Personally, an "American Idol" tryout would be "American Nightmare." I lack rhythm and voice, and the nerve to endure a Simon Cowell brickbat. Nevertheless, for the seventh year in a row, it's time to sing the praises of PG South boys' hoops, a.k.a. "The Shrummies":

Best Player -- Mike Sherry, Chartiers Valley. He's an exceptional shooter, but more important, he's a scorer. Even when Sherry is off, he will get points -- he wasn't sharp in the WPIAL title-game loss to West Allegheny, yet rang up 30. West Mifflin standout Chris Giles is the runner-up.

Best Team -- Bethel Park. Up-tempo teams believe that defense is what you put around de yard to keep de neighbors out. Not the Black Hawks, who were outstanding at stifling the opposition. They also were a neat blend of complementary players. Two years ago, you could see a WPIAL champion in the making. Chartiers Valley was second in WPIAL AAA, and is second in this category.

Coach of the Year -- Mike Mastroianni, Bethel Park. At first glance, and 50th glance, Mastroianni comes off as Waldo without the specs: quiet, even-tempered, always in that tan sweater. His coaching resume is splashy, though. It includes two WPIAL gold medals and a PIAA silver, courtesy partly of his time at Quaker Valley. This guy has put together a quality program at Bethel. Tim McConnell of Char Valley is second for overseeing the ...

Advertise with us

Best Team Story. OK, the Colts had Sherry and they dropped in classification, theoretically making them a favorite in AAA. And they did reach the WPIAL final. Still, this team was amazing, winning 23 times, rolling to the Section 4 title and earning district silver despite multiple injuries, a half-season suspension, a kid moving and a decided dearth of size.

Best Game -- The second and third Bethel Park-Moon matchups. Bethel won by 14 on the road in the first one, a surprise in the ease with which it occurred. The Tigers prevailed by two in the section rematch, then by three in overtime in the first round of states.

Best Rivalry -- Mt. Lebanon-Upper St. Clair ... forever, in just about every sport. The first game at USC ended in chaos, leading to airtight security for the second -- the dogs were bigger and more ominous than Andrew Devlin. But the games are always competitive and exciting, and the kids revel in facing one another. The Blue Devils and Panthers are the epitome of the term "arch-rivals," although Serra Catholic and Clairton are a representative second. Bethel Park-Moon, if the Tigers remain in Quad-A, could be a great one as well.

Best Fans -- Chartiers Valley. The Colts' stable of supporters is always large and loud without degenerating into ugliness -- as happens too frequently in Section 4-AAAA. Students there should curb the enthusiasm.

Best Foot Forward Award -- Steve Swiech, Elizabeth Forward. This 6-foot-9 Akron recruit had another dominating season, averaging 24.6 points. He did so despite a left foot that, at best, was 85 percent recovered from a stress fracture incurred 13 months ago. Swiech had nerve damage and still goes to physical therapy, but played on -- and well.

Advertise with us

Biggest Surprise -- Serra Catholic's lack of medals. No offense intended, Eagles. We just thought you'd end up with WPIAL and/or PIAA jewelry. This was a highly exciting team that went 24-4, swept two section games from Clairton and had the look of a WPIAL Class A champ -- until its semifinal encounter with a peaking Leechburg bunch. The Eagles also went on to the state quarterfinals

Under the Radar Award -- Brandon Bradley, South Park. The Eagles struggled this season, finishing 6-17. That obscured Bradley's play, which was at a high level; he averaged 23.5 points. Coaches in 4-AAA were well aware, however, voting him first-team all-section. Although he averaged 16.4 points, topped 1,000 for his career and made first-team All-Section 4-AAA, Dom DeCicco is a worthy runner-up. His football exploits overshadow his basketball abilities.

Teams to Watch in '08 -- Keystone Oaks and Steel Valley. Life in Section 4-AAA is fast-paced and fraught with peril -- Char Valley is there. But the Golden Eagles and Ironmen should be strong next winter. KO had two marvelous younger players this season, junior Jimmy Taylor and sophomore Corey Bellovich. Steel Valley will have seven of its first eight players back, including Ryan Sabo, Mike Carr and Nick Siniawski.

Worst Decision -- The WPIAL, for disdaining PIAA qualifier games. OK, these people are unfairly maligned; they do the right thing most of the time. But your fifth and sixth seeds in the state tournament shouldn't be determined by who lost in the quarterfinals to the eventual champ and runner-up. Let the quarterfinalists play off for berths. Other PIAA districts do.

Class Act Award -- AA, easily the best classification in the WPIAL. A number of big-school powerhouses from the mid-'70s -- Aliquippa, Jeannette, Beaver Falls, Monessen -- have endured losses of mills and population in their towns, yet remained strong.

Advertise with us

Nostradamus Award -- Our preseason PG South Fabulous Five for 2007-08: Quintin Harding, McKeesport Area; Christian Shea, Upper St. Clair; Ryan Sabo, Steel Valley; Jim Taylor, Keystone Oaks; Pat Grubbs, Serra Catholic.

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.