Robby Carmody is a 6-foot-4 guard on the Mars High School basketball team who is ranked the No. 47 junior in the country by ESPN and is one of the most heavily recruited basketball players in the WPIAL in a decade. Carmody’s father, Rob II, is in the middle of it all as dad, head coach at Mars and also assistant for his son’s AAU team (Ohio Basketball Club). The following is another installment of Carmodys Corner, a diary from the elder Carmody that will appear periodically in the Post-Gazette, as told to P-G writer Mike White.
On June 15, this recruiting process changed a lot for Robby. It was a crazy day.
That was the first day college coaches could make personal contact with a player from the class of 2018. Before, coaches could call me, but only because I’m his high school coach.
At 12:01 that day, he started getting text messages from coaches. Most coaches might not call at 12:01, but they started to text. The rest of the day was kind of like a whirlwind. Robby would be on the phone and another coach would call. You try to manage that while still trying to get a workout in during the day.
I’d say he talked to maybe 30 coaches that day. Yes, 30. A lot of the calls came from assistants, but some head coaches, too. [Villanova coach] Jay Wright called. Robby came to me kind of excited and said, “Dad, Jay Wright called.”
I said, “Who’s Jay Wright?” He thought I was some kind of idiot and said, “He’s the Villanova coach. What’s wrong with you?”
I told him, “Robby, I know who Jay Wright is. I’m just trying to get you to laugh a little about all of this.”
Honestly, he was kind of excited to get those calls. He wanted to save some of the voice mails. It’s nice that he’s so innocent about a lot of this.
The offers
Robby has maybe around a dozen scholarship offers now. Pitt, Duquesne, Penn State, Notre Dame, Louisville, Purdue, Xavier are some of them. Stanford and Northwestern were the most recent to offer.
He’s not ready to narrow down his list yet. There are a number of schools that want to see him play over the next month in AAU tournaments and there could be some more offers after that. Villanova, Ohio State, LSU, Vanderbilt, Syracuse and Michigan are some of the ones that want to see him play.
We visited Michigan in June and coach [John] Beilein has been to Mars to watch Robby work out. He’s watched film of him, too. We visited there because everything seems to fit in terms of the style they play and the academics. When we visited, coach Beilein said he couldn’t offer a scholarship yet until he sees him play live in person. We’re not offended by that at all. Some people might be, but we want Michigan to be sure he fits what they are doing if they are going to offer.
On the same trip, we visited Notre Dame and Purdue. We’ll be taking some other trips in August after AAU ends. We’re definitely going to see Syracuse, Northwestern and probably Vanderbilt. Maybe Stanford, too.
In the fall, we’ll maybe start to thin things out a little and maybe narrow things a little. I don’t want to speak totally for him, but I don’t believe he wants to go into this senior year with not really knowing where he’s going to college. At this time next year, I think he wants to have the decision out of the way.
About Pitt
Pitt offered a scholarship to Robby last year when Jamie Dixon was the coach. We’ve talked with new [Pitt] assistant coach Tom Richardson, who came with coach [Kevin] Stallings from Vanderbilt.
Honestly, I don’t know if the scholarship offer is still there, or does the new staff have to re-evaluate? I’m sure that will be worked out. Robby had an interest in Vanderbilt when coach Stallings was there.
Busy AAU schedule
July is a big month for AAU tournaments and recruiting because it’s a “live” period. Robby will be with the Ohio Basketball Club in the adidas Gauntlet Finale this week in Spartanburg, S.C. The next weekend it’s the All In tournament in Cincinnati. Then the weekend after that it’s the adidas Super 64 in Las Vegas.
Those three weeks are grueling — for everybody involved. It’s grueling for the college coaches and it’s really grueling for the high school players. You’re talking about three weeks back to back, and these kids at these high-level tournaments know every time they go out there, there are college coaches watching. There’s that stress and then the level of competition is very high.
Say what you want, but some of these kids are fighting to get scholarships. By that third weekend, you might have played 15 games in three weeks. One of the tournaments is from Wednesday through Sunday. So you’re bouncing from one tournament to the next. That last weekend, kids are beat up and they get tired from trying to play at their max.
But that’s the way AAU and recruiting goes. I’d like to see the live periods spread out a little more. There are only two live periods in April and three in July. Why can’t we spread them out a little more?
WPIAL vs. Ohio
With Robby playing AAU basketball for OBC the past two years, one thing I’ve noticed is the difference in the Ohio AAU and high school teams versus the way it’s done in PA. Ohio has rules in place that allow the AAU and high school programs to supplement one another better than we do in PA. Ohio also has a rule that forces the emphasis of the offseason on individual skill development. I think both of these are really good for the kids.
In PA, high school programs can start almost immediately after the season with undergrads, spring/summer league, and team camps. It is great for the high school programs to build continuity and begin to implement their systems. The flip side is that kids maybe don’t try to get out of their comfort level and do different things, play in different roles. In Ohio, the coaches can’t play in these types of things until June. So from the end of the season until June, kids are playing AAU. The kids get to play in different roles, try new things without the fear of upsetting their high school coach.
Through the spring, Ohio does allow the coaches to work with players. However, they can only have four at a time in the gym so it really forces an emphasis on skill development. If the kids want to play games they play AAU on weekends and spend their time at their high schools working on their individual skills.
I’ve been coaching in Western Pennsylvania for 22 years. I don’t know if there is a right way or wrong way to do it, but I think one of the reasons Ohio is a little ahead of where we are in Western Pa. is because of these two rules that emphasize developing skills, instead of playing so many games in the offseason.
The rumors
One thing that this recruiting process has showed Robby and myself is how many rumors are out there. After this first “Carmodys Corner” diary came out, one of my assistant coaches told me about a conversation he had at school. I wish I was making this up, but a teacher asked him about my TV reality show. The teacher said he was at a party and people were talking about how they saw in the paper that I’m doing a TV reality show. They turned this diary into a reality show. Wow.
Then that same teacher said people at the party were talking about how I might have been offered a coaching job at Notre Dame. What? They turned Notre Dame offering Robby a scholarship into offering me a job.
Then there are these rumors about Robby going to a prep school. They think that just because we graduated a lot of players from last year, he’s going to a prep school? Yes, prep schools have called, but that’s not something he wants to do. He has grown up with Mars basketball. He’s been a little dribbler, attended youth camp, played in our youth program, and practiced in our gym more hours than we could count.
He’s getting a great education here at Mars. He’s very close to his brother and sister, and his grandparents can get to see him play. These things all matter to him. On the basketball side of it, he has received plenty of exposure through AAU, camps, and we have had plenty of coaches come in to watch him work out. Staying home allows him to do all the typical things that high school kids do.
Mike White: mwhite@post-gazette.com and Twitter @mwhiteburgh





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.