The Allderdice Dragons boys basketball team has been the torch bearer of the City League for the past few years. Hey, Dragons are supposed to breathe fire anyway, right?
But Westinghouse and Carrick made the flame much bigger this season.
It was a banner year for City League basketball. This isn’t to suggest the City League is comparable to its heyday in the 1960s and ’70s, but it has been almost two decades since the City League shined so brightly in Western Pennsylvania. Allderdice, Westinghouse and Carrick all made it to the second round of the PIAA boys playoffs in different classifications. The previous time three City League teams advanced to the second round was 2003 when Allderdice, Oliver and Perry made it to the sweet 16s.
What the Allderdice, Westinghouse and Carrick basketball teams accomplished this season brings about a perplexing question. It’s no secret that City League sports teams generally have, with a few exceptions, struggled to compete against WPIAL teams more than ever in the past decade. Except in boys basketball. So, while a number of the six City League sports teams struggle to survive outside their boundaries, why did City League boys basketball teams thrive this season?
Carrick won a PIAA game for the first time in 25 years and made it to the second round for the first time since 1990. Westinghouse made it to the second round for the first time since 1999. And Allderdice hasn’t done well only this season. The Dragons made the PIAA semifinals in 2015, the title game in 2016, the second round last year and will play in the quarterfinals Saturday.
There is an opinion that success in boys basketball is simply a matter of tradition. The City League has always been known for basketball. In the 1960s and ’70s, the City was a mecca for great teams and great players. From 1966-78, Schenley won four PIAA titles, Fifth Avenue one and Peabody lost in a championship. Those teams had legendary players such as Kenny Durrett and Maurice Lucas at Schenley, Sam Clancy at Fifth Avenue and Melvin Bennett at Peabody. A few of those teams are considered among the greatest in Western Pa. history. But Schenley, Fifth Avenue and Peabody of those schools are not even in existence any longer.
“I think it’s just a case of you need fewer players to be successful in basketball, opposed to baseball where you need nine, and in football you need 11 or more,” said Buddy Valinsky, Allderdice’s basketball coach.
City League football teams, most notably Perry, used to be extremely competitive in the PIAA playoffs. Perry, under coach Gus Catanese, won a PIAA championship in 1989 and made it to a PIAA title game in 1997. But lately, City football has struggled against outside competition.
“All I know is that, in general, the sport of basketball has gone down in Western Pennsylvania over the years, but the City League is able to hold its head above water sometimes by just getting two or three players and being competitive,” said Valinsky.
Mike Gavlik, City League director of athletics, believes a reason basketball teams are successful is because basketball is one of the few sports in the City League that has a pseudo “feeder” system.
“We still have 22 schools with middle school [grades 6-8] basketball teams. That means something,” said Gavlik.
The additions of two classifications in Pennsylvania basketball might also have helped teams such as Westinghouse or Carrick. With only four classifications in the past, a City League team might have been playing a school in the PIAA playoffs that was much larger in terms on enrollment.
“Now, teams are in ‘truer’ classifications, playing schools their own size and there is a benefit to that,” said Gavlik.
Others are of the opinion that City League basketball has been successful also because it’s a cultural thing. Basketball is big in many inner cities around the country, although Pittsburgh doesn’t produce as many Division I college players nowadays as other cities similar in size.
“It’s still the favorite sport among kids to go out and play,” said Valinsky. “It’s an easy game to practice. You don’t need a lot of equipment. All it takes is a big man here and there. Maybe a guard and a big man.”
But maybe coaching has something to do with the success of these City League boys basketball teams. It sometimes is not easy to coach in the City League, for various factors that suburban schools don’t have to deal with. Valinsky has been extremely successful in his years at Allderdice. The comment that he simply “throws the balls out” and lets Allderdice play is hogwash. Valinsky was the Post-Gazette coach of the year in 2016.
Eugene Wilson has been tremendous for Westinghouse’s program since coming over from Wilkinsburg before the start of the 2016-17 season. He has tried to make an impact on the court, but also for players off the court.
Walt Milinski has been Carrick’s coach for two decades. In the offseason, it’s not uncommon for Milinski to drive all over, picking up numerous players in different locations in a van, just to play in spring or summer-league basketball games against a WPIAL team. Carey White has done similar things as Brashear’s coach, but just hasn’t had much talent in recent years.
Whatever the reason is for the City League’s success in boys basketball, it only enhances Western Pennsylvania high school basketball in general.
“This season has been a very positive thing for the City League,” said Gavlik, “and Pittsburgh Public Schools in general.”
Mike White: mwhite@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mwhiteburgh.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.