During the regular season Oakland Catholic competes in Section 3-AAAA against teams from the northern suburbs.
During the postseason it seems like Oakland Catholic has been competing in Section 4 with teams from the south suburbs.
In 2008 and '09 Oakland Catholic reached the WPIAL semifinals only to be turned away by two teams from Section 4, Upper St. Clair and Mt. Lebanon. Last year it was Peters Township, another Section 4 representative, bouncing the Eagles from the postseason.
This year another Section 4 gauntlet was laid out in front of Oakland Catholic when the WPIAL playoff pairings were announced. No. 4 seed Oakland Catholic (15-8) got past Upper St. Clair last Friday, 57-44, only to set up a WPIAL quarterfinal showdown against No. 5 seed Baldwin (17-5), yet another team from Section 4.
The two will meet Friday at a time and site to be determined.
The winner of the Baldwin/Oakland Catholic matchup will likely get a date against two-time WPIAL champion Mt. Lebanon of Section 4.
Oakland Catholic knows something about Mt. Lebanon, but Baldwin really knows about Mt. Lebanon. Baldwin has been eliminated by the Blue Devils every time the Highlanders have qualified for the playoffs since coach Dan Thayer took over six years ago. Baldwin lost to Mt. Lebanon four times in the playoffs in the past two seasons, including in the WPIAL championship game last season.
Nobody needs to tell the players on Baldwin that a win over Oakland would help set up a possible rematch with Mt. Lebanon.
"Obviously they are on the horizon after this ... if we win," Thayer said. "That is the only team we have lost to in the playoffs in forever and we are OK with that because Mt. Lebanon has been the best team the last couple years and that should give us some confidence."
The players on Baldwin also know it's all about first things first and for a reminder of what Oakland is capable of, all they need do is look back to the regular season when Oakland Catholic knocked off Baldwin, 49-34, in a non-section game on Jan. 8. The Eagles outscored Baldwin by 15 points in the second half after being tied at halftime.
"They are an athletic team," Thayer said. "They shoot the ball real well. They beat us by 15 last time, but now it is on a neutral court and I think we are playing a lot better than we were then."
What made that Oakland Catholic win even more impressive is that it came five days after Baldwin had secured its signature win of the year, a 48-46 win at Mt. Lebanon. The Blue Devils had won 60 consecutive games against in-state competition and owned a 12-game winning streak against Baldwin.
Mt. Lebanon evened the score in a rematch with Baldwin, winning 63-31 at Baldwin. That game would be remembered for more than the outcome as Baldwin lost its top player, Belma Nurkic with a concussion in the first half.
Nurkic a Duquesne University recruit, averaged 18.9 points per game but was forced to miss half of the Mt. Lebanon game and the next three games. Her teammates stepped up and Baldwin won three in a row against Canon-McMillan, Butler Area and Moon Area.
A noticeably rusty Nurkic returned to the lineup but was held to eight points in a 67-50 loss to Bethel Park in the regular-season finale. She returned to form in the first round of the playoffs with a 23-point effort in a 50-23 victory against Plum.
Oakland Catholic coach Shannon Boyle is well aware of what Nurkic brings to the table.
"We have seen a couple other teams with very good Division I players and she definitely fits into that category," Boyle said. "We are going to have to account for her."
Oakland Catholic's 13-point first-round win was sparked by double-digit scoring performances from Corey Taglianetti (15 points), Mara Fitzgerald (14) and Ally Schmidt (10). Schmidt has led the Eagles in scoring this season, averaging about 15 points per game.
It was defense that determined the outcome of the first Baldwin-Oakland meeting and it might be defense that determines this one. Oakland altered its defense against Baldwin in that game. Thayer said Oakland's defensive switch was a key to the regular-season win.
"They out-hustled us last time on defense. We have to out-hustle them this time," Thayer said. "We have to defend their shooting and control the boards. The game will come down to those three things."





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.