It has never been easy for the WPIAL to win a PIAA Class AAAA championship in boys basketball.

Since the classification was formed for the 1983-84 season, a WPIAL team has won only twice.

But the way the PIAA brackets are set up these days, it's hard for a WPIAL team to even make it the Class AAAA championship game -- and this year will be no different.

WPIAL Class AAAA teams have had trouble advancing to the state title game in recent years because the PIAA discarded true East-West Region brackets in 2005. It used to be the PIAA tournament had a bracket with western teams, a bracket with eastern teams and a true East vs. West final.

Advertise with us

But since then, a number of teams from eastern Pennsylvania play through the Western Region of the bracket, and some of the eastern teams are very talented. Most of the good eastern teams have been from the Philadelphia area.

The end result is the stronger eastern teams are keeping WPIAL and other western teams out of the Class AAAA championship game.

The PIAA tournament begins tonight and Class AAAA boys teams play tomorrow. A look at the Class AAAA bracket shows the WPIAL might once again have trouble getting a team to the final. Four teams in the Western Region bracket are ranked in the top 10 in the state by the Harrisburg Patriot-News. Those four are all eastern Pennsylvania teams -- No. 2-ranked Council Rock North, No. 4 Neshaminy, No. 6 York and No. 9 Penn Wood, a team that has played in the past two PIAA finals.

Check out the new online publication devoted to South Hills varsity and community sports with updates every weekday on your hometown sports scene. Click to visit Sports Town now ...

No team from the WPIAL or any other Western Pennsylvania district is ranked in the top 10. The four WPIAL teams in the PIAA Class AAAA tournament are Gateway, Chartiers Valley, Butler and Mt. Lebanon. Upper St. Clair also qualified but lost a play-in game Tuesday to Erie McDowell.

Advertise with us

Teams from the west have lost to an eastern team in the semifinals four times in the past six seasons. The average margin of defeat in those games has been 18.8 points. A WPIAL team has lost in the semifinals three consecutive years. A year ago, North Allegheny was defeated by Plymouth-Whitemarsh, 71-47. In 2009, Mt. Lebanon lost to Penn Wood in the semifinals, 79-58. In '08, Moon lost to Norristown, 52-33.

"There are some excellent teams from the east that are placed in the western side and someone from the WPIAL is going to have to be pretty good to beat them," Mt. Lebanon coach Joe David said. "That said, I thought we had a legitimate chance to make the state championship last year and would've loved to play Ply-mouth-Whitemarsh in the semifinals. I thought we could've given them a game, but we lost along the way.

"Whether or not WPIAL teams can do it this year, I don't know. It may take an upset to get one of the WPIAL teams to the championship game because those teams from the east are pretty good and it's hard."

Since the PIAA threw out true East-West Region brackets in 2005, the only Western Pennsylvania team to make the Class AAAA final was Schenley, who played in the '06 and '07 title games. But those Schenley teams were exceptionally strong and featured DeJuan Blair and D.J. Kennedy. In recent history, those teams were the exception rather than the norm for Western Pennsylvania.

Only three WPIAL teams have made it to the AAAA title game since 2000 -- Uninontown in 2000 and '02, and Penn Hills in '04.

Advertise with us

In 27 years of Class AAAA championships, the only WPIAL teams to win AAAA titles have been Ringgold in 1995 and Penn Hills in '04. Schenley gave the City League its only AAAA championship in '07.

Since '05, two eastern teams have met in the PIAA final four of six times.

The eastern teams playing through the Class AAAA western bracket this year have some talented players. Darrun Hilliard is a 6-5 guard at Bethlehem Liberty who is a Villanova recruit. Penn Wood features 6-5 Aaron Brown, who has signed with West Virginia.

"I don't know if it's size that those eastern teams have over us. I think they just have more players," David said.

The PIAA had its reasons for abandoning the true East-West bracket six years ago. Class AAAA schools in the east complained that there shouldn't be equal PIAA qualifiers on the east and west when the east has many more Class AAAA teams. There are 139 Class AAAA boys teams in eastern districts, compared to 42 in western districts.

Advertise with us

So the PIAA took away some Class AAAA playoff spots from the west and put eastern teams in their spots. In the smaller classes, however, some western teams play through the eastern bracket, which could bring about a PIAA final with two western teams. For example, the 2007 Class A girls final matched North Catholic and Bishop Guilfoyle of Altoona.

Wally Blucas, chairman of District 10 (Erie area), proposed to the PIAA last spring that the league go back to true east-west brackets in all sports. But the PIAA Board of Control voted against his idea.

North Allegheny coach Dave DeGregorio also would like to see the PIAA go back to true east-west brackets. His team lost in the semifinals last year to Plymouth-Whitemarsh.

"I don't think we, as teams, get the respect in this area that we should," DeGregorio said. "I'm not going to be one that says WPIAL teams don't have much of a shot to get to the final because I think they do. I think basketball is getting better in this area and it wouldn't surprise me if a WPIAL team gets there -- and wins."

Defying the odds

Advertise with us

Three teams from the Pittsburgh area have won PIAA Class AAAA titles:

2007: Schenely defeats Chester 78-71

2004: Penn Hills defeats Parkland 57-48

1995: Ringgold defeats Williamsport 71-66