I am a little ashamed to admit it, but I did not see the movie "Hoosiers" until I was a freshman in college.
That might not sound so bad, except I was born and raised in the Hoosier State. I blame my parents, who deprived me of quality movies as a child. We are, after all, an Italian-American family, and just last fall I saw "The Godfather" for the first time in my life.
OK, maybe I'm getting far afield, here.
Back to "Hoosiers," the story of the small school that had no shot to win the Indiana state high school basketball tournament, but somehow did it anyway. I fell in love with the story, as did pretty much anybody who has watched the movie. It stands the test of time because the story is universal. Who doesn't love an underdog story?
That's why I shudder a bit during the WPIAL playoffs. The Keystone State does a lot of things better than the Hoosier State. High school basketball playoffs is not one of them.
I wish Pennsylvania would adopt an open tournament.
I'm not saying abandon the class system, in which school's compete against one another based on enrollment. Even Indiana adopted the class system in the late 1990s, although some still favor the good ol' days -- when every school competed for the same title -- for sentimental reasons.
Instead, I'm advocating every team earn a spot in the WPIAL playoffs.
An open tournament creates a lot more excitement than the current setup, and not only because more teams are involved.
It gives underdogs one more chance to knock off some of the area's powerhouses. Those games are why people love March Madness.
And, perhaps most importantly, it provides more opportunities for kids in the area, not just to improve, but to build relationships and create lasting memories.
Those in favor of the status quo argue an open tournament devalues the regular season. But an open tournament still rewards regular-season performance by giving top-performing teams a higher seed. And I don't think there is any less incentive for a team to compete at a high level just because a few extra teams qualify for the playoffs.
Every major college basketball conference conducts an open tournament. But teams still compete hard during the regular season, whether they are playing for conference titles, a better tournament seed or, simply, respect.
Some also argue the current system helps weed out the bad teams, which an open tournament would allow play in the postseason.
I don't know if that's necessarily a great thing. What's so wrong with allowing a bunch of bad teams to play one more game in a season? Worst-case scenario, they provide a tune-up for some of the top teams in the WPIAL as they gear for a playoff run. Best-case scenario, they pull off a shocking upset that will likely be the story of the season.
Besides, the current setup does not do a great job of creating an elite tournament. Thirty-two teams with losing records qualified for this season's boys and girls playoffs. My colleague Rich Emert, who admits he would prefer even fewer teams in the WPIAL playoffs, did a little research on the subject. There were 261 boys and girls high school basketball teams in the WPIAL this season, and only 100 were eliminated from playoff contention.
On the girls side, all six teams from Class AAA Section 1 and all six teams from Class AAA Section 4 qualified, though three in each section had section records of 2-8.
Those here in the office who have a bit more tenure than I do say the WPIAL tried an open tournament in 1984 and it was a disaster. Why not figure out what went wrong and try to correct those mistakes?
Maybe it's time to revisit the idea.
A Plum season
Though its season has come to an end, the Plum girls basketball team can celebrate its first winning campaign since the 2007-08 season.
Senior Lindsay Deemer, junior Karleigh Weichler and sophomore Angelena Borriello are three standouts on a balanced Plum team.
The Mustangs (12-10) won six of their last nine games to earn the third of four playoff spots from Class AAAA Section 2. Plum lost to Baldwin, 50-23, in the first round of the WPIAL playoffs.
A peak season for Valley
The Valley girls basketball team lost 20 games in each of the past three seasons and had not made the playoffs since the 2002-03 season.
They broke those bad streaks this season under difficult circumstances.
Attrition and injuries forced the Vikings to play for several weeks toward the end of the season with just five girls in uniform, coach Jeff Cheatham said. At times, in-game injuries or foul disqualifications forced the Vikings to play with fewer than five players on the court.
Valley finished with an 8-15 record and was one of the six-team contingent to qualify from the playoffs out of Class AAA Section 1.
Lashay Madison, a freshman, led the Vikings, averaging nearly 15 points per game this season.
The Vikings dressed seven players during a 67-22 preliminary-round loss to Thomas Jefferson.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.