Walt: What's your take on this belle vernon wrestling story? It's a coach's mistake, why is the kid being punished?
Mike White: Crazy story. Sad one, too. I didn't write it, but looking as an outsider you just wonder is there is more to this story?? If all is true in story, then really bad for coach not knowing those rules. Always thought the whole weight thing with wrestling was crazy. This just proves it. Hear those stories over years of kids doing ridiculous things to lose weight, like wearing a trash bag all day to sweat.
Mike White: WPIAL basketball semifinals this week. Honestly, my favorite time of high school sports year.
Varsity Xtra: Baskeball Semifinals
Dave Fuhrman: What WPIAL team has the best shot to get to Hershey?
Mike White: Someone in Class AA or A. Because Triple-A and Quad-A have to play at least the semifinal against a team from Eastern Pa., maybe Philly area. That isn't easy. Double-A and Class A don't have to go through eastern teams.
Dave Fuhrman: Who is the best individual hoops player you have seen this season?
Mike White: Boy that is tough to say. There is not one or even two standout players. Only one player in senior class signed with Division I school - Plum's James Edwards with Air Force. As far as D-1 talent, one of worst senior classes ever. But that doesn't mean there aren't some very good players here. I think there are more good players in Western Pa. than colleges think. Allderdice has a couple of the best around. I really like Robby Carmody, sophomore from Mars. Not saying he is best right now, but he is a stud for a sophomore. Already a number of offers from majors. More will come. Skilled and also extremely athletic.
Guest: Did you watch any of the Roman Neumann game? How do you think Dice matches up with Roman?
Mike White: I did not. Allderdice can play with anyone in state. Not saying they will definitely win the state, but they can play with anyone.
Dave Fuhrman: Do you like the WPIAL play in games to determine lower seeds rather than the follow the leader previously used?
Mike White: Yes I like them. I used to think it wasn't a big deal with follow-the-leader approach. But too many times, the best teams weren't going to the state playoffs. This settles it on the court - and not who beat who, who beat who. Good move by the WPIAL. Other districts do it. District 1 has been doing it for a while.
Mike: Prediction for canes game tonight
Mike White: 3's will fly. Both teams are guard-oriented and can shoot. Be shocked if New Castle doesn't win, but I love the job Highlands coach has done.
North Side Jason: You probably get this a lot, but with Tyler Boyd going to the NFL combine this week, who's a current WPIAL player who has the best chance to get a shot at the pros?
Mike White: Was asked this last week. That's a lot to put on a kid, saying he will be an NFL player when he's in high school. I'm not copping out on the question, but I wouldn't like to make that call. Unfair to the kid. The only one that comes to mind most recently was Gronk. And as I said last week, I wasn't convinced about him as a football player or how good of an athlete he was until I saw him play basketball. Reminds me of a story. When I saw Gronkowski play hoops for the first time, my wife was with me. Midway through first half, I said to her "see that kid? He'll be in the NFL someday." She scoffed "how do you know?" I said, "cause there ain't no 6-6 or 6-7 kids around playing tight end who are this athletic." He was doing 360 dunks.
North Side Jason: Which WPIAL semifinal are you most looking forward to?
Mike White: Beaver Falls-Mars tonight is a really good one. That's tonight at Ambridge. I'm going. I think both Quad-A games are good, and not just because I have personal stake in one. Also, don't be surprised if Canevin-Lincoln Park is really good. Canevin has a shot.
Will: I thought it was interesting that the final 4 in aaaa doesn't have any traditional powers. Do you think NHills experience from last year will help them?
Mike White: Maybe somewhat. But only two of those starters played in last year's semis against CV. What helps is having a talented 6-6 kid on the team this year, and Nick Smith has developed into one of the best guards in the WPIAL.
WPIAL Joey: For those of us who have not had the opportunity to see them play, what makes this Alderdice team so darn good?
Mike White: Everything. They have speed, size and skill. Ramon Creighton one of best point guards around and his outside shot has improved. James Jackson has turned into one of best players around and his twin also is good. But what also helps is size in the back with 6-9 Tim Pugh and 6-5 Jordan Rawls. They have great hands on defense and can take chances in their zone traps because those two are in the back to protect things. Plus, they can shoot. And what is overlooked. Buddy Valinsky has coached them. Does great job. Runs things. Doesn't just throw it out and say "play." But no way this team is as good as Schenley in 2007, which I have heard some people say.
Dave Fuhrman: How nervous were you when your son had to take over for Coach Gabos on Sat vs Char Valley?
Mike White: Ha ha. Range of emotions was off the charts for my wife and I. I wasn't there to cover the game. Just was there to watch and then Coach Gabos went down. You are so concerned about him but then keep thinking my son taking over. But he has some experience at JV level, is very involved as a varsity assistant, spent a year with a DLeague team in Erie and coached at IMG Academy in summer for two years. Plus I think he probably has watched or played in maybe 9 thousand games. LOL.
Mike White: Yes, I was a little nervous because of the magnitude of game and it was Char Valley. I kind of felt people looking at me in my stands, but as I told my wife quietly, "the players will decide this. Not him." But I must say was awfully proud and he did do a few things with play calls that I thought were big. But it really was one of the craziest situations I have ever been in as a parent or reporter. Will never forget
John: Whats ur breakdown on Canevin vs LP?
