Nowhere on my Pirates promotional schedule for 2018 can I find one giveaway item commemorating the silver anniversary of the 1993 team, an apparent oversight that appears easily rectifiable on July 6 now that Andrew McCutchen Figurine Day seems a bit hollow.

Is it too late to substitute a handsome Al Martin bobblehead or a full color Midre Cummings growth chart?

OK, fine, just let the dusty memories of the ‘93 club fade into oblivion then, but an opportunity is being missed. The parallels between that team and the one Clint Hurdle will put on the field to open the 2018 season on Thursday are not only numerous and tortured, but perhaps even encouraging for an organization and a fuming fan base desperate for some quantum of hope.

To begin, both teams, Jim Leyland’s post-postseason edition of 1993 and Hurdle’s well past-postseason venture for 2018, carried the fresh exit wounds of their best everyday player and their best starting pitcher — Barry Bonds and Doug Drabek back then, Gerrit Cole and McCutchen today. Both the McCutchen trade and the Bonds exit closed the curtain on Pirates eras, twin three-year bursts of excellence constituting the only times since 1979 the Pirates could so much as smell a World Series. MVP McCutchen’s 2013 ensemble got within one game of the League Championship Series. Bonds team got within one strike of the Fall Classic itself.

Advertise with us

“Sitting in that clubhouse at the end of ‘92, we knew that that was it,” starting pitcher and present-day Pirates broadcaster Bob Walk said this week from Florida. “We knew it was gonna be a rebuilding thing. We were kinda hopin’ maybe the young players would catch fire, maybe this, maybe that.

“Well, the maybes didn’t work out.”

Few people inside or outside the clubhouse really expected them to, and that put Leyland in a tough spot. It wasn’t just that Bonds and Drabek were gone, but then general manager Ted Simmons released catcher Mike LaValliere and traded Gold Glove second baseman Chico Lind to Kansas City for two pitchers, one of whom would be out of baseball by 1996 (Joel Johnston) and another who would work in 10 games for the ‘93 Pirates and never pitch again (Dennis Moeller).

“What you have to say to the fans and the public — it’s not that you’re lying — you’re not lying because it’s your job to encourage your team, that’s one thing,” Leyland said from another Grapefruit League outpost were he’s working as a special assistant to the Detroit Tigers. “But when