The first half of section play is over, and it's become clear WPIAL Class AAAA boys' basketball needs an all points bulletin -- for all the missing points.

If you haven't noticed, a number of Class AAAA teams are having trouble scoring. But a lack of points hasn't stopped some teams from having successful seasons.

A number of recent games have involved teams scoring in the 40s and even the 30s. Last Friday, the top four teams in Section 3 played each other. North Hills beat North Allegheny, 38-33, in one game. Pine-Richland beat Shaler, 39-22, in the other. Also last week, in a game featuring two of the better teams in Class AAAA, Mt. Lebanon defeated Bethel Park, 35-34.

Sixth-grade teams routinely score in the 30s.

Advertise with us

Overall, only 41 percent of the teams in WPIAL Class AAAA are averaging 55 points or more in section games. That's the lowest among all four classifications. In Class AAA, 63 percent of the teams are averaging 55 points in section play, 47 percent in Class AA and 56 percent in Class A.

Eleven of the 29 teams in Class AAAA are averaging 50 points or less in section play. Section 3 is the place where the offense is most anemic. The average score in Section 3 games is 50-41.

Teams aren't necessarily holding the ball, either. So, what gives when the schools with the largest enrollments are putting up the smallest numbers on the basketball court?

Coaches say the reasons for the lack of offense are excellent defensive play, good coaches who scout thoroughly and take away an opponent's offensive sets, a lack of talented offensive players who can beat defenders off the dribble, and, get this, some coaches say there is "overcoaching" going on. In other words, some coaches want their offensive sets run to a "T" and don't give players freedom to improvise.

Howie Ruppert is a former assistant coach at Seton Hall and Duquesne University and is now Shaler's head coach.

Advertise with us

"I really do think there are a lot of coaches around here who really teach kids how to play defense," he said.

But Ruppert also believes individual talent is lacking.

"People get mad at this quote, but there aren't a lot of players around here at the moment who can do things like a Division I college player, such as beating people off the dribble, playing above the rim, having great quickness and ability to create offensively," he said.

"You can overcoach by scrutinizing every single play and not allowing for personality and free play. I'm guilty of that sometimes. But in order to give kids that freedom, they have to show they deserve it. It's like giving a kid the keys to the car. You hope he has the responsibility to not drive like a crazy maniac. But when you look at the accidents, you might not want to give him that freedom. It's the same way with playing."

North Hills coach Buzz Gabos is in his first season in Section 3 after seven years at Class A Vincentian. But years ago, he was an assistant at North Hills.

Advertise with us

"I think the low scoring has been this way in Section 3 for a long time," Gabos said. "I think part of it is you have teams that you know are going to lock people up defensively just about every night. I think rather than get those teams into a fast-paced game, you play the way they play."

Upper St. Clair is averaging only 48 points in section games.

"I think one of the main reasons for the low scores is a lot of coaches watch so much film nowadays and that wasn't done years ago," said Danny Holzer, Upper St. Clair's coach. "Their teams make it hard to score on your initial set and I think coaches are emphasizing defense more."

Not all games in Class AAAA are low scoring. The average score in Section 1 is 63-54. Central Catholic is averaging 77 points in Section 2 games. Franklin Regional is averaging 70 points in Section 1 games after failing to average 50 points in section games the past three seasons. The Panthers' overall record during that time was 21-51. This season, they are 10-5 overall and 5-2 in section.

"To be honest, over the last two years we weren't winning and our kids really weren't having fun with the system we were running," Franklin Regional coach Doug Kelly said. "We decided, whether we win or not, we were going to change our system this year. We're giving up more points this year, but the bottom line is the kids are having fun and we're winning.

Advertise with us

"We've just opened up the floor more and tried to push the ball more."

But Franklin Regional played one team from Section 4 (Upper St. Clair) and one from Section 3 (Shaler) -- and lost both games. The scores were 61-43 and 39-36.

"Shaler was as good a coached team as we've seen the last three years," Kelly said. "We know if we get into the playoffs, we're going to get into some games like that."