A game such as this is why these two teams should never have been separated.

Hate? That's too strong a word.

Just call it a "healthy dislike" when Central Catholic and Fox Chapel get together on the basketball floor.

Last night, after a two-year hiatus from being in the same section, the two had a classic matchup.

Advertise with us

In the end, Fox Chapel (12-4, 6-0) grabbed control of WPIAL Class AAAA Section 2 with a 73-70 overtime victory at Central Catholic. The Vikings (11-4, 4-1) came into the game as the Post-Gazette's No. 1-ranked Class AAAA team and the front-runners in the section. It was the fifth consecutive victory for the Foxes.

Fox Chapel's offense showed balance as Ahmed Abu-Elmagd scored 17, John Hastings had 16, Seth Eisner 15 and Terry Hartford 12 off the bench. Central Catholic's Chris Saltzman led all scorers with 31 and Joe Berenato finished with 19.

Out of the gate, it looked as if both teams would make a run at putting up triple digits. Central Catholic hit its first 5 of 8 3-pointers, and Fox Chapel hit on 5 of 7 long-range shots early to tie the score at 21-21 after the first quarter.

To say the early pace was frenzied would be a gross understatement as often times each offense held the ball for less than 10 seconds before shooting. And these weren't the garden variety jumpers either, as Berenato let a few fly from several feet behind the arc as did Fox Chapel's Eisner.

"To be honest, they are more used to that style than we are," Fox Chapel coach Ben O'Connor said. "But I think the best thing that happened was that it went up and down like that early. It settles us in, and we were thrown right into the middle of it and responded."

Advertise with us

The game slowed in the second half and went to overtime after a controversial end to regulation. With the score tied, 66-66, Abu-Elmagd drove to the basket with less than one second to play in an attempt to win it for the Foxes. Contact was made by a Central defender under the basket, and the officials looked as if they were going to call a foul. After conferring for a few minutes, the officials ruled the foul came after the buzzer, sending the game into overtime.

"This might seem like I am being politically correct or something, but I didn't mind that we went to overtime," O'Connor said. "To have a chance to win that way wouldn't have been the right way to do it."

But Fox Chapel outscored the hosts, 7-4, in overtime and, when Saltzman's 3-pointer at the buzzer hit the back rim and bounced out, O'Connor's team escaped with one of its biggest wins in recent history.

Through the years, the Fox Chapel-Central basketball rivalry has proven one of the most bitter matchups in the WPIAL. Last night was no different. Numerous fans, including several Foxes supporters who made the short trip across the Highland Park Bridge, were packed into a cramped Alumni Hall along Fifth Avenue to see Fox Chapel win just its fifth game in 22 visits.

"I think everything people needed to know about our team can be summed up in how Fox Chapel reacted at the end," Central Catholic coach Chuck Crummie said, alluding to the Foxes, who rushed the floor along with some of their fans.

"Had we won, we wouldn't have been that excited about it. But, for them, it was like they had just won the WPIAL championship. To me, that says that they didn't think they would win this one. But, we saw them celebrating and we'll remember that. We'll definitely remember that."