Random thoughts on the WPIAL basketball tournament:
• File this under it-will-never-happen department, but wouldn't it be interesting if the WPIAL gave the coaches of highly seeded teams the option of playing right away or taking a bye.
For example, Quaker Valley is the No. 4 seed in the boys Class AA field this year. The Quakers were given a bye because of the number of teams in Class AA that qualified for the playoffs. But what if the basketball steering committee went to the Quakers and gave them an option of playing right away or accepting a bye and waiting.
"I'd rather play than sit," Quaker Valley coach Mike Mastroianni said after the Quakers struggled to defeat Bishop Canevin, 44-30, a week ago. "We scrimmaged New Castle up there and it was a pretty good scrimmage, we played well. But a scrimmage isn't the same as a game."
The four boys Class AA teams that had byes -- Quaker Valley, Greensburg Central Catholic, Beaver Falls and Monessen -- won their first-round games. That wasn't the case in girls' Class AAA where four of eight teams that had byes -- Kittanning, Chartiers Valley, South Park and Montour -- lost their first games in the tournament. South Park was the No. 3 seed; Chartiers Valley No. 4.
And in girls Class AA, two of the eight teams that had byes -- Charleroi and Washington -- lost their first games.
Giving a coach the option of playing or sitting will never happen because of the logistics. It would be too time-consuming to call 20-some coaches and ask them if they'd like to have a bye. Not when the WPIAL basketball steering committee has just two days to put the tournament together.
But many coaches do not view a tournament bye as a good thing. In Quaker Valley's case, Mastroianni's team went 10 days without playing a game as did the Chartiers Valley girls.
• If the basketball steering committee's main job is to see that the top four seeds in each classification reach the semifinals, then the folks on chairman Dan O'Neil committee deserve a round of applause.
There are always going to be a few upsets, but most of the top seeds made it to the semifinals.
On the boys side, 10 of the 16 top-seeded teams were in the semis, while 11 of 16 made it for the girls.
The only classification which had all four top seeds reach the semifinals was girls Class AAAA where No. 1 Mt. Lebanon, No. 2 Shaler, No. 3 Bethel Park and No. 4 Oakland Catholic made it through.
• There is only one section -- boys or girls -- that had three teams reach the semifinals. The honor of toughest section goes to girls Section 2-AAA that had New Castle, Blackhawk and Ambridge in the final four. The Bridgers finished third in the section.
It should be pointed out that New Castle and Hopewell from Section 2-AAA were in the championship game last year.
• While we have been praising the basketball steering committee for a wonderful job, we do question the committee for putting Rochester and Clairton on the same side of the boys Class A bracket and then having them meet -- if they both won their first-round games, which they did -- in a quarterfinal.
Given the recent history between the two schools -- they have met in the WPIAL Class A football final at Heinz Field the past two seasons and played each other in a football semifinal in 2008 -- wouldn't it have made sense to put them on opposite sides of the bracket, or at least set it up so the Bears and Rams would have met in a semifinal.
OK, so Clairton came into the tournament with an 8-10 record and finished third in its section. Still, the Bears had won five in a row and appeared to have their act together.
• The next best thing to the WPIAL conducting its championship games at Duquesne's Palumbo Center or the Pitt Fieldhouse was when the league would have boys Class AAAA or AAA semifinal doubleheaders at one of those sites. Alas, that has happened for a few years. Too bad there isn't a high school gym in the area big enough to accommodate two games like that.
• Having one of the top scoring players in the league during the regular season doesn't guarantee a team a spot in a final ... or even a semifinal.
Highlands' Micah Mason, Norwin's Matt Palo and Trinity's Josh Valentic were the top three scorers, with each averaging 30 points or more a game. Their teams didn't make it to the semifinals.
The highest scoring player on a team in the semifinals was Lincoln Park's Chaquille Pratt, who averaged 22.7 ppg and was 17th on the Post-Gazette's list.
That wasn't the case on the girls side where Ciara Gregory of Jeannette, who averaged 20.4 ppg in the regular season and was third on the PG's list, helped the Jayhawks make the semifinals in Class AA.
On the air
For those who want a sneak peak at the WPIAL championship games Friday and Saturday at the Palumbo Center, the MSA Sports Network has just the thing.
MSA's WPIAL Roundball Report, which can be heard on the Internet on Wednesday during the season, will be 7:30-9 p.m. today. MSA operations manager Don Rebel will be joined by Sam Hall and former coach Johnny Lee in breaking down the title games. There will also be interviews with coaches.
To listen, go to www.msasportsnetwork.com and click on broadcasts. All of the shows on the MSA Sports Network are archived, so those who miss the show can listen to it later in the evening.
The MSA crew will also air the Class A and AAA boys championship games Friday and the Class AAAA boys and girls finals on Saturday on KQV-AM (1410) and on the Internet.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.