Taylor Lehman has everything Major League Baseball scouts covet in a pitcher. He has abundant size, standing 6 feet 8 and weighing 225 pounds. He is a left-hander and throws in the low 90s with potential to add more velocity as he matures.
The one thing Lehman is searching for — and likely the element of his game that will determine when he is drafted in the MLB entry draft in June — is consistency.
Lehman, a 2014 graduate of Keystone Oaks High School, has been a member of Penn State’s weekend rotation since his freshman season. His 3-15 record as a college pitcher might not seem the stuff of MLB prospects, but there is much more to the story.
In 8 of his 10 starts last season, Lehman had three runs or fewer in run support. And while his 4.79 ERA wasn’t great, he did strike out 47 batters in 67⅔ innings.
“There have been glimpses of him being the dominant player we thought he was going to be, and the player we still think he will be,” Penn State coach Rob Cooper said. “It just comes down to doing it consistently.”
What has MLB scouts intrigued is Lehman’s performance at the Cape Cod League last summer. In the premier amateur summer league in the country, Lehman put it all together for Cotuit Kettlers when he posted a 3-1 record with a 3.19 ERA.
After a rough start in which he gave up eight earned runs in his first 8⅔ innings, Lehman allowed just three earned runs over his final 21⅔ innings. He showed off his fastball, his slider and worked on his changeup, a pitch he hopes to incorporate more this season for the Nittany Lions.
Cooper doesn’t think Lehman’s record will be a big turnoff for MLB teams. The circumstances around it and his potential are expected to outweigh it in the evaluation process.
“When he got here it was my second year, and we were in a pretty serious rebuild,” Cooper said. “He’s had plenty of quality outings for us, but you need more than one guy to win a game. He dominated in the Cape Cod League. A lot of scouts will look at that. They’ll look at his frame and his velocity. And then they’ll get to know him and his great makeup and how much he cares about the game. They’re going to love him.”
Lehman was drafted by the Miami Marlins in the 34th round of the 2014 draft. If he can build off his performance in the Cape Cod League as a junior this spring he is expected to get selected much higher this time around.
Not bad for a kid from Dormont who batted sixth in the order on the borough’s 12-year-old all-star team, for someone who golfed in the fall and played basketball during the winters at Keystone Oaks, for someone who didn’t play for a travel baseball team until the summer before his junior year.
In an era when some young players are on travel teams by the end of elementary school, Lehman earned his scholarship the old-fashioned way. He developed as a well-rounded athlete and didn’t worry about how the college and major league scouts would find him.
“If I could go back I wouldn’t have done it any other way,” Lehman said.
He has had some terrific college experiences along the way, too. In November 2015, Penn State became the first NCAA Division I baseball team to play in Cuba. Lehman opened the four-game friendship tour against Industriales, the top team in the Cuban National Series. He had a good outing — allowing one earned with two walks and two strikeouts against a team of professional players — but the trip gave Lehman and his teammates an inside look at a country that hasn’t been open to Americans since 1961.
“It was even more of a culture shock than we expected, just the average everyday life,” Lehman said. “The average salary is something like $3,000 a year. It was like they were stuck in the 1950s. People were driving cars from the ‘50s. They live in poverty, but you can’t tell because they were all happy.”
Then there was Cape Cod, the idyllic baseball experience for an aspiring major leaguer. In 2016, 297 Cape Cod alumni were on MLB rosters. Kris Bryant, Josh Donaldson and Todd Frazier are just a few of the current MLB stars who passed through as amateurs.
“The Cape was an awesome experience,” Lehman said. “I worked on my changeup. It’s a pitch I have to have, and I feel comfortable throwing it at any point in the count now. I had high expectations.”
Lehman has high expectations for his spring, too. He is hoping the rebuilding phase is in the rear view mirror. Penn State was 6-16 in Big Ten play when Lehman was a freshman and 12-12 last season.
The Lions were 4-5 heading into this week. Lehman is 0-2 after dropping decisions to No. 1 TCU and Xavier.
Putting up more victories as a pitcher is an obvious goal for Lehman, but he would like to be a part of a team turnaround that ends with the Lions competing with conference heavyweights Maryland and Michigan for a Big Ten title.
“Everyone wants to put up good numbers, but I’d rather be a part of a winning team,” he said.
Ray Fittipaldo: rfittipaldo@post-gazette.com and Twitter @rayfitt1.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.