Remember this promo from Fox’s coverage of last year’s World Series?
The Astros of Sig Mejdal, the NASA scientist with degrees in mechanical and aeronautical engineering, battle the Dodgers of Farhan Zaidi, the trained brain from MIT and Berkeley, in Game 1 tonight at 8 on Fox!
Of course you don’t.
Because who would watch that?
With immense due respect to Messrs. Mejdal and Zaidi, no one in the entertainment universe tunes in to see anyone crunch the numbers, itself a contrived phrase that wildly oversells the action. In math, there is no actual crunching. There’s more action in a bowl of Frosted Flakes than in the research and design of baseball analytics, fueled by verifiable genius though they are.
Baseball in the 21st century will go to any length to try to convert math into entertainment. The Pirates, as data-driven an enterprise as almost any in the big league constellation, began their weekend by launching a STEM Zone along PNC Park’s Riverwalk, STEM being the acronym for science, technology, engineering, and math. An educational co-operative of the ballclub, Chevron, and the Children’s Museum of Pittsburgh, the STEM Zone is described as “an experiential, hands-on learning exhibit (that) includes educational exercises and interactive displays focused on the science of the game.”
Read More
Experiential?
Anything that remotely promotes the furtherance of education, particularly STEM education, I’m all for, but I was wondering last week how Nick Kingham would describe his experiential time with the Pirates, who demoted him to Indianapolis three times this season despite glowing analytics.
I mean look at that WHIP (0.991), to say nothing of his FIP (3.35).
FIP, the acronym for fielding independent pitching, is a calculation designed to reflect what happens when outcomes are solely attributable to the pitcher — strikeouts, walks, hit batsmen, homers — rather than what results from the vagaries of batted balls in play and the sometimes curious attempts to, you know, field them. Kingham, who made six starts for Clint Hurdle’s team and struck out 35 batters as he walked only seven, took the best FIP of any Pirate starter with at least 30 innings back to Class AAA for the third time last weekend — 3.35.
Considering that any self-respecting sabermetrician will tell you FIP is a better predictor of future performance than ERA — you remember earned run average? — it’s striking that between Kingham’s historically brilliant major league debut April 29 and this third trip west along I-70 June 10, the balance of the Pirates rotation was going 5-8 with a 4.37 ERA and relatively floppy FIP.
Earlier this month, defensive analytics triggered the biggest boil-over of frustration of the season in Philadelphia, where starter Jake Arrieta roasted the organization’s data mavens for excessive shifting. In this case, the data confirmed Arrieta’s steamy intuition. According to MLB’s Statcast, the Phillies deploy a full defensive shift (three infielders to the right of second base) 29.1 percent of the time with Arrieta on the mound, compared with a league average for all pitchers of 17.3 percent. The result, somehow, is that they’re dead last in runs saved by the shift.
Still, data wranglers are at the apex of their powers with the ascendance of the world champion Astros under Jeff Luhnow, who took two Ivy League degrees out of Penn and made Houston an unabashedly analytics-driven operation from the ground up. Luhnow hired Mejdal, the aforementioned NASA Engineer, as the club’s Director of Decision Science.
“The engineering exposes you to breaking down complex problems into smaller parts and solving each of the smaller parts, one at a time; I think those skills were very useful for baseball,” Mejdal says in MLB Network anchor Brian Kenny’s book, “Ahead of the Curve, Inside the Baseball Revolution.” “It’s human nature to jump from what feels right to the conclusion that it is right. I think it’s important to stop that leap and question it. If at all possible to test the thing that feels right.”
Can't get enough of our in-depth Pirates coverage?
Support quality journalism. Subscribe today.
Mejdal is no doubt right about that, and no doubt the 15 general managers in the National League, who hold nine Ivy League degrees (the Mets’ Sandy Alderson has two, Dartmouth and Harvard Law, tying him for the National League degrees lead with St. Louis’s Michael Girsch — Notre Dame mathematics and University of Chicago science) are making the right decisions regarding strategy and scouting and many other things.
Just one problem.
The data-driven product on the field is boring as hell.
Under an avalanche of information, the industry has been separated from its tenuous understanding that it’s in the entertainment business. Today, the only people familiar with this notion are wearing pierogi suits or firing t-shirts out of air cannons. In any randomly selected big league game, the best action seems to be coming from the stands. The girl at the Padres game who caught a foul pop in her beer cup and chugged what was left is the front runner for my MVP right now. At the pace baseball is presented, it’s hard to keep even the players interested – witness Gregory Polanco’s indifferent jog to first base on a beatable grounder that quelled a potentially historic Pirates comeback this week.
If you think no one’s noticed, uh, wrong. Attendance is down in 19 of the 30 big league ballparks, and the places where it’s up have seen mostly modest increases. But crowds have shrunk by more than 8,000 per game in Baltimore, 10,000 in Miami, 11,000 in Toronto, 7,000 in Detroit, and by almost 7,000 at PNC Park. Total major league attendance is off nearly 16 percent since 2007, according to the figures at baseballreference.com.
No wonder some of the game’s brightest students, external and internal, have begun to push significant changes, the exact kind of design audibles with which football has no difficulty but baseball can’t seem to abide.
Limiting the number of pitchers on an active roster or the number that can be used in a game, outlawing the shift, moving the pitching rubber back to decrease pitch velocity, allow a manager to pinch hit any player in his lineup for another –—batting him out of order —once per game, putting the tying run on third at the start of an extra inning, shrinking the strike zone, expanding the strike zone, do something — anything! — to relieve the game of this tedium where hitters are either trying to drive up pitch counts or trying to launch the ball over the shifts and striking out in staggering numbers while bullpen-addicted managers are using six pitchers to get a 2-0 shutout.
This isn’t blamestorming for the sake of blamestorming. One published estimate posited that this season, there will be 10,000 fewer balls in play than in 2009.
In his book, “The Big Chair,” former Dodgers GM Ned Colletti, who worked for three clubs over 30 years, nailed the essence of this conflict.
“As analytics became more of a go-to requirement, I continued to embrace them. I just could never put sheer numbers ahead of the soul and personality of the human being inside the uniform. I used every piece of information I could in my decision making. But I do understand the allure and the fascination with the numbers. And it’s not surprising when you consider the fortunes earned by so many owners prior to their baseball experience. They live in worlds where analytics predict the futures of companies and products. [They] became millionaires and billionaires with formulas and calculations that crush the competition.
“In my first years with the Cubs, the [ownership] didn’t seem to appreciate the great scout Hugh Alexander — how someone with barely a high school education and a somewhat disheveled appearance could be brilliant at projecting baseball talent. The leadership of the Cubs’ parent company was filled with MBAs from Northwestern and Michigan. Without question they knew how to grow the company and its stock. None of them looked like Hugh Alexander.”
If it seems like I write this column every summer (or is it every month?), let it be clear that I would never say that the bigger brains are bad for the game. All this says is that maybe the game’s greatest minds have to work on re-establishing its entertainment value instead of determining precisely where the second baseman ought to be in a million different situations. Because right now the brains are working diligently and no doubt brilliantly to a place where all tendencies and probabilities are calculated to optimum strategic efficiency.
It’s going to be a very lonely place.
Gene Collier: gcollier@post-gazette.com






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.