Though South Fayette was the reigning WPIAL champion and was riding a nine-game winning streak, it knew that it would have a tough time with District 10 champion Villa Maria Academy.

“That team is ranked No. 9 in the country, they have six Division I players and those kids are there to play basketball,” South Fayette coach Matt Bacco said. “They go to that program because it’s a perennial power and they want to play basketball.”

Though South Fayette gave the Victors a challenge, Villa Maria (28-0) just had too many weapons as Lafayette recruit Sarah Agnello scored a game-high 19 points, including five 3-pointers, to help end the Lions’ season with a 54-44 loss Saturday at New Castle in the PIAA Class AAA quarterfinals.

“South Fayette is very talented one through five and it doesn’t matter who is out there or who has the ball,” Villa Maria coach Douglas Chuzie said. “We tried to mix our defenses a little bit so they wouldn’t get comfortable because, as soon as they get comfortable, they’re going to execute and put the ball in the hoop.”

Advertise with us

South Fayette (24-4) struggled throughout at handling the Villa Maria team speed, but more so in the first half when the team committed 12 turnovers and was only 6 for 16 from the floor. Despite the problems the Lions had moving the ball, they only trailed, 22-21, at the intermission and could have taken the lead if Carlee Kilgus’ layup at the buzzer falls.

South Fayette was still able to take the lead just 13 seconds into the second half when Mikayla Fetchet hit two free throws for a 23-22 lead. That also was the final time the Lions had the advantage as Villa Maria went on a 10-0 run, thanks in large part to two 3-pointers from Agnello and Canisius recruit Anna Sweny, that helped the Victors to a 32-23 lead with 5:08 left in the third quarter.

“Every time we needed a stop it seemed they would bang a 3 and we made them make some tough plays,” Bacco said. But they’ve got five good offensive players on the floor, and anytime you’re not defensively perfect, it’s going to end up in your hoop.”

South Fayette worked its way back into it a bit, but a late 8-2 run to end the third period gave Villa Maria a 42-31 lead heading into the fourth.

“We were forcing them to kind of move the ball around so that they wouldn’t be able to get into their stuff,” Bacco said. “We wanted them to play a little helter-skelter on offense and we trapped them a good bit, but we weren’t going to be on our heels.”

Advertise with us

More Class AAA girls

South Park 33, Northern Lebanon 30: Alison McGrath scored a game-high 11 points as the Eagles continued their impressive run through the PIAA Class AAA playoffs. South Park was held without a point for the final 2:23 after Brittany Andrews scored the team’s final points, but Megan Brandt’s desperation 3-pointer at the buzzer didn’t hit the rim. South Park now will play Villa Maria in the semifinals Tuesday at a site and time to be determined.

“We’ve seen South Park and Alison McGrath is so talented and she’s a threat all over the court,” Chuzie said. “They come at you with a couple of different zone traps and, I don’t even know where to start. We’re going to have our hands full.”

Class A girls

Cardinal Wuerl North Catholic 62, Bishop Carroll 45: Sam Breen continued her postseason offensive onslaught as she racked up 36 points to help the WPIAL Class A runner-up Trojanettes move into the PIAA semifinals. Breen also has 13 rebounds.