Plum High School's Nolan Cressler was showing off his Division I college talent, putting the team on his shoulders and bringing the Mustangs back from a 12-point third-quarter deficit.

It took two future Division I athletes to trump him.

Shaler's Geno Thorpe and J.P. Holtz made every big play down the stretch to help the Titans push past Plum, 57-48, in a WPIAL Class AAAA quarterfinal Saturday at North Allegheny.

Thorpe, a junior guard and a Penn State recruit, and Holtz, a senior center and a Pitt football recruit, scored 19 of Shaler's 22 points in the fourth quarter to stave off Plum's comeback. Thorpe finished with 24 points, including 10 in the fourth quarter. Holtz scored eight of his 13 points in the final quarter.

Advertise with us

They helped Shaler (22-2) reach the WPIAL semifinals for only the third time in school history.

"They have that Division I tag on them. They're supposed to make the plays," Shaler coach Paul Holzshu said. "I'd be disappointed if they didn't."

Cressler, a senior who is headed to Cornell of the Ivy League, finished with 28 points, making 10 of 16 shots from the field and 5 of 7 from the free-throw line. He was the second-leading scorer in the WPIAL in the regular season at 25.7 ppg, but he had only eight points in the first half. He sat for the final 4:21 of the half after picking up his third foul.

Shaler led, 21-15, at halftime and opened up a 27-15 lead early in the third quarter. But Cressler scored 10 points in the next 10 minutes and his steal and layup brought the Mustangs within 43-41 with 3:54 left.

"I thought Ryan Micher and Sean Gavin did as much as they could to neutralize Cressler in the first half," Holzshu said. "We knew there was going to come a point where he was going to catch a rhythm. What a great player he is. Fantastic."

Advertise with us

After Plum pulled within two, it was Holtz and Thorpe against Cressler. A free throw by Holtz and a basket by Thorpe made it 46-41.

Cressler answered with a 3-pointer, but Holtz converted a three-point play off a pass from Thorpe to make it 49-44. After a Plum turnover, Thorpe scored with 2:32 left and Holtz added another basket a short time later. Plum couldn't recover.

"Cressler gave us all we could handle," said Thorpe, who made 8 of 14 shots. "I whispered to [Holtz] that if I get the ball in the middle against their zone, I'm going to be looking for him. I told him I'd give him the perfect pass for him to finish -- and that's what he did."

Shaler's defense also was a key, holding Plum to its third-lowest offensive output of the season.

"I don't know if we're a lot better on defense this year than last year, but we definitely take it more seriously," Thorpe said.

Holzshu said, "I've been in this game since Jesus Christ was in diapers and I've always subscribed to one basic philosophy. If you can hold a high school team to less than 50 points, you should win. You won't always, but you should win most of the time, particularly if you have talent like we have."