Earning a trip into the PIAA playoffs was never much of a concern for Lincoln Park's boys basketball team.
Before moving up a classification this season, the Leopards were regular contenders in the WPIAL Class A playoff bracket and typically earned an automatic bid into the PIAA tournament.
This year, however, Lincoln Park had to put in some extra work to continue its postseason.
After losing to Quaker Valley in WPIAL quarterfinals, the Leopards received a second chance at the playoffs and entered the Class AA consolation -- or "play-in" -- bracket. Lincoln Park defeated both Our Lady of the Sacred Heart and Neshannock in those "play-in" games to secure a spot in this weekend's state tournament.
"We've made the state playoffs every year since our inception into the WPIAL," said Mike Bariski, who is Lincoln Park boys coach as well as the school's athletic director. "We would always see coaches, whom we had beaten a few days before, at the WPIAL championship game rooting for us.
"It was kind of weird seeing teams that tried to beat you cheering for you."
That was because the WPIAL traditionally used a "follow-the-winner" format to determine which teams qualified for any additional berths beyond the four semifinalists for the PIAA boys and girls basketball tournaments.
The number of PIAA berths awarded to District 7 vary depending on the classification. The PIAA awards those spots based on the number of teams in a given classification in that district.
For example, five WPIAL boys and girls teams advance in Class AAAA and Class A, while seven Class AA girls teams and six Class AA boys move on to states.
In the past, that meant teams that didn't advance into the WPIAL semifinals usually had to hope the team it lost to in the quarterfinals either made it to the championship round or, in the case of seven berths for a given class, lost to the semifinal loser that lost to the eventual champion.
According to WPIAL executive director Tim O'Malley, the WPIAL's basketball committee approved to modify its longtime "follow-the-leader" format in August for a new policy regarding how it awards berths into the PIAA basketball playoffs.
"There had been some discussions about changing the policy on an annual basis," O'Malley said. "Coaches whose teams didn't make the semifinals were usually the ones who brought up the subject."
For the first time since the early 1980s, the WPIAL's "follow-the-leader" format was out and a new consolation bracket was implemented for this year and next. Quarterfinal losers now actually compete for whatever remaining berths are available beyond four.
"After that, it remains to be seen," O'Malley said.
Coaches have welcomed the change.
"Before, you would sit around and wait to see if the team that eliminated you won or got into that championship series," Trinity girls coach Bob Miles said. "Now, games are much more meaningful and competitive."
After Blackhawk defeated Trinity in the girls Class AAA quarterfinals, the Hillers were eliminated again after losing to Beaver Area and McGuffey in the consolation rounds.
"It made practices more intense for the fact we were still playing games and knew we had to be sharp," Miles said.
In the past, however, Trinity would have made the PIAA tournament simply because Blackhawk won a WPIAL title.
"You shouldn't be lucky to get in," Highlands boys coach Tyler Stoczynski said. "This way, you hold your own destiny."
Highlands played five postseason games but did not qualify for the state tournament after it lost to Mars and South Fayette in the consolation bracket. If the WPIAL used its old format, the Rams would have advanced into the state tournament because it lost to WPIAL champion Indiana in the quarterfinals.
"Losing those playoff games were tough, but I'm still a huge supporter of [the new policy]," Stoczynski said. "We were the lowest seed [in the Class AAA bracket], so we shouldn't get into the state playoffs just because Indiana won.
"We should have to fight and earn it like everyone else."
The Mt. Lebanon boys, on the other hand, secured its spot in the Class AAAA state bracket following consolation wins against Upper St. Clair and Hempfield.
"If this were last year, Upper St. Clair would be in and we'd be out," Blue Devils coach Joe David said. "Why would they get to go just because they lost to Chartiers Valley? It doesn't make much sense."
The California girls team also benefited from the new format. The Trojans entered the WPIAL playoffs as the No. 3 seed but were eliminated by Riverview in the quarterfinals.
"This gives teams a chance to earn their way," California coach Chris Minerd said. "We had high expectations for this season and we were upset after losing to Riverview. We were able to challenge our girls because they knew we still had something to play for.
"Our team could have easily folded, but our girls came back and stayed focused."
The new system, however, didn't make it easy on the WPIAL.
"It's a lot of work," O'Malley said. "We had 166 [playoff] games played in two weeks and we added 27 [play-in] games during a two-day period. It's taxing to find the facilities to hold these games.
"To compound the problem this year was the snow."
Inclement weather not only delayed a day's worth of games but it also forced many teams to play back-to-back playoff games.
"The transition from Monday to Tuesday was very difficult," David said. "It was hard for everybody, but that was because of the snow."
Weather aside, coaches liked the new format.
"I hope they keep it," Miles said. "The crowds we saw at our games were good-sized and really into the games. I'm all for keeping it like this."
Bariski agreed.
"This format makes it fair," he said. "You have to get in on your own merits and not get dragged in by someone else."



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.