Never mind the one-two punch, in WPIAL Class AAAA boys basketball, it is the three-four punch that is most lethal come playoff time.
Sections 3 and 4 were thought to be strong before the season started, with both sections having a deep pool of quality teams. The strength of the two sections was evident in this year's WPIAL playoff seedings and also the first few days of the tournament.
But the combo has been strong for a while, at least compared to the other sections.
Eight of the top 10 seeds for the Class AAAA playoffs this season were from Sections 3 and 4 -- Shaler (No. 1 seed), Mt. Lebanon (2), North Allegheny (3), Upper St. Clair (5), Chartiers Valley (6), Moon (8), Butler (9) and Pine-Richland (10). Section 3 is made up of mostly north suburban teams, while Section 4 is mostly south suburban teams.
The only teams in the top 10 seeds not from Section 3 or 4 were Gateway (4) and Connellsville (7). Gateway plays in Section 2, which includes mostly east suburban teams. Section 1 has teams mostly from Westmoreland and Fayette counties.
While four Class AAAA first-round playoff games were still to be played Thursday night, two Section 4 teams -- Upper St. Clair and Chartiers Valley -- and one Section 3 team -- North Allegheny -- had already made it to Saturday's quarterfinals with victories last weekend in first-round games.
In first-round games played before Thursday night, Section 4 was 2-0, Section 3 was 1-0, Section 2 was 1-2 and Section 1 was 0-2.
But this is the continuation of a trend in Class AAAA. Consider these statistics before Thursday night's games were played:
• Since the WPIAL started taking four teams from each section to the playoffs in 2005, Section 4 qualified three teams for the quarterfinals six years in a row. Depending on Thursday night's games, the streak could go to seven this year.
• Before this season, the only other Class AAAA section to have three teams in the quarterfinals since 2005 was Section 3, which had three in 2009 and four in 2005. Before this season, Sections 1 and 2 have never had three teams in the quarterfinals since 2005.
• In the past seven seasons (excluding Thursday night's games), Section 4 has a 20-7 record in first-round games, Section 3 is 13-12, Section 2 is 11-15 and Section 1 is 8-18.
• Since the WPIAL started taking four teams to the playoffs in 2005, 16 of the 24 semifinalists have been from Sections 3 and 4. Two years ago, all four semifinalists were from Sections 3 and 4.
"I think what says a lot is that six of the past seven WPIAL [Class AAAA] champions have come from teams in our section," said Upper St. Clair coach Danny Holzer, whose Panthers compete in Section 4. "Top to bottom Section 3 was really impressive this year, but I don't think I could sit here and say [Section] 3 was better than [Section] 4, or 4 was better than 3.
"I can only say that the way this [playoff] thing has played out so far, I think it's pretty apparent that the teams in Sections 3 and 4 that didn't get in the playoffs, I feel pretty confident that they might have grabbed a playoff spot [if they played] in one of the other sections."
Of the teams in Section 1 this season, the last one to win a WPIAL Class AAAA title was Norwin in 1986. Of the teams in Section 2, the last to win a WPIAL title was Penn Hills in 1994 (although Central Catholic used to be a part of Section 2 and won a title three years ago).
So what gives? Why are Sections 3 and 4 dominating in recent years?
"I ... well .... I think it's hard to explain," said North Allegheny coach Dave DeGregorio, whose team plays in Section 3. "I don't really have an answer, but I think it is kind of weird."
Shaler plays in Section 3 and coach Paul Holzshu said, "I don't want to put a stamp on anything and say Sections 3 and 4 have superior players, programs or coaches than [Sections] 1 and 2. I think maybe it's just the natural phenomenon of things going in cycles."
Holzshu's point is well taken when examining the first few years of Class AAAA basketball. Class AAAA was formed for the 1983-84 season. In the next six seasons, Section 1 had three WPIAL champions and five Section 1 teams were title-game participants.
Holzshu coached a few years at Gateway before coming to Shaler.
"I think one of the things is that basketball has become a very, very strong thing at the schools in our section," he said. "And I know we have a lot of coaches who work hard."
But Holzshu said that doesn't mean coaches in Sections 1 and 2 aren't working hard. DeGregorio agreed.
"I know I see a lot of those Section 1 and 2 teams in spring and summer leagues, just like us," he said. "It's just really hard to say why this is happening [with Sections 3 and 4]."
Maybe coaching experience has something to do with it. In Sections 1 and 2, 10 of the 15 coaches have less than 10 years experience and four have taken a team to a WPIAL title game. In Sections 3 and 4, 13 of the 15 coaches have more than 10 years experience and nine have led a team to a WPIAL championship game.
"Maybe coaching has something to do with it, but that's not to say there aren't solid coaches in the other sections," Holzshu said.
Holzer said style of play might be an important factor.
"I think if you look back at all of the teams that have won WPIAL championships from our section, half-court defense has been a key for them," he said. "There aren't a lot of up-tempo type teams in our section, scoring 70 points a game that win [Class AAAA] championships."




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.