIAL history. He won 500 games in only 22 seasons, faster than any boys coach in league history. His record in 25 seasons is 552-146 (.791 percentage) and his six WPIAL titles ties him for fourth behind only three legends — Farrell’s Ed McCluskey (11), Blackhawk’s John Miller (8) and Midland’s Ed Olkowski (8). He has been selected the Post-Gazette coach of the year twice (2001 and 2010).
McConnell made the WPIAL playoffs in every one of his first 24 seasons as coach. But this past season, Chartiers Valley finished 8-14 and missed the postseason for the first time under McConnell.
Mike White: mwhite@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mwhiteburgh.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.