Ed Bouchette and Gerry Dulac break down Steelers vs. Chargers

See if you can identify a trend somewhere in the following paragraph.

Los Angeles Chargers quarterback Philip Rivers, a walking winter nightmare to NFL defensive backs coast to coast, completed 25 passes in a row last Sunday and 28 out of 29; Marcus Mariota, middling quarterback of the Tennessee Tuxedos, hit on 16 passes in a row Monday and 22 out of 23; Pat Mahomes, the hottest football story on a fast-heating planet, fueled the Kansas City Chiefs to 51 points the night of Nov. 19, and lost to Jared Goff and the Los Angeles Rams; Ben Roethlisberger — maybe you’ve heard of him — threw for 462 yards last Sunday at Denver and his passer rating went down!

So I’m asking you, serious students of the NFL product, when a kicker, Chris Boswell, effortlessly completes a touchdown pass to an offensive tackle (Alejandro Villanueva), when five NFL players who are not even quarterbacks have a perfect passer rating of 158.3, are we anywhere near the point in history where it’s too easy to complete a pass in this league?

That’s not a rhetorical question.

Advertise with us

The answer is “Oh hell yeah.”

Search the pale green eyes of Steelers defensive coordinator Keith Butler and you’ll discover the haunting irritations of his thankless profession, or maybe it’s just the looming mental exhaustion of someone who’s spent the past six days reviewing the tape of Rivers taking apart the Arizona Cardinals like a crazed neighbor obliterating doomed birds in mid-flight with a tennis racket.

Or something.

Butler didn’t want to complain, but the man is human.

“The way the rules have changed over the years, I think it’s made it a little bit advantageous for the quarterbacks,” Butler allowed after practice one day this week. “You gotta be careful about how you hit ’em. You gotta be careful about how you take ’em to the ground. All that stuff.

Advertise with us

“I was talking to [Chargers Hall of Famer] Dan Fouts a while back about it. I told Dan, I said, ‘Man if they had these rules when you played, you’d still be playin’.”

And that’s when Butler’s Southern drawl erupts in a cannon-fire laugh that drags him blessedly from the despair felt by defensive coordinators nationwide. For the first time in NFL history, both teams scored 50 points in that Chiefs-Rams riot. It won’t be the last.

“It’s ridiculous, 54-51,” Butler said. “There’s a lot of stuff I see that’s goin’ on in terms of rules. How [receivers] people can pick [off defenders] and stuff that irritates me because I’ve been in the league a long time. I came into the league in 1978 and to see the rules change over the years and see the advantages offenses have. It makes it harder on defenses; it makes it harder to coach them.”

Butler is plainly aware of the politics in play here. Points and scoring projections are at an all-time high, with TV ratings and ad revenues pursuing like eager bloodhounds. For every fan who moans to his talk show therapist about the merits of running the ball, there are 10 who like the ball in the air a whole lot better. Roethlisberger completed 44 passes in one night last December against Baltimore. In four Super Bowls, Terry Bradshaw completed 49.

In four Super Bowl appearances, Terry Bradshaw completed fewer than 50 passes. (Associated Press)

“I think it is fantastic for pro football because now you don’t have to have one of those eight elite quarterbacks to have a chance to win,” NBC’s Cris Collinsworth said this week on colleague Mike Tirico’s podcast. “Now what’s happened is that we’ve got these guys that even if they don’t have a great arm, they can be great read option players because they’re smart, or they’re athletic, or they can really run. I think the idea that we’ve now moved from 6-8 quarterbacks that can win the Super Bowl every year into more 12-14 quarterbacks that might be able to because of these various styles is making the game more interesting.”

Advertise with us

Fair enough, but is what we’re seeing every weekend an explosion of quarterbacking capability and offensive innovation or little more than the over-regulation/strangulation of NFL defenses?

No one wants to erase from this game spectacles like Roethlisberger’s 97-yard touchdown toss to JuJu Smith-Schuster last Sunday, because that’s a clear instance of athletic brilliance on both ends, but are this many passers really this brilliant every weekend?

