A few weeks ago, I used this notebook to advocate for an open tournament in the WPIAL playoffs. One of my reasons? It would create more opportunities for the student-athletes.

Some might call me a hypocrite for what I'm about to write, but it's OK. I've been called worse.

Here is my proposal: Teams that lose in the WPIAL playoffs (or any district playoff game, for that matter) should not advance to the PIAA tournament.

Check out the new online publication devoted to South Hills varsity and community sports with updates every weekday on your hometown sports scene. Click to visit Sports Town now ...

Advertise with us

Some might say: "But Michael, wouldn't eliminating teams from the PIAA tournament deprive student-athletes of opportunities, for which you were an advocate just a few weeks ago?"

To which I would reply: "Touche."

Maybe I'm old fashioned, but I do not believe a team that loses in its district playoff deserves the right to compete for a state championship.

PIAA titles should be won only by teams who perform nearly flawlessly in March. Instead, the PIAA record books are littered with teams that have really goofed up in the postseason.

Now I understand why the PIAA operates its postseason tournament this way. The basketball tournament generates a fair amount of revenue. The more teams that play in the tournament, the more games are played, the more tickets are sold, etc. In rough economic times, it is tough to envision any new system that might adversely affect the bottom line.

Advertise with us

Most states use a single-elimination statewide tournament -- similar to the PIAA football championships in which only the district winners have a chance to win a state tournament. Some states feature consolation brackets, which allow teams to win another chance into the main draw. Some feature a system like Pennsylvania's.

I think Pennsylvania should practice best practice and adopt the most popular tournament setup. And not just for basketball, but for all team sports that give teams new life in the state tournament.

Some have equated the dynamic between the WPIAL and PIAA playoffs to the one between conference and NCAA tournaments.

I believe they are different.

First, the postseason conference tournament is a relatively new phenomenon in college basketball and was created to give teams an automatic berth to the NCAA tournament. Although conference tournament losers can advance to the NCAA tournament, the teams that advance do not necessarily play well in the conference tournament. It is predicated more on a team's performance in the regular season.

Advertise with us

I believe the dynamic is much more similar to the early rounds of the NCAA tournament. Teams that lose in the first round of the NCAA tournament do not get another shot to win the championship. Nor should they.

"March Madness" would be much different if teams knew their season might not end in a loss.

I would like to say I believe in second chances. But not in postseason basketball.

Adieu to you and you

The first week of the PIAA basketball tournament was mostly kind to teams from the WPIAL and the City League. But some teams did not fare as well as their District 7 and District 8 peers.

Advertise with us

Here is a quick look back at some of the teams from the Post-Gazette's South Xtra coverage area that finished their seasons this past week.

Chartiers Valley boys (20-7) -- The Colts excelled this season, despite graduating last season's leading scorer (T.J. McConnell) and moving to Class AAAA from Class AAA.

Chartiers Valley was led by Matt Nozska (19.9 points per game) and Steve Burda (16.2 ppg). But the Colts could not replicate last season's deep run in the PIAA tournament, losing to Allderdice in the first round last week.

West Mifflin boys (22-4) -- Had star C.J. Hester (17.7 ppg) stayed healthy the entire season, West Mifflin likely would have played for the WPIAL title. Hester missed five games this season after sustaining two concussions.

He returned for the PIAA playoffs and scored double figures in both of the Titans' PIAA games.

Advertise with us

But West Mifflin's season ended with a first-round loss to Johnstown, 41-35.

Serra Catholic boys (15-9) -- The Eagles were not as strong as they have been in recent years, but Serra advanced to the PIAA playoffs for the seventh consecutive season.

The Eagles earned a share of the Class A Section 4 title, but their season ended last week with a loss to Elk County Catholic in the first round of the PIAA playoffs.

Brashear girls (15-8) -- Led by Nyasia Middleton and Nautica Buchanan, the Bulls enjoyed a solid season. Brashear won nine of its last 11 regular-season games and advanced to the City League semifinals.

WPIAL power Oakland Catholic ended Brashear's season with a 71-15 victory in the preliminary round of the PIAA tournament.