Which teams should get the top four seeds for the WPIAL Class 6A playoffs?
That seems to be the biggest question in the WPIAL. The WPIAL will announce playoff pairings and seedings Tuesday night and the tournament begins Friday.
So, let’s play “bracketology.” Central Catholic, Woodland Hills and Mt. Lebanon are the three section champions in Class 6A. So you would imagine one of them will get the No. 1 seed. But which one? You can make points for all three. You can also poke some holes in all three. Then what do you do with Pine-Richland, a two-time defending champ that has had a healthy team for only about two weeks? Then there is Fox Chapel, who might be playing as well as anyone in Class 6A.
The fact is Class 6A doesn’t have a dominant, excellent team. But there are plenty of good teams. Is it parity? Or is it simply Class 6A lacking a really good team? It’s probably a little of both. But it’s hard to remember the largest classification of the WPIAL having so many decent teams, especially because many of the other classifications are watered down since the advent of six classes.
I’d say this about Class 6A: Eight or nine teams have a legitimate chance at making a run and getting to the championship. However, I could also see any of those same eight or nine teams losing in the quarterfinals. And I put the top seeds in that group.
The WPIAL basketball committee is meeting today and tomorrow to decide pairings and seedings. I can save them some work. Here is how the brackets should look:
Read More
CLASS 6A
Byes: Central Catholic, Woodland Hills, Mt. Lebanon, Pine-Richland
Matchups: Canon-McMillan (8) vs. Seneca Valley (9), winner to play Central Catholic (1); Fox Chapel (5) vs. Upper St. Clair (12), winner to play Pine-Richland (4); Butler (7) vs. Latrobe (10), winner to play Woodland Hills (2); Penn Hills (6) vs. Bethel Park (11), winner to play Mt. Lebanon (3).
The scoop: Picking the top seed from Central Catholic, Mt. Lebanon and Woodland Hills was next to impossible. I’ve seen all three and honestly can say I really don’t have an overwhelming feeling about any of the three as No. 1. It’s not that they aren’t good teams. But it’s hard to pick one of the three. They all have different styles. I went with Central Catholic as the No. 1 seed. But if I had to pick a winner for 6A right now, I’d go with Pine-Richland. The Rams have had everyone back for a little more than two weeks and I think they are the best overall team. Fox Chapel might be playing as well as anyone, but the Foxes still didn’t win their section. Canon-McMillan’s loss to Baldwin cost the Big Macs a possible top four seed and moved them to No. 8.
CLASS 5A
Byes: Mars, Franklin Regional, Highlands.
Matchups: Gateway (8) vs. Laurel Highlands (9), winner plays Mars (1); West Allegheny (7) vs. Albert Gallatin (10), winner plays Franklin Regional (2); Trinity (6) vs. Hampton (11), winner plays Highlands (3); Moon (5) vs. Greensburg Salem (12); McKeesport (4) vs. Armstrong (13).
The scoop: Franklin Regional’s non-section victory against McKeesport Friday was key. It solidified Franklin Regional and Highlands as the No. 2 and 3 seeds. Franklin Regional and Highlands tied for a section championship and split two meetings. McKeesport is seeded No. 4. Moon’s loss to Montour Friday was costly. It might have cost the Tigers a No. 2 seed. After all, Moon has victories against Mars and Franklin Regional. Trinity might be deserving of a better seed than No. 6. After all, Trinity beat Moon in a non-section game. But you can’t get around the fact that Trinity finished second to McKeesport in section play.
CLASS 4A
Byes: Quaker Valley, New Castle, Belle Vernon, Indiana
Matchups: Valley (8) vs. South Park (9), winner plays Quaker Valley (1); Central Valley (5) vs. Deer Lakes (12), winner plays Indiana (4); South Fayette (7) vs. Freeport (10), winner plays New Castle (2); Ambridge (6) vs. Uniontown (11), winner plays Belle Vernon (3).
The scoop: The biggest questions in this class are where to seed the No. 2, 3 and 4 teams from Section 2, and where do you place section champs Belle Vernon and Indiana? Section 2, which includes Quaker Valley, is unquestionably the best section in 4A, but not as strong as last year when the WPIAL made the top four teams the first four seeds. Belle Vernon and Indiana are section champs, but their sections (especially Indiana’s) are not as strong as Section 2. So should Indiana be seeded higher than the second- or third-place team from Section 2?
CLASS 3A
Byes: No byes because this is a 17-team bracket. There will be one preliminary-round game.
Matchups: Brownsville (17) vs. Carlynton (16) in preliminary-round, winner plays Lincoln Park (1); East Allegheny (8) vs. Burgettstown (9); Aliquippa (4) vs. South Side Beaver (13); Burrell (5) vs. Avonworth (12); Washington (3) vs. Brentwood (14); Cardinal Wuerl North Catholic (6) vs. Riverside (11); Shady Side Academy (7) vs. Ellwood City (10); Seton LaSalle (2) vs. South Allegheny (15).
The scoop: One of the biggest questions is where to put Burrell, Shady Side Academy and East Allegheny? They tied for a section championship. However, in head-to-head, Burrell had a 3-1 record, Shady Side Academy 2-2 and East Allegheny 1-3. Thus, they should be seeded in that order. Also, Cardinal Wuerl North Catholic’s record is only 10-11, but the Trojans played a tough non-section schedule and finished second to Seton LaSalle in the section.
CLASS 2A
Byes: Sewickley Academy, Our Lady of the Sacred Heart, Jeannette, Chartiers-Houston.
Matchups: California (8) vs. Springdale (9), winner to play Sewickley Academy (1); Serra (5) vs. Frazier (12), winner to play Chartiers-Houston (4); Leechburg (7) vs. Neshannock (10), winner to play Our Lady of the Sacred Heart (2); Shenango (6) vs. Fort Cherry (11), winner to play Jeannette (3).
The scoop: Who should get the No. 1 seed – Sewickley Academy or OLSH? They split two games this year and seem to be even. In that case, maybe give the No. 1 seed to Sewickley, based on the fact the Panthers are defending WPIAL and PIAA champs. A few weeks ago, Fort Cherry might have been worth a higher seed. But Ryhan Culberson, the Rangers’ top scorer, is no longer with the team.
CLASS 1A
Byes: Monessen, Vincentian, Union, Clairton.
Matchups: Cornell (8) vs. Winchester Thurston (9), winner plays Monessen (1); Propel Andrew Street (5) vs. Geibel (12), winner plays Clairton (4); Imani Christian (7) vs. Holy Family Academy (10), winner plays Vincentian (2); Eden Christian (6) vs. West Greene (11), winner plays Union (3).
The scoop: Propel Andrew Street, Eden Christian and Imani Christian all tied for a section championship and they were all 1-1 against each other. But the nod for the higher seed should go to Propel because it has played the best lately, winning nine in a row, including victories against Eden Christian and Imani Christian. I know my scenario has Clairton and Monessen on the same side of the bracket, but they wouldn’t meet until the semifinals. And if you are going to truly seed teams, then do it.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.