Brandon Stone, Tre Mitchell and Ja’Mier Fletcher would be three of the top big men in WPIAL basketball next season. Two already have Division I college scholarship offers while Fletcher is getting some Division I interest.
But Stone, Mitchell and Fletcher have played their last games in the WPIAL. They all have a preppy look to them now.
Stone, Mitchell and Fletcher have decided to leave their homes, schools, their longtime teammates and friends and play at prep schools next season. The chief reason for their departures, according to the players or their parents, is they believe the WPIAL competition, or their coaches, or their schools aren’t good enough for them. With prodding from others, such as AAU coaches, the players believe they will develop more at a prep school, gain more exposure to college coaches and increase their chances at what they covet most. It’s not a WPIAL or state championship. Not even high school success.
It’s that major-college scholarship.
• Stone, a 6-foot-10 junior at Southmoreland High School, will go to Christ School, a prep school in Arden, N.C. He averaged 25 points a game last season and already has a few scholarship offers from lower-level Division I colleges.
• Mitchell, a 6-foot-9 sophomore at Elizabeth Forward, will go to Woodstock Academy in Connecticut. He averaged 19 points a game and already has an offer from Mount St. Mary’s, a Division I college.
• Fletcher, a 6-7 junior at Steel Valley, will attend Faith Love Christian Academy, a tiny school in Washington, Pa., that has had a basketball program for only a few years. Fletcher averaged 19 points a game and has a few Division I colleges expressing interest.
Players have left WPIAL schools before to attend prep schools before they graduated. But not three all at once like Stone, Mitchell and Fletcher and not three with their stature and reputations. Their decisions are somewhat of a blow to WPIAL basketball. But like it or not, Stone, Mitchell and Fletcher are examples of how prep schools these days are affecting high school basketball and recruiting, both in the district and even more so around the country.
A number of prep schools now recruit many high school players much the same way colleges recruit. Some prep schools give scholarships, but some high school players also pay to go there. The price could be $10,000 to $20,000 a year.
“You go to a big-time AAU event and all the prep schools are there, wearing their shirts and gear, just like college coaches.,” said Mars High School coach Rob Carmody.
Carmody’s son, Robby, is a Mars junior who has many scholarship offers from colleges across the country. Carmody the coach said at least a half dozen prep schools have tried to recruit his son over the last year, trying unsuccessfully to get him to leave Mars.
“He has wanted to play where he grew up, play with his buddies, play for his school, no matter what,” said Rob Carmody the coach.
The main question, though, is does a player really need a prep school to get those major-college offers, especially with AAU basketball being so big in recruiting these days.
John Miller is the legendary former boys coach at Blackhawk High School. His two sons, Sean and Archie, are head coaches at big-time colleges — University of Arizona and Indiana. John Miller also coaches some of the top WPIAL girls players for his Drill 4 Skill AAU team and coached boys AAU teams for a number of years with the old Pittsburgh JOTS. He is not shy about giving an opinion on whether a high school kid needs to leave his high school team and go to a prep school for more college exposure.
“I would say no way do you need to leave and go to a prep school,” said Miller. “I would go back and put my hat on for what I’ve said to parents for the last 25-30 years. If you really work hard every day, and work hard every week, and you have talent, colleges will find you.
“I’m old school, but I’m really not old school. The key is wherever you are, get good training. Hopefully, you can get that from your high school. If not, then find somebody who might get you on the right track. Then you go bounce around in the AAU in the offseason, and away we go. Colleges will find you.”
Why go prep?
Some prep schools have a high school team and also a graduate team, where students can go for a year after high school graduation. Stone and Fletcher plan to “reclassify,” meaning they will repeat a grade in order to get an extra year of playing at their prep schools. It is essentially the same as redshirting in college. Mitchell is not sure if he will reclassify.
Stone, Mitchell and Fletcher could stay at their high school through their senior years, and then go to a prep school for a fifth year.
“No disrespect to the coaching staff or anything [at Elizabeth Forward], but I find it’s kind of hard to compete on the high level that I would like, while I am attending the school I am at now,” said Mitchell.
Erin Mitchell said her son “wants to be pushed and he doesn’t feel like he’s being pushed at all in the WPIAL.”