Mike White: Lincoln Park has really good guard combo with Cummings and Aloi. Cummings really good. But Canevin has good guards too. Lincoln Park has some size that could be a factor. Big key will be Canevin how well they shoot it
WPIAL Joey: Mike, thanks for the chat. I read your predictions blog post a few minutes ago. Could you elaborate any further on why you like Latrobe over PR?
Mike White: Have to pick one. I think it will be very close. Maybe Latrobe's guards overall will be the difference. But I wonder if Pine's Phil Jurkovec could play a big role. Jurkovec by the way is the stud sophomore QB with a number of offers for football. I think it's nice to see someone with that big of a football future proving you can still play another sport and be successful at that one also.
Dave Fuhrman: What is your feelings on the PIAA going to 6 classes in many of the sports?
Mike White: I don't mind it. In some sports, will give some teams more of a chance to compete. Are there some drawbacks to it?? Yes. But let's give it a few years and see how it does. I know other people who are in favor of it also, especially in football.
Guest: Why doesn't the wpial address its biggest problem the public schools vs catholic/ charter schools debate
Mike White: WPIAL does more to watch transfers than any other district. What do you want them to do?? PIAA doesn't seem to care much about it. Philadelphia district just turns a blind eye to all the transfers and kids moving in and out schools. Could make transfer rule tougher, but that's probably not going to happen. And don't even think about separating them. People may want that, but PIAA would be in court immediately.
WPIAL Joey: Are you aware of any television coverage for the WPIAL basketball finals, live or otherwise?
Mike White: Nothing live. Usually is On Demand on Comcast within the next day or so. But nothing live.
Pal: Would you take New Castle or the quad A field this year?
Mike White: Good question. I'd say New Castle would be the favorite in Quad-A also.
Pal: Who would you take Carmody or Aiken?
Mike White: Curtis very talented. But Carmody more all around game right now. Who knows? That could change in future. Have to like Carmody's size and athleticism.
Guest: Who is better Nick Smith or Andrew Petcash?
Mike White: Not answering that. Just let them both be very good players and leave at that.
Dave Fuhrman: Do you think charter schools & private schools should have separate championships from public schools? Unfair advantage?
Mike White: Again, no use saying they should have separate championships. It's not going to happen plain and simple.No knock against private coaches or players, but no they are not on same playing field as public schools. That's quite obvious. Just because players to go to private schools from anywhere. No geographical boundaries.
Dave Fuhrman: Do you think the WPIAL did a good job realigning sections in football & basketball?
Mike White: Their hands were tied. Some might not seem right but with 6 classes, some teams were going to travel, plain and simple. But some moves I don't understand. Like putting Central Catholic and Penn Hills in North football section. They made a super "conference." And that other conference in 6A can't even compare. Me?? Would've made much more sense to put Central and Penn Hills in other conference with eastern teams and have Bethel and Lebo play in North. Bethel and Lebo used to play in North. And Connellsville hoops playing in South Hills section makes you scratch your head. Connellsville should be in eastern section, Fox Chapel moved to the North section and Central to the South Hills section. Central can go anywhere. But I know Fox Chapel didn't want to go to North. So they got what they wanted.
Will: Has the WPIAL decided how they will handle 12 title games next year?
Mike White: No. They will have to do 3 days. Can't play 6 and 6 in two days. They are considering maybe going Friday, Saturday, Sunday. They don't want to have to play games during the day on a Thursday. Also would consider having girls at one site and boys at another, but as TIm O'Malley said, then you might be fighting your own self for crowd.
Beaver County Guest: Alderdice this year against the old Schenley team with Dejuan Blair, DJ Kennedy and co. or Aliquippa's team of Herb Porp, Jonathan Baldwin, and Antonio Reddic? Quick off the top predictions? Amazing games at least you would have to think....
Mike White: Again. Allderdice is good. But please stop with comparisons to 2007 Schenley. That team had two NBA players (Blair and Kennedy) and another stud who led an Iowa State team to the Sweet 16 (Deandre Kane). And don't forget Onion. Didn't play in college and was small. But was tremendous point guard for that team. And the fifth starter was Greg Blair, who was leading tackler one year for Univ. Cincinnati. Allderdice is good but please stop with the comparisons to Schenley 2007. Allderdice against Aliquippa 2007 team would be a good game.
Dave Fuhrman: Just want to say you are excellent at covering high school sports and as a former high school hoops coach we & the athletes you cover very much appreciate your coverage!
Mike White: Why thank you very much Dave. Nice of you to say. Usually just get complaints from parents that we don't cover this team or that team, or this player. But I love high school hoops - and many high school sports. This is great time of year.
WPIAL Joey: Speaking of Public/Private, the City Schools enrollment seems kind of strange/confusing to me. Do all the Allderdice kids live within certain boundaries or is there more to it than that?
Mike White: You can pretty much go to any school in the city if you live in city.
Mike White: Hey, that's it for now. Great stuff. Enjoyed it. Geez, didn't know if there would be this many questions. But it's great. See you next Tuesday unless bosses want me to do one before WPIAL basketball finals. Be good.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.