Peabody High School didn't have as many "great" basketball teams as Schenley over the years, but Peabody still has a rich athletic tradition.
And like Schenley, Peabody sports teams will only have memories because Peabody also is closing at the end of the school year.
At one time, Peabody had tremendous baseball and track programs in the City League. Peabody also had some excellent basketball teams and football teams.
"I think it's a very nostalgic time for a lot of people associated with the City League," said Ken McDonough, 78, Peabody's highly successful baseball coach from 1965-92.
"Are we getting rid of everything these days? It would be nice if we ever got this world built. We just keep constantly changing things over and over. But I guess that's just the way it is."
McDonough won eight City League baseball championships from 1969-92 before retiring. His teams also were highly competitive against top WPIAL squads.
McDonough had a rare coaching relationship with Norm Frey. In basketball season, McDonough was Frey's assistant coach. In baseball season, Frey was McDonough's assistant coach.
Frey, revered as one of the greatest coaches in City League history, won five City League titles in basketball and six in baseball before relinquishing the baseball duties to McDonough.
In basketball, Melvin Bennett was one of Frey's best players, and Bennett led Peabody to the 1974 PIAA Class AAA title game. Bennett went on to play at Pitt and in the NBA.
Decades ago, Peabody had some excellent football teams under coach Joe Hnath and dominated track and field for decades. Nine Peabody graduates have played in the NFL, including running back Kevan Barlow (2001-06), defensive lineman Mike Barnes (1973-81) and defensive lineman Dave Logan (1979-87).
Ken Saybel played baseball at Peabody in the late 1960s and now is the director of athletics at Schenley.
"It's actually a real sad time for me because of the two schools," Saybel said. "Every sport at these two schools now has its last game ever this year. It's sad."
McDonough said: "What bothers me the most is I see this Western Chapter of the Pennsylvania Sports Hall of Fame around for a long time and other halls of fame. Where the heck are all the old City League athletes in these things? I don't see anything being done with City League kids."




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.