Elizabeth Forward had a 12-11 record this past season and lost in the first round of the WPIAL playoffs.
Stone has a slender body and said going to a prep school and reclassifying will give him another year to add weight and get stronger. He also said it would be “rough” next season at Southmoreland because the team lost eight seniors.
Bill Fletcher said academics is one of the reasons his son is leaving Steel Valley. But basketball also is part of the decision.
“You look at who we’re playing [at Steel Valley],” said Fletcher. “If we’re not playing anyone and we’re losing, then when are the college coaches going to come?”
Prep history
Players from the WPIAL have gone the prep school route before, both before they graduated high school and after graduation. In some cases, a prep school did nothing for their recruitment.
North Allegheny’s Cole Constantino was a Post-Gazette Fabulous 5 selection in 2015. He wanted Division I scholarship offers, but they never came after playing at The Phelps School in Eastern Pennsylvania. He is now attending Case Western University, but not playing.
Ambridge’s Daylon Carter had some Division II scholarship offers, but decided to attend Cushing Academy (Mass.). He signed with Shippensburg University (Division II) and recently finished his freshman season.
West Mifflin’s Karlyn Garner was a standout guard who attended Mount Zion Prep (Md.) this school year. He is getting interest from Divison II colleges, the same as he was in high school.
Julian Batts was a standout point guard at Jeannette and after graduation played for a year at St. Thomas More (Conn.). He ended up getting a scholarship to Division I Long Island University.
Adrian Batts is Julian’s father and Jeannette’s coach.
“These three guys leaving now, you wonder because they already have interest from colleges,” said Batts. “Why leave now, go to a prep school now and reclassify? Why not just go after high school?”
Jarrod Simmons grew up in Moon and attended Moon schools through eighth grade. But for ninth through 11 grade, he played at Cushing Academy (Mass.). He also played high-level AAU and got Division I scholarship offers. But he came back to Moon for his senior year and led Moon to a WPIAL title.
Simmons, who has signed with Pennsylvania of the Ivy League, doesn’t regret any of his decisions and doesn’t’ think Stone, Mitchell and Fletcher are making bad decisions.
Anthony Dallier left North Allegheny after his junior year, reclassified and played two years at Northfield Mount Hermon (Mass.). He ended up playing four years at Yale. But Ivy League and Patriot League schools were the same ones recruiting him when he was at North Allegheny.
“I didn’t get that next-level scholarship offer I was hoping for when I left,” said Dallier. “But I think I was a lot more prepared academically and basketball-wise when I got to college.
“It kind of depends kid by kid, I think. I don’t regret what I did. But I’d be lying if I said I don’t think about it sometimes. I had lived in North Allegheny my whole life. I definitely think about, ‘hey, maybe we could’ve won a WPIAL had I stayed or maybe something else could’ve happened.’”
The AAU influence
An offshoot of the decisions of Stone, Mitchell and Fletcher is more animosity from high school coaches toward AAU coaches, something that is not uncommon around the country.
Nate Perry and Tom Droney are former WPIAL basketball standouts who coach both Stone and Mitchell for Bridge City, a Western Pa. AAU club. Seven years ago, Perry and Droney were on the Post-Gazette Fabulous 5 (Perry played at Hempfield and Droney at Sewickley Academy before playing at Davidson). They have been coaching AAU for only a few years and neither has ever coached in high school. But they have the ears of some players and parents and have encouraged players to leave their high schools for prep schools. Erin Mitchell, mother of Tre Mitchell, said Perry and Droney acted as the go-between for prep schools and her son.
Some coaches around the WPIAL question the motives of Perry and Droney. Perry acknowledges that he and Droney have told players to leave high school for prep schools.
“I think it depends on every kid’s situation,” said Perry. “I could definitely see where there might be a rift between us and some high school coaches. But there are some players around here who go play for higher-level AAU organizations outside of the Pittsburgh area. If they can do that, then why can’t guys from the WPIAL do the same thing with prep schools to broaden their network? … I’m in it for the kids. I’m sure some people are not nice about what we’re doing. But if we can better a kid’s future, the parents trust me and we can weigh the pros and cons, then we can only give our opinion.”
And when it comes to prep schools and basketball, there are many opinions.
Mike White: mwhite@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mwhiteburgh




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.