Nine active quarterbacks hold their franchise’s record for passing yards in a game. The NFL’s top three quarterbacks in career passer rating are all active: Aaron Rodgers, Russell Wilson, Tom Brady. The top three quarterbacks all-time in rookie passer rating are all active: Dak Prescott, Wilson, Robert Griffin III. The top three quarterbacks for most completions in a rookie season are all active: Carson Wentz, Sam Bradford (a free agent), Derek Carr. The top three quarterbacks for completions in one season are not only all active, they’re all named Drew Brees.

Even after encountering an actual defense Thursday night in Dallas, Brees, who broke Peyton Manning’s career yardage record in October, is completing 75.5 percent of his throws, 30 of which have gone for TDs while only three have been picked. The league as a whole is completing 65 percent.

“There’s just elite guys out there making throws and receivers been catching the ball,” said Steelers safety Sean Davis. “I know it’s tight coverage out there, but sometimes quarterbacks just throw better than tight coverage. There’s just a lot of good football being played right now. I always love being on the other side from the quarterback. I’m trying to look at the positive things of that. Quarterbacks are throwing the ball great. We’ve got to combat that.”

Advertise with us

Davis, in just his third NFL season, figures to see a lot of combat in his future. On Dec. 16, he might even be on the field when Brady joins Manning, Brees, and Brett Favre in the 70,000-yard club. He’s already encountered the great Mahomes, who at Heinz Field in September went 23 for 28 for 326 yards and six touchdowns. Did you happen to see what Archie Manning told Sports Illustrated last week about the state of the game?

“If Patrick Mahomes plays into his 40s, he’ll have 100,000 yards.”

For my own potential rhetorical purposes, I used to keep track of 300-yard games by quarterbacks, as that used to be a landmark performance. Isn’t that adorable?

This season, there have been 85 such performances, not including the 20 times when someone threw for 400 yards or more. Better yet, or rather worse yet, 25 percent of the 400-yard games got authored by quarterbacks who’ve since been benched, Ryan Fitzpatrick (4) and Blake Bortles (1).

Ryan Fitzpatrick has four 400-yard passing games this season — and has been benched. (Peter Diana / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

As discussed, the reasons for all of this are multi-factorial, ranging from ridiculously complicated predictive analytics to the purely elemental — such as the ball. If you’ve ever had the occasion to hold in your hands an actual NFL football, your first thought is not “Oh my gawd I’m holding an actual NFL football,” it’s “Geez I could really whip this thing!” It’s smaller than you might imagine with high laces, an aerodynamic marvel.

Advertise with us

Then, it gets fired with high precision to an elite athlete wearing gloves that are custom fit and have what Under Armour describes in its model as a Super-Sticky GrabTack palm.

What’s a defensive back to do?

Frustration among the defenders, Steelers cornerback Joe Haden estimates, is up “one thousand percent — I wish we could do something about it, but they know that points is what’s gonna get fans watching the games. If you have a 7-3 game, they’re like, ‘Oh that was a terrible game.’ It was a defensive battle, but they’re like, ‘Where were the points?’ It’s never good defense. It’s always bad offense.”

There is something that can be done, I mean short of making an incompletion a turnover, which I understand was the official reaction according to the collegiate rules of 1906.

“Oh it fell to the ground? OK our ball!”

Advertise with us

The NFL Competition Committee meets every year to further cultivate the game, and perhaps the topic of how stupidly easy the passing game has become might be a worthy topic.

“I’m sure it’s something that we do look at; we look at the overall health and competitiveness of the game,” said Mike Tomlin, noted committee member. “We monitor competitive trends and things of that nature. But those are things that are done at the end of the journey with the totality of it. I know I’m not ready to have those discussions. I’ve got enough issues here in Pittsburgh, Pa.”

We’ve got three rivers, Tomlin seemed to be saying, and we don’t need Philip Rivers changing the topography as well, especially if he plans to complete his first 25 passes tonight. Or 30.

Gene Collier: gcollier@post-gazette.com and Twitter @genecollier