On a Saturday morning in mid-April 2013, Tiger Woods was saved from disqualification at the Masters by what was termed a “committee rule” (wink, wink) that appeared to be pulled from the magnolias like a rabbit from the hat.
The controversy stemmed from an illegal drop Woods made the previous afternoon, during Friday’s second round, when his third shot at the par-5 15th hole hit the flagstick and caromed into the pond that fronts the green.
When Woods went back in the fairway to drop his ball for his fifth shot, he admitted after the round he made the drop 2 yards behind the original spot. Surprisingly, Woods apparently did not know Rule 26-1a requires players in such instances to drop “nearly as possible” to the original spot. Six feet away is not really considered as close as possible.
When Fred Ridley, who was in charge of rules and officiating at the time, was told of Woods’ comment, he went back and reviewed TV footage of the drop and determined the four-time Masters champion had indeed made an illegal drop. That is cause for a two-shot penalty. Earlier in the day, Ridley has previously determined, without watching the replay, Woods had done nothing wrong and found no reason to question him about the drop before he signed his scorecard.
Because he made an incorrect ruling, Ridley decided the next morning he had erred, not just Woods, and because of that the Masters was not going to DQ the former No. 1 player in the world, just assess a two-shot penalty to his second-round score. But that meant Woods had signed for an incorrect score on Friday, which, under the rules of golf, is automatic disqualification.
After the ruling, I called Arnold Palmer, who had already gone back to his home in Orlando, Fla., following his ceremonial opening tee shot on Thursday. I was curious what Arnold thought of the ruling. Arnold, though, begged off making a public comment, not wanting to get involved in the controversy.
Read More
But then he said to me, “I know what I would do.”
“What’s that,” I said.
“I’d withdraw,” Palmer said.
Woods, of course, didn’t, and went on to finish tied for fourth.
Now, five years later, another of golf’s all-time great players is embroiled in a controversy in a major tournament, and this time the organization that saved him from what should have been disqualification was the United States Golf Association, the very group responsible for writing the rules of golf.
Phil Mickelson’s deliberate disregard for the rules on the 13th green during Saturday’s third round of the U.S. Open was surprising enough. Making it even more shocking was that it was Mickelson himself who committed the flagrant violation — a five-time major champion who comports himself on the golf course as wonderfully and gentlemanly as any player since Palmer.
When he missed his putt for bogey and ran after the ball before it could roll off the green, hitting it back toward the original spot while still in motion, it was as though nobody could believe what just happened. Later, an unrepentant Mickelson was assessed a two-shot penalty by the USGA under Rule 14-5 for striking a moving ball, giving him a 10 instead of the eight strokes he actually played on the hole.
But the USGA disregarded Rule 1-2, which says a player can be disqualified for a “flagrant” breach of the rules, which is clearly what Mickelson did. Unlike Woods in 2013, who did not know he was breaking a rule, Mickelson admitted after the round he knew exactly what he was doing — trying to save himself from playing his fifth shot from off the green again, regardless of the two-shot penalty.
If Mickelson didn’t flagrantly breach the rules — he apologized for his actions days later, saying he was embarrassed — he surely violated the spirit of the rule. Like Woods, he should have disregarded the decision of the tournament committee and done what Palmer suggested five years earlier — withdrawn.
And one other thing…
If listening to Joe Buck and the Fox broadcast of the U.S. Open isn’t bad enough, the network came up with the perfectly moronic idea of placing 200 open microphones around Shinnecock to enhance the crowd noise.
Doing that with a New York gallery is like opening the meat-locker door for a dog.
Not only was the background crowd noise annoying to the broadcast itself, but some of the comments picked up by the less-than-behaved galleries (not to mention disgruntled players) were not exactly FCC-approved. And I’m not just talking about the incident on Friday when the microphones picked up a conversation about sex between two fans — an exchange that forced Fox and the USGA to publicly apologize.
