Personally, an "American Idol" tryout would be "American Nightmare." I lack rhythm and voice, and the nerve to endure a Simon Cowell brickbat. Nevertheless, for the fourth year in a row, it's time to sing the praises of PG West boys' hoops, better known as "The Shrummies":

Best Player -- Herb Pope, Aliquippa. The New Mexico State Aggies are getting a mobile big guy with an all-around game. Teammate Jonathan Baldwin and Beaver Falls sophomore Todd Thomas aren't far back.

Best Team -- Aliquippa. The Quips had quite a test last night, against Jeannette in the Western final. An upset was possible. But going into that one, no one in the entire WPIAL was better. The Quips, averaging 83.1 points, may be the best Beaver Valley team since the fabled '67 Ambridge squad. This season's Bridgers are No. 2 in this category.

Best Team Story -- West Allegheny. For years, hoops aficionados will rave about George Mason's shocking burst to the Final Four last year. West Allegheny's run was equally impressive. Had a 16th or 17th seed -- the Indians had to win a play-in game -- ever won a WPIAL title before? West A defeated a No. 1 seed (Greensburg Salem) and a 3 (Chartiers Valley) en route to the crown. Then again, CV coach Tim McConnell was right when he said after the title game: "That was not a 16th seed."

Advertise with us

Second-Best Team Story -- Monaca's revival. The Indians went 15-9 and to the playoffs two years after going 5-18.

Classiest Team -- Aliquippa, for collecting donations for the family of a Center cheerleader who died in an auto accident a few weeks earlier. The Quips presented money for the Chelsey Roman Fund to her mother on Senior Night at Center. These kids excel at a lot more than basketball.

Most Improved Team -- Carlynton. The Cougars went from 9-15 to 22-5 and berths in the WPIAL quarterfinals and PIAA second round.

Best Coach -- Josh Bears, West Allegheny. It was obvious at the Palumbo Center that this was a really good team, very cohesive. One question: How the heck were these guys 6-9 overall, 2-4 in section and on the brink of playoff elimination at one point this season?

Biggest Surprise -- Moon Area not winning a WPIAL title. This is no knock. When you rule WPIAL Class AAA for three years, the bar is way up there. The Tigers weren't golden in Quad-A this winter, but they were close, finishing 25-5, prevailing in a tough section and reaching the state's Elite Eight. They remain top cats.

Advertise with us

Best Game -- Aliquippa-Jeannette, WPIAL AA final. This one proved that someone other than Schenley and the Phoenix Suns can match baskets with the Quips. It also may have been the second-most entertaining game in WPIAL history, behind the Lance Jeter Show two years ago.

Under the Radar Award -- Robert Barnes, Langley. With little acclaim, this senior averaged 25.1 points and sparked the Mustangs' one-year rise from 3-20 to 10-14. City coaches noticed Barnes, selecting him first-team all-league, a notable accomplishment considering the talent there.

Best Fans -- West Allegheny. No, that wasn't the blizzard of '93. Those were West A students, 500-plus in white shirts, jammed into the end zone balcony at the Palumbo Center. Then they wore all red for the first round of states. Talk about a rainbow coalition ... color these kids great supporters.

Comeback Player of the Year -- Derek Moye, Rochester. This Penn State football recruit missed most of his junior hoops season with an injury. This winter, he played in every game and averaged 18.6 points.

Mr. Intensity Award -- Todd Thomas, Beaver Falls, in a landslide. He is the first human capable of glaring at himself without a mirror. This exceptional sophomore demands a lot of himself, and his team, every play. But smile once in a while, Todd.

Advertise with us

Dam Good Season -- The Western Beaver Golden Beavers. They went 19-8 and won a PIAA game for the first time.

Good Shepherd Award -- Rev. Rod Smith, Ellwood City coach. Even after he took over, the Wolverines didn't seem to have a prayer, going 1-21 in his first season. Two years later, they were an improved 7-15 and competitive in a tough AAA section. The Wolverines should be better next winter, but increased responsibilities at his church forced Smith to quit despite another three-year contract offer.

Worst Decision -- The WPIAL, for disdaining PIAA qualifier games. OK, these people are unfairly maligned; they do the right thing most of the time. But your fifth and sixth seeds in the state tournament shouldn't be determined by who lost in the quarterfinals to the eventual champ and runner-up. Let the quarterfinalists play off for berths. Other PIAA districts do.

Class Act Award -- AA, easily the best classification in the WPIAL. A number of big-school powerhouses from the mid-'70s -- Aliquippa, Jeannette, Beaver Falls, Monessen -- have endured losses of mills and population in their towns, yet remained strong.

Nostradamus Award -- Our preseason PG West Fabulous Five for 2007-08: Jonathan Baldwin, Aliquippa; Todd Thomas, Beaver Falls; Brian Walsh, Moon Area; David Phillips, Beaver Falls; Antoine Childs, Blackhawk.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.