We pose the question at this time every year: Why doesn't the WPIAL play games to decide which of its teams get an opportunity to compete in the PIAA playoffs?

The WPIAL has always played follow-the-leader when determining some of its participants in the PIAA tournament.

For example, the WPIAL sends five teams to the PIAA playoffs in boys Class AAAA. The four semifinalists -- Gateway, Chartiers Valley, Butler and Mt. Lebanon -- advance and the team that loses to the eventual WPIAL champion in the quarterfinals, in this case Upper St. Clair.

Other PIAA districts have play-back games in their tournaments to decide which teams advance to the PIAA tournament. In the WPIAL, a team's PIAA fate is tied to an opponent's success or lack thereof.

Advertise with us

Shaler Area was the top seed in boys Class AAAA in the WPIAL playoffs. The Titans were edged by Butler, 50-47, in the quarterfinals and needed Butler to win the WPIAL title to keep its season alive.

The fact Shaler defeated Butler twice in the regular season doesn't matter. The fact Shaler crushed Upper St. Clair, 63-35, in a non-section game doesn't matter. The fact Shaler had a much better regular-season record than Upper St. Clair doesn't matter. The fact the WPIAL basketball steering committee thought enough of the Titans' resume to make them the No. 1 seed doesn't matter.

The only thing that matters is that Upper St. Clair was fortunate enough to play Gateway in the quarterfinals and that Gateway went on to win the championship. Upper St. Clair could have lost to Gateway, 100-1, -- Upper St. Clair played Gateway tough, losing by only four points -- but it was still going to the PIAA playoffs as long as the Gators won the title.

We understand where the WPIAL is coming from in its follow-the-leader policy in determining the teams the league sends to the PIAA tournament.

Every school knows the rules going into the WPIAL playoffs, so the playing field is level. It is costly to hold play-back games -- schools do not just kick open the doors to their gyms, there are rental fees to be paid. Attendance at play-back games probably would not be very good. It would be a logistic nightmare for the WPIAL while it is trying to put on a quality championship tournament, which it does.

Advertise with us

We aren't advocating complete play-backs. Just have the quarterfinalists playoff in a mini-tournament to determine the Nos. 5, 6, 7 and 8 teams in a classification. Hold them at one site and play two games in the morning and one in the afternoon.

Would it be a pain in the neck to set up something like that? Yes. Would it be a better way to determine which teams advance to the PIAA playoffs? We think so. Will it ever happen? No.

But it should be pointed out that in boys Class AAAA, two of the WPIALs top four seeds -- Shaler and North Allegheny -- are not in the PIAA field. In boys Class AA, No. 4-seed Quaker Valley is done for the season and in Class A No. 1 Rochester didn't make the PIAA tournament while Serra Catholic did.

On the girls side, Class AAA No. 3-seed South Park and Class AA No. 2- seed Riverside have had to pack away the uniforms.

One guy's MVP choices

Advertise with us

The WPIAL does not select most valuable players for its championship games. We have always thought that was a mistake. With that in mind, here are our MVPs for this year's finals at the Palumbo Center.

• Boys Class AAAA: Gateway's Tyler Scott, who scored 20 points in leading the Gators to victory.

• Boys Class AAA: Montour's Austin Heter, who scored 11 points, grabbed 9 rebounds and did a good job on defense in the Spartans upset against South Fayette.

• Boys Class AA: Monessen's Earl Pickney, who had 11 points and 10 rebounds as the Greyhounds topped Greensburg Central Catholic.

• Boys Class A: Vincentian's John Bray, who scored 21 points in the win against Lincoln Park.

Advertise with us

• Girls Class AAAA: Shaler's Shannon Powell, who had 14 rebounds and 8 points for the Titans in the upset of two-time defending champion Mt. Lebanon.

• Girls Class AAA: Blackhawk's Alexa Hayward, who had 21 points and connected on five 3-pointers in the win against rival Ambridge.

• Girls Class AA: Seton-LaSalle's Naje Gibson, a talented freshman who scored 16 points and grabbed 8 rebounds in the Rebels victory.

• Girls Class A: North Catholic's Kendall Hoffman, who scored 19 points and made a pair of 3-pointers as the Trojanettes won their 16th WPIAL title.

PIAA features tasty first-round menu

Advertise with us

The PIAA tournament got underway Tuesday with play-in games. First-round contests are Friday and Saturday and there are always a couple interesting confrontations.

Here are a few boys game worth checking out:

WPIAL runner-up Chartiers Valley (20-6) against City League champion Allderdice (16-7) in Class AAAA at 4:30 p.m. Saturday at Peabody; City runner-up Perry (21-3) vs. Blackhawk (17-8) at 7:30 p.m. Friday at Brashear; WPIAL Class AAA runner-up South Fayette (22-2) vs. District 10 runner-up General McLane (20-5) at 7:30 p.m. at Moon; North Catholic (19-7) vs. District 10 Class A champion Rocky Grove (18-7) at 6:30 p.m. Friday at Slippery Rock University.

An interesting girls game Saturday has WPIAL Class AAA runner-up Ambridge (20-7) meeting Franklin Area (23-2) at 4:30 p.m. at North Allegheny High School.