It was just a week before the start of the 118th U.S. Open at Shinnecock Hills when Jeff Hall, who is managing director for rules and Open championships for the United States Golf Association, calmly but boldly predicted that what happened at Shinnecock in 2004 would not and could not happen again.
“We’re quite confident it will not,” Hall said.
Hall is part of a team that includes Mike Davis, the USGA’s chief executive officer, responsible for the course setup at Shinnecock. While a lot of their decision process has to do with how high to grow the rough, how narrow to make the fairways and how fast to speed the greens, one of the most critical elements of what they do, especially once the tournament begins, is where to locate the pins.
In addition to the speed of the greens, that involves taking into consideration the slopes and contours of the surfaces and how weather conditions — sun, rain, wind — might affect the locations.
To that end, Hall assured that technological advances in equipment would make a repeat of 2004, when the USGA lost control of several of the putting surfaces, including an embarrassing episode at the par-3 seventh green, highly unlikely, if not downright impossible.
He said the USGA has developed in-ground meters that measure not only the firmness of the putting greens, but also how much moisture they are retaining. In addition, he said the weather data being used is much more sophisticated now and the USGA’s on-site meteorologists “are just on a different level.”
“It was not a brilliant moment for us that Sunday afternoon,” Hall said in an interview 10 days ago, referring to 2004. “We did not do a good job. We have learned from that mistake.”
And guess what? It happened again.
Saturday afternoon at Shinnecock resembled what happened 14 years earlier, a mixture of carnage and carnival because the USGA, by its own admission, failed to properly gauge how much the wind would blow for the third round of the U.S. Open.
Wind gusts of 20-30 mph, which baked some of the greens like an overcooked pork chop, sent scores soaring into the 80s. It caused Phil Mickelson, one of the game’s most revered disciples, to disrespect his craft with a move you might see on a Saturday morning municipal course.
The pin position at No. 15, a 409-yard par 4, was so severe (read: unfair) that shots that landed 10 feet from the pin ended up in an adjoining sand bunker. It is one thing when good shots are not necessarily rewarded. It is still another when they are penalized. Pin positions have to take into account slope, speed and, yes, wind. Those factors were ignored with several hole locations on the back nine.
Caddies and players began echoing exactly what was said in 2004 — the USGA had lost control of the course. Hank Haney, one of the most respected teachers in the game, tweeted the USGA “ruined another U.S. Open.”
Davis went on Fox’s broadcast after the round and admitted the USGA goofed again, saying his crew failed to account for the severity of the wind and wished “they had a mulligan” to do it over.
Uh, they had a mulligan. It came after 2004.
What is getting under the skin of most nearly every golfer is that the USGA is becoming a part of the story in too many U.S. Open championships. It happened in 2015 at Chambers Bay, when the course got as crusty as a waffle cone. It happened at Oakmont in 2016 with the Dustin Johnson moving-ball episode. And it happened again, almost incredibly, at Shinnecock.
I understand the U.S. Open is set up more difficult than any tournament in the world. The USGA wants to push the course to the edge, if you will, setting it up where a sheet of paper might not fit through the gap between tough and unplayable.
But even with the supposed best technology available, their attempt to avoid a repeat of 2004 at one of the greatest courses in the world happened again.
Even when they said it couldn’t and wouldn’t. And that is too bad.
Gerry Dulac: gdulac@post-gazette.com.







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.