Fox also has this irritating habit of keeping its cameras focused on a player too long after he hits a shot, especially pitches or bunker shots. Instead of getting to immediately see the result, the viewer gets to watch the player watch his shot. That’s like watching Ben Roethlisberger after he throws a pass to Antonio Brown.
Remind me: How long is Fox’s contract with the USGA?
Pittsburgh sports news in my inbox? Yes, please.
Get the PG Sports Feed newsletter each weekday here.
Don’t skip it
Frank Fuhrer is not concerned most of the top players in the Tri-State PGA are banned from his $200,000 invitational that begins Monday at the Pittsburgh Field Club.
He said he has plenty of interest from mini-tour players around the country to fill out his select 40-man field that competes for a $40,000 first prize.
“I had 150 applicants coming from all over the country,” said Fuhrer, a Fox Chapel businessman whose South Side beer distributorship is the 20th largest in the country. “When you only have so many spots and that many applicants, it gets a little hairy.”
Fuhrer uses 25 of the 40 spots for his own personal use, extending invitations to local mini-tour players such as Mike Van Sickle, Easton Renwick, Dan Obremski and Spencer Mellon; and national players such as Web.com Tour member Denny McCarthy, three-time champion David Bradshaw and defending champ T.J. Howe.
The remaining spots go to the top 15 players on the Tri-State PGA point list, the local club professionals. But eight of the top 15 players on the current point list are banned from competing because they skipped Fuhrer’s tournament in the past to compete in national events such as the PGA Professional Championship and the U.S. Senior Open, among others.
Even the best amateur player in Western Pennsylvania — four-time U.S. Mid-Amateur champ and three-time U.S. Walker Cup team member Nathan Smith — is not invited back because he skipped Fuhrer’s tournament several years ago. And he won the event in 2005 and 2009.
He will be joined on the banned list next year by Sean Knapp, who is skipping this year’s tournament for the first time in 16 years because he is playing in the U.S. Senior Open as the reigning U.S. Senior Amateur champion. Knapp won the Fuhrer Invitational three times, going back to when it was the Pittsburgh Open.
That has always been Fuhrer’s rule: Once you skip his tournament, you don’t get to come back. And he’s not about to change his stance.
“If you don’t like the rules, too [darn] bad,” said Fuhrer, 92. “I spend the money, I’ll make the rules. We never change the rules and we never will. There’s a lot of guys I like that are out of this tournament. I hate to throw them out, but I can’t change the rules.”
Record breaker
Pete Edwards is a former World War II fighter pilot who has been a member at St. Clair Country Club since 1946. At 97, he still plays at the club several times a week and has shot his age a number of times.
And he still knows how to pilot his ball to the hole.
Edwards had a hole in one June 16 at St. Clair’s 121-yard fifth hole, using a hybrid. It was his fourth career ace but first in 23 years.
Safe to say Edwards is the oldest player to record a hole in one at the club.
Last week’s winners
• Oakmont’s Devin Gee shot 6-over 294 and finished tied for 38th in the National PGA Professional Championship at Seaside, Ca., missing qualifying for the PGA Championship by three shots. Among the Tri-State PGA players who also qualified for the national club pro event, Reid Howey of Oakmont (75-75), Justin Collins of Nemacolin Woodlands resort (76-79), Rob McClellan of Oak View (80-71), Joe Boros of Treesdale (81-79), Roy Vucinich (86-81) and Tom Bummer of Greene County CC (85-86) missed the cut.
• Frank Blazewick of Stonecrest Golf Club and instructor Gordon Vietmeier each shot 2-under 70 to share first place in the Tri-State PGA’s Latrobe CC Classic. Latrobe assistant Jonathan Beck’s team won the best two-balls of four event with a score of 15-under 129.
• Angus McHolme, 16, of Elizabeth Township, shot par-72 and won a playoff at Windber Country Club to grab the only qualifying spot into the U.S. Junior Amateur championship July 16-21 at Baltusrol CC.(Listen to “The Golf Show with Gerry Dulac” every Thursday, 7-8:30 p.m., on ESPN Pittsburgh, 970 AM, 106.3 FM)






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.