Last November, in Week 11 of the NFL’s 99th season, the Los Angeles Rams beat the Kansas City Chiefs 54-51; it was the first time in league history both teams scored 50 or more points on the same stage.

Fans loved it. The league loved it. Television loved it to death.

But fretters gotta fret.

A few days later I was talking to Steelers defensive coordinator Keith Butler about it, and we agreed that 54-51 offended our sensibilities. It was becoming too easy to pass, too hard to rattle the quarterback, too flippin’ difficult to figure out what you can and cannot do to defend a receiver.

Advertise with us

We were looking at a future filled with basketball scores on NFL Sundays and we were exactly ... wrong.

Something seismic happened, something not easily explained, but within weeks the product no longer appeared so combustible. Dallas beat New Orleans 13-10. The Steelers beat the Patriots, with celebrated gunslingers Ben Roethlisberger and Tom Brady stalking each other at Heinz Field, 17-10. That same week, Dallas and the New York Giants were shut out. By the time we got to the fourth quarter of the Super Bowl, New England and the aforementioned 54-point Rams of Nov. 19 were tied 3-3.

Though the Patriots would cobble together a 13-3 victory, the Super Bowl had zero touchdown passes. Zero.

I met Butler on the Saint Vincent practice field this past week to reassess.

“New England ran the ball a ton early in that game,” Butler noted. “Tried to control the ball. The thing about winning and stats, it’s always been if you can possess the ball and you can win the turnover takeaway ratio. Throughout the history of the league, you get to these points where everybody starts throwing the ball everywhere. But is Brady gonna throw the ball everywhere? I don’t think he is. I think they’re gonna have a mixture of running and passing and the good teams usually do because if you shut down one part of their offense they gotta have something else to go to.”

Advertise with us
Julian Edelman runs with the ball against the Los Angeles Rams in the second half of the 2019 Super Bowl. The teams combined for zero touchdown passes (Mike Ehrmann / Getty Images)

That perspective gets tested Sept. 8 in Foxborough, where Mike Tomlin’s team opens the 2019 season, but last season’s offensive wildfires got controlled and all but extinguished when the weather turned cold, so something is different, right? Something?

Well, there is this thing about the middle linebacker being dead. Not dead, gone. Probably gone. The main defensive character, played by the people who made you fall in love with NFL Films — Jack Lambert, Dick Butkus, Mike Singletary, Ray Nitschke, Junior Seau, Chuck Bednarik, Willie Lanier, Sam Huff — no longer a thing.

Butler explained.

“What’s gotta happen is, and this is happening with us, the day of the middle linebacker is probably gone. Probably. What we did is we’ve got a couple of guys who are probably hybrid safeties that are gonna play inside linebacker for us. Because what people are really doing more than anything else is they’re trying to get a matchup with a linebacker. We count receivers from outside in, 1, 2, 3, and offenses know they can usually get a linebacker on that 3. That’s what they’re trying to do, to go one-on-one with a linebacker. The Chargers did it to us. We had a couple of guys down and we couldn’t do nothing about it. We had to play with linebackers on that No. 3 and they ate us up. That’s what’s happening a lot in the league; people are putting what they call an athlete at 3, gaining yards that way.”

The Chargers ate up a 23-7 Steelers halftime lead and won 33-30 as Keenan Allen, that night’s 3, seemingly caught 100 passes for 1,000 yards, even if it was actually 14 for 148 and the touchdown that started that comeback.

Advertise with us

Nowhere is it guaranteed that if Butler deploys rookie Devin Bush and newly acquired Mark Barron at those linebacker/safety spots, the Steelers will remove all of the bacteria that led to losing four of their final six and avoiding the playoffs.

But in general, meaning league-wide, defensive football appears to have the momentum back.

“Defenses develop throughout the season as they start to have a lot of tape on you,” said Steelers offensive coordinator Randy Fichtner. “From a study standpoint they develop certain ways that they’re gonna give and hopefully not break for the touchdown. You kick field goals and the score’s gonna be lower. But some of that was on us. We turned the ball over more than we should. We’re always gonna be responsible for that. We can’t turn the ball over.”

The Steelers forked it over 11 times in their final six games, so Fichtner’s not certain he agrees that the defensive pendulum has swung.

“The Super Bowl, that could have been nerves, something as simple as that,” he shrugged. “Each game takes on a character of its own. It starts to define itself and you realize, ‘Hey this is a week where, man, this thing’s gonna go back and forth and whoever has the ball last is gonna win.’ If you get a feel for it, you kind of know it, and you don’t let off on the gas pedal. You may be up a touchdown, but it’s not time that you’re gonna go into a four-minute offense in the middle of the third quarter.

Advertise with us

“This league is always going to be about, obviously, outscoring people, but there are different ways you have to do it. What’s interesting is that whether it’s 54 to 51 or 13 to 3, it still tells you it’s coming down to probably one series at the end of the game. So how well you do in situation, how well you do in the four-minute, holding that ball, that type of thing is always going to define you.”

In other words, there’s just no telling what will happen come September. Maybe some of us should stop trying to define it.

Gene Collier: gcollier@post-gazette.com and Twitter @genecollier.