A playoff game is never a good time for a team to be in a situation where a player is physically unable to contribute.

But that's precisely the scenario the Carlynton Cougars found themselves in last month during a 40-35 WPIAL Class AA semifinal loss to Seton-LaSalle at West Allegheny High School.

Seton-LaSalle went on to win the WPIAL title while the Cougars entered the PIAA Class AA tournament as the No. 3 team and earned a 45-33 first-round victory against Red Bank Valley, the No. 2 team from District 9.

The Cougars’ quest for state honors came to a close on Tuesday, however, when they lost to fellow WPIAL competitor Chartiers-Houston, 57-49, in a second-round game at Canon-McMillan. Carlynton led by six points going into the fourth quarter, but couldn’t hold on.

Advertise with us

With the defeat, Carlynton closes its season with a 20-7 record. Nonetheless, it was a season of significant accomplishments for the Cougars.

They shared the Section 5-AA title with Our Lady of the Sacred Heart and won three postseason games -- two in the WPIAL playoffs and another in the state tournament.

Sixth-year coach Tim Bonner said a contributing factor for the loss to the Rebels in the WPIAL semifinals was that the Cougars' center, 5-foot-10 junior Abigail Greiner, would have made a bigger impact had she been able to play the whole game. She sat out the first half with an ankle injury

"She's averaging nine points a game and 12 [rebounds], and [Seton-LaSalle] had a big team," he said. "She didn't play in the first half, and that hurt us. We struggled, and at halftime she said she could play."

With a taller player in the Cougars' lineup, the court opened up for standout guard Conor Richardson, who scored 20 of her 22 points in the second half when Greiner returned to the lineup..

Advertise with us

"[Greiner] had six points and seven rebounds in the second half," he said. "Had she been able to play the whole game, she might have scored 12 points and had 14 rebounds."

Bonner said he hopes Greiner will be able to play as she would take some pressure off Richardson, a 5-10 senior who averages 20.5 points, 5 steals and 5 assists and will play for Duquesne next season.

Bonner said the loss to Seton-LaSalle and a 52-22 WPIAL Class AA first-round victory against Frazier were the two most frustrating games he's been involved with this season.

In both games, the Cougars' offense struggled. They led Frazier, 14-9, at halftime in that game but went on to win, 52-22. Seton-LaSalle held a 16-10 halftime lead over the Cougars.

"Against Frazier, we had everyone, and that's what made it even more frustrating," he said. "But we knew we'd struggle against [Seton-LaSalle] because Abby hadn't missed a game all year."

Advertise with us

Bonner said the Cougars' success was based on some offensive and defensive alignments that have worked best for his personnel. There's been some balance, too.

Jordan Melko, a 5-9 senior, is averaging 11.7 points and 9.5 rebounds per game. Greiner, who is expected to be the centerpiece in the Carlynton offense next season, is averaging 9 points and 12.5 rebounds per game.

"Abby has played against some big centers and has done very well," Bonner said. "We're happy she'll be back next year."

He's also been pleased with sophomore guards Lexi Kowal and Ashleigh Wilson.

"Ashleigh started last year, but both of them are very tough defensively," Bonner said.

In addition to Richardson and Melko, Lexus and Lyric Woods will also graduate.