The PIAA has an officials' evaluator at each of its basketball tournament games. We'd like to see what that person at the Rocherster-Mercyhurst Prep Class AA boys' quarterfinal jotted down.

By now it is common knowledge that Mercyhurst Prep, the District 10 champion, defeated Rochester, the WPIAL runner-up, by nine points this past Saturday afternoon.

Hopefully, it is also common knowledge that Mercyhurst Prep attempted 26 free throws, making 16, while Rochester was 2 for 2 at the line.

Did we mention that the game was played at Edinboro University's McComb Field House, which is in the heart of District 10?

Advertise with us

Now, we have always contended that officials at the high-school level have never won or lost a game for a team. But when one team shoots 26 free throws and the other two ...

It's not that unusual in the PIAA playoffs for a team to shoot 10 more free throws than its opponent, especially if one team is fouling at the end to stop the clock in an effort to catch up. But it sends up a red flag when one team shoots 24 more free throws.

Had Rochester shot just half as many free throws as Mercyhurst Prep -- 13 -- and made them, it would have won.

Rams' coach Paul Long was understandably upset after the contest. Not only did his team have to drive to Edinboro and play on a court that Mercyhurst Prep had played on in the first round of the PIAA playoffs, he had to watch the Lakers stroll to the foul line 26 times.

"I saw that," WPIAL executive director Tim O'Malley said Monday. "Have I received any phone calls? No.

Advertise with us

"It [officiating] is an imperfect science."

We realize that the style of basketball varies in different regions of the state. Some teams -- and officials -- are not used to going against teams with a number of athletic players. But teams in District 10, which takes in schools from the Farrell/Sharon area all the way to Erie -- basically, the entire northwest corner of the state -- for the most part play the same style as those in the WPIAL.

So why the huge gap in the number of free-throws attempted?

More head scratching

While on the subject of District 10, we can't help but wonder why Mercyhurst Prep has not played a PIAA tournament game outside of its district? That includes Wednesday night's Class AA semifinal against South Fayette, which was scheduled for Meadville High School.

Advertise with us

Hey, we are all for district champions enjoying some home cooking in the PIAA playoffs, but it appears as if Mercyhurst Prep had a standing reservation inside District 10.

Its first-round game was at Edinboro University, its second-round contest was at Kennedy Catholic High in Hermitage, it played Rochester at Edinboro and now Meadville.

"The PIAA tries to find a mid-way point [between schools] for games," O'Malley said. "The logical mid-way point for Rochester and Mercyhurst Prep would have been Meadville, but that site was unavailable and the game ended up at Edinboro.

"That's the thing that fans don't understand ... sometimes midway places just aren't available."

We could understand Mercyhurst Prep playing close to home if its opponent was another District 10 team, but all of its opponents in the PIAA playoffs have been from the WPIAL.

Advertise with us

We are not pointing a finger at Mercyhurst Prep officials. The Lakers are just going where they are told. But shouldn't the PIAA folks in Mechanicsburg or the District 10 honchos be paying attention?

Or maybe the District 10 folks are paying attention. Hm-m-m-m-m?

TV coverage

For fans who can't make it to University Park, Pa., for the PIAA championships Friday and Saturday, the games will be televised on the Pennsylvania Cable Network.

• Game times Friday are: Noon, Class AA girls; 2 p.m., Class A boys; 6 p.m., Class AAAA girls; 8 p.m., Class AAA boys.

Advertise with us

• Game times Saturday are: Noon, Class A girls; 2 p.m., Class AA boys; 6 p.m., Class AAA girls; 8 p.m., Class AAAA boys.

Replays of the championship games will be shown by PCN Sunday and early Monday morning, and on April 2.

Also on PNC, there will be a preview show for the PIAA championship games starting at 7 p.m. today.

The reason why

For those wondering why District 1 (Suburban Philadelphia) and District 3 (Harrisburg and south central Pennsylvania) have nine and seven teams, respectively, in both the boys' and girls' Class AAAA brackets in the PIAA playoffs, while the WPIAL has just five, here is the reason.

Advertise with us

The PIAA uses the number of schools a district has in a certain classification to determine how many teams from that district advance to its playoffs.

The WPIAL, for example, has 29 schools with Class AAAA boys' teams. But District 1 has 51 and District 3 has 41. The PIAA decided those two districts should have the most teams in the Class AAAA field, which makes sense.

In Class AA, the WPIAL sends eight boys' team to the PIAA tournament. That's because the WPIAL has 40 schools, more than twice as many as any other district except one, with Class AA boys' teams.