Tony Court became mayor of Ellwood City a year ago. He feels what prepared him most for the job was, of all things, officiating high school basketball for almost three decades.
"Officiating prepped me in how you have to deal with people, and the complaints they might have," said Court.
Basketball fans likely have yelled at and complained to officials since James Naismith nailed the first peach baskets to the wall. It might be the hardest sport to officiate because of the volume of calls in a game. Many are judgement calls. But most officials, including Court, and also those involved in high school athletics will tell you that what makes basketball the hardest sport to officiate are the fans, especially over the past decade or so.
Everyone from officials, to high school athletic directors, to those who run the WPIAL believe poor fan behavior toward basketball officials has been at its all-time worst in recent years -- and the sometimes vile behavior reaches a crescendo this time of year because it is playoff time. The WPIAL boys' and girls' basketball championships are today and tomorrow at Duquesne University's Palumbo Center.
It seems dealing with verbal swipes is part of earning your stripes.
"I still love it and I still enjoy the excitement that goes along with officiating," said Court, 52, who has officiated WPIAL basketball games for 29 years. "But I do agree that it's tougher on officials these days. I think it's gotten to the point where people watch so many games on TV and watch how some of those fans act toward officials at college games, and it filters down to the high school level."
Just a few weeks ago, North Hills played host to a WPIAL first-round game. North Hills athletic director Dan Cardone, the WPIAL game manager, noticed a fan was so upset at officials that he went into the stands and sat with the adult man for a few moments.
"I told him he was out of line," Cardone said. "But I took him a bottle of water, too, and told him, 'If you're acting this way, you have to be dehydrated. Drink this.' I remember one time I took a group of Sto-Rox fans bottles of water because of how outraged they were at the officials."
Only a year ago at a WPIAL Class A semifinal, a fan, Donald Kirkwood of New Castle, came out of the stands during a fight involving his nephew, a player for Neshannock. When the officials asked him to leave, he became upset and was arrested by police.
It was only six years ago that a fan, Peter Dukovich, came out of the stands and body-slammed an official, Ron Bell, onto the court. Bell was taken to the hospital and suffered a concussion, and Dukovich, whose son was playing in the game, was charged with simple assault.
Those are the extreme cases, but Cardone said, "We have hosted many playoff games in the past few years, and I definitely have noticed the increase in fans' vocality toward officials. The WPIAL has schools read a sportsmanship message to the crowd before the game, and we make announcements about behavior. Then, at the jump ball to start the game, all that stuff gets thrown out the window."
Officials wanted
To become a registered official with the PIAA (governing body of Pennsylvania high school athletics), an individual must first pass an officials test, concerning rules, etc. Nowadays, officials must also submit background clearances to the PIAA.
Once registered, an individual usually joins an officials chapter. Schools generally use chapters to assign officials to their games. There are 19 officials chapters around the WPIAL and Pittsburgh City League with 840 registered officials.
Bill Sinning officiated district high school basketball for 28 years and now assigns officials to all WPIAL playoff games. He says fewer younger people are becoming basketball officials these days -- and one of the main reasons is because they don't want to put up with the fans' behavior.
Basketball is different than just about any other sport because fans are so close to the playing surface.
"It's becoming harder to get people for junior-high games," Sinning said. "It used to be that younger people who wanted to learn officiating would work those games. Now it's gone the other way. We can't get the young people, and the ones we have to get to work junior-high games are lower officials who have been around for a while.
"We're really hurting for younger officials because I think those young people hear the way spectators act on every call made, and they don't want to be part of it. It's not so much that people complain about a call. People are going to disagree, and that's fine. It's the behavior and what is said. It gets personal when fans start yelling at an official, 'Hey Baldy' or 'Hey Fatso.' "
Women officials are hard to find -- and a competent woman official can move up the ladder quickly. Bridget Borelli, 36, is in only her second year of officiating and already is working big playoff games. She officiated the WPIAL Class AA semifinal Tuesday between Seton-LaSalle and Avonworth.
"I know I'm crazy, but you have to be a little crazy to do this [officiating]," said Borelli, who coached grade-school basketball for nine years. "I started doing this just to stay active with kids, to stay involved in the game and to give back because a lot of officials gave back when I played. I love it."
But Borelli acknowledges hearing the complaints from fans. Some of the comments are just because she's a woman.
"They'll yell things like, 'They let you do this?' or 'That's why they don't put women on these games,' " Borelli said, with a laugh. "You just have to have thick skin. If you don't have thick skin, it's not going to happen for you."
Pam Cherubin assigns officials for WPIAL girls' playoff games. She was an official for 28 years and used to work Division I women's college games.
"I see folks just venting more anger than I ever have in the past," Cherubin said. "Sports used to be an extracurricular activity, and it was a privilege to play. I just see so many parents nowadays who think it's their kids' right to play, and they're going to express their opinions if they think a call is against their child. But, really, I think it's a society thing, too, where nowadays it's just acceptable to yell at people and not be respectful of them."
Working the big games
No one is making a living from officiating high school basketball games. During the regular season, officials earn anywhere from $55 to $75 for a game. For the WPIAL playoffs (boys and girls), officials make $60 for first-round games, $65 for quarterfinals, $70 for semifinals and $75 for championships. The WPIAL has a rule that an official can work a championship game only once every three years.
"That's just to maybe give more people a chance at working the finals," Sinning said.
Officials are picked for playoff games based mainly on merit, Sinning said. At the start of the playoffs, all officials chapters submit a list to the WPIAL of officials who are worthy -- and available -- to work playoff games. The WPIAL also asks each school for a list of officials' names they would consider worthy to work playoff games.
"But that doesn't mean the names on that school's list will work their games," Sinning said.
An evaluator is present at all WPIAL playoff games and grades each official on his or her performance. The evaluator fills out a form where some areas of officiating are weighted more than others. Appearance and demeanor, whistle, voice and communication are all 5 percent of the grade. Confidence/court presence counts for 10 percent, consistency 15 percent, mechanics 20 percent and judgment/rules 35 percent.
Those who rate the highest get more playoff games, "but I will say that one bad night doesn't always take them out," Sinning said.
For every round of playoffs, Sinning and Cherubin give WPIAL executive director Tim O'Malley a list of what officials are working games. Sinning said it's rare when O'Malley makes a change to the list.
"The people I've met through officiating has been great, and there are a lot of great coaches to deal with," Court said. "I love the excitement of it. But some guys get into this and think it's all peaches and cream, and they're gung-ho for a while. Then, in a few years, they say, 'This isn't for me.'"





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.