Paul Holzshu eschewed an opportunity to down a libation (or two) at the "19th hole" after a recent round of golf to participate in a question-and-answer session. He jokingly second-guessed the decision. "I'd probably have better answers for you if I had gone," he said, laughing.

Yes, Holzshu is enjoying the fruits of retirement, basking in a career that spanned 42 years as a coach and administrator on the high school and collegiate levels.

On July 31, he retired from Shaler Area High School, where he served as the athletic director for 12 years and as the boys basketball coach from 2008-09 to 2012-13. He won two section titles.

A native of Pitcairn and 1967 graduate of Gateway High School, Holzshu played basketball at Clemson University. He got his start in coaching at IUP under Carl Davis before embarking on a four-decade sojourn that landed him in 10 locales, including East Allegheny, Franklin Regional, Yough and Gateway High Schools.

Advertise with us

Holzshu, 65, and his wife of 42 years, Nancy, are parents to three children – Erinn, Tracey and Michael – and to five grandchildren.

In a revealing, no-holds-barred conversation, Holzshu discussed his entrance into the world of coaching/athletic administration, his frustrations with parental interference, his concerns with AAU basketball, the great moments, the not-so-great moments and his one big regret.

Q. What launched you onto your career path 42 years ago?

A: I was taking my (future) wife to a sorority event at IUP. She was a sophomore at the time. While I was there, I ran into Carl Davis, the head coach. We sat down and Carl convinced me that coaching might be something I'd like to do. He was honest with me, too. He said there will be good and there will be bad, but as long as the pluses outweigh the minuses, it'll be worth it. I've stayed with it in some capacity for the past 42 years.

Q. When you started in 1973, Richard Nixon was president, the Watergate scandal had come to light and the Steelers had yet to win a Super Bowl. Much has happened, much has changed. What big changes did you see in athletics during that time?

Advertise with us

A. I’m going to pinpoint something. When I was growing up, we learned to compete on the street. The first athletic experience I had was meeting friends on the corner and picking up sides. There were no guarantees. You had to be good enough to get picked, good enough to play. And there were no parents grooming or catering to you – making sure you got a chance. There was no organization; it was by the seat of your pants. If you were good enough, you played. If not, you went and did something else. By the time I got to seventh grade and I was trying out for the basketball team, I knew it would be tough. But there was no anticipation by my parents, no expectation that I’d make it just because I played on some AAU team. I don’t see kids on the streets anymore; it’s too vanilla for me. Everybody thinks their kid should be playing, should be the starter and be the best player. Well, that’s not how it works. I have seen the integrity of athletics being compromised.

Q. What are your thoughts on overzealous/meddling parents?

A. There is no bigger plus to a coach-player relationship than trust. And whether that player is the best or the worst on the team – or somewhere in between – they have to trust the coach and believe in what he’s doing. They have to know where they fit in, what their role is. That’s what we call chemistry, and it’s something that you can’t coach. It comes within the ranks. So, when a player is being told everyday by an adult that, “The coach doesn’t like you … the coach isn’t giving you a fair shot … the coach doesn’t know what he’s doing,” the kids are going to believe that. They believe what they’re hearing at home. And that’s what saddens me. I’m not saying every coach is great or is the most knowledgeable or the most strategically sound, but to try to degrade a coach with a personal attack, to me, is just ludicrous. As an administrator, I always tried to maintain integrity and to make sure our coaches were morally and ethically solid. If you want to dispute their coaching knowledge or strategy, we can discuss that. But to immediately attack a person and their integrity and their character just because you’re unhappy that your kid isn’t playing, that doesn’t flush with me. Never has and it never will.

Q. What was the most challenging moment as a coach and/or administrator in dealing with parental interference?

A. I won’t mention names, but I know for a fact that I’ve been in situations where coaches have been run off the job because parents have complained and gotten school board members to go after the coaches. The school board situation is part of a political process; it’s politics. When I offer a coach a job – and that’s part of my duties – and he’s run off without any investigation or a sit down meeting, it’s just unfair. You’re basically taking my observations and interactions with him and throwing them in the waste basket. Are you kidding me?

Advertise with us

Q. Are there any measures that can be taken to insulate athletic programs from such parents?

A. When I got hired at Shaler Area, they asked if there was anything that I wanted to say. I said, “I don’t care about being politically correct. I care about being correct.” Once again, this thing that we call athletics is getting contaminated. Good coaches don’t want to coach anymore, don’t want to put up with the nonsense. You take AAU. I can appreciate what a kid brings to the table when he’s with seven or eight good players on an AAU team. But when that kid comes back to our (high school) program and he’s our best player, he has to do what’s best for the team. In AAU, you play to get recruited, to showcase your skill. In the high school setting, the goal is to win a section, win the WPIAL, win the state playoffs. People think I’m anti-AAU. Not true. I’m anti what has emerged from the residue of AAU and how it’s affecting the inner circle of interscholastic athletics.

Q. In what way was your high school program different than an AAU program?

A. As a high school coach, it is my job to give a parent an honest evaluation of their son. And sometimes, it may not be what you want to hear as a parent. Now, when you’re an AAU coach and that kid’s parents are paying $2,000 to be on your team, you might not get an honest evaluation. They’ll say what you want to hear.

Q. What is your proudest moment?

Advertise with us

A. I just told my son this the other night: You can take all the wins, all the losses, all the championships. You can take the high moments and you can take the low moments. But to me, the most gratifying and rewarding part about those 42 years are the relationships with people, the friendships. I don’t know that I’ve ever coached a team at any level where I don’t still have relationships with those players. If they’re coming to town, they call and say, “let’s get lunch, let’s get dinner.” I’ve gone to reunions and homecomings. I’ve had former players come in and stay at the house. That’s what you take away from it. You share those moments. Those wonderful highs and those sickening lows. You get through those things together. You remember the good moments more – and embellish them more – than you do the bad moments. But it’s all part of that relationship with your players.

Q. What is sound advice for young players?

A. I always said to my players, “It’s not a question of can or can’t; it’s a question of will or won’t.”

Q. What is your regret?

A. My only real regret over the 42 years is that I spent a lot more time with other people’s kids than I did with my own. And that’s time I can never make up. It’s only now that I’m finding a real rewarding relationship that continues to grow with my three children now that they are adults. But as I’ve told them, that’s part of the chemistry, part of the make-up, part of the deal when you sign up for this. … All three of my children attended my (retirement) golf outing and they heard some of the things that were said. I think that allowed them to understand and to appreciate what those 42 years were about.