The Pirates last weekend completed one of those transactions that doesn’t alter a single particle of your existence, releasing an obscure player they’d signed on the eve of spring training, a player from whom they’d get nothing of any use, unless you find useful a .193 average in 44 games at Class AAA Indianapolis.
Which you don’t, nor should you.
Like just about everyone else in baseball, the Pirates were wrong about Nick Franklin, now a 28-year-old free agent with a humble big league resume that mostly served only to delay his life’s work. But there was one person, a person not in baseball, who was right about Nick Franklin in so many ways.
“There’s a conversation in the book where we talk about failure and how it just wasn’t something he’d had much of a reason to consider,” Lucas Mann was telling me this week. “That has always stayed with me. It must be so very strange to be as good at something as he is at baseball. And then to have baseball be so difficult that it can humble even the most insanely talented people.”
The book is Mann’s “Class A, Baseball in the Middle of Everywhere,” which happens to be as fine a study of baseball’s unrelenting inner desperation as I’ve ever come across. It’s the inside story — the way, way inside story — of the 2010 Clinton LumberKings, then a low minors Iowa outpost of the Seattle Mariners. A baseball fan from New York who’d just taken an MFA from the writing program at the University of Iowa, Mann was of the players’ generation. He shared some of their inclinations, some of their insecurities, and many of their fears. As it happened, none of them could play like he wrote, but Nick Franklin at least looked the part.
“All anyone can tell me about Nick Franklin – parents, agents, coaches – is that the kid loves baseball,” is how the bottom of page 210 begins. “He understands baseball and continues to study it without a trace of apathy. That, I believe. He feels comfortable within it, he is interested in how good he can be at it, but love necessitates reflection, risk, pain, joy. I don’t think Nick has been allowed to feel any of those things. People feel for him, through him.”
Read More
Reflection, risk, pain, and joy form the emotional super collider of Mann’s work on this project, but are in no way limited to the LumberKings’ clubhouse. It’s about a town of failed industries, an intimate fan base that identifies the metaphors of their lives in every inning, the always suffocating realities of baseball politics.
Like a disciplined hitter, Mann does not reach for the narrative in “Class A,” but lets the ball come to him, lets the narrative that’s wrapped up in Nick Franklin come to him, and he crushes it.
A confession: Because Mann noted at the book’s beginning that some names had been changed and some chronology altered for narrative clarity, I wasn’t sure in the reading of it that Nick Franklin actually existed. His big league career – parts of six seasons with four teams for whom he hit .214 – never penetrated my radar. Yet this was a player taken two slots after Mike Trout in the first round of the 2009 draft.
“A lot of people raised eyebrows about that, but our guys really liked him, thought he was really gonna be a player” said Jack Zduriencik, then the general manager of the Mariners and now the expert postgame voice of the Pirates’ radio broadcasts. “He really hit the ground running, got off to a great start in the minor leagues, but he wound up having a career that wasn’t anything like that.
“There was a point where he was a very desirable piece to have. Any time there was trade talk people would bring up his name.”
In 2014, a year after Mann’s book came out, Zduriencik traded Nick Franklin to Tampa Bay in a three-way deal that sent David Price to Detroit and Austin Jackson to Seattle.
It was only four years after Franklin had broken the Clinton LumberKings record for homers in a season that earned him a late-season call-up to Double A, but he would view leaving Clinton with some reluctance.
“People loved him here,” Mann wrote. “He lived with roommates here, shared rented TVs with four other guys, rode in the backs of (expletive) cars like mine to dive bars, was served illegal drinks by smoky-voiced bartenders who told him they like his fancy diamond earring, that it made him look like a rap star. He will not be loved like this anywhere else. Not really. Maybe if he becomes a major league superstar, he will be known to the nation, the world, but it will be a diffuse love, and anyway, that situation probably won’t happen. He’ll probably be a mediocre big league infielder for a decade or so (and) make more money than I’ll ever see.”
Plainly, Mann was much closer to being right about Nick Franklin nine years ago than anyone would ever be, but that’s not at all what he’d like you to know.
“I can’t claim to have known him well at all, and I’ve had people say my portrayal of him was unflattering, which I hope isn’t entirely true,” Mann told me. “I found him to be a mostly nice, quiet, thoughtful guy, especially considering that he’d just become a 19-year-old millionaire and then was sent to a small town far away from home to be both isolated and idolized. Most people (myself included) would be an (expletive) in that scenario, and he wasn’t.”
Mann teaches writing at the University of Massachusetts-Dartmouth. Two weeks ago, he went to a Triple-A game in Pawtucket with no idea he’d see Nick Franklin playing second base for visiting Indianapolis.
“This strange thing where I was watching him in Triple A,” Mann said, “a guy who’s been paid millions over nearly a decade to be insanely good at something that a lot of people try to be good at, thinking about that as a sort of failure. That’s unfair. Ultimately, I think most people still wish they could have the career he did.
“I really wish him the best.”
On the day I finished the book, the Pirates released Nick Franklin. Found it on my Twitter feed. Wait, I thought, he’s real?
Oh, he’s real.
Tried to reach him through the ballclub this week. No reply.
On Friday, the Angels signed him and assigned him to Class AAA Salt Lake.
Gene Collier: gcollier@post-gazette.com and Twitter @genecollier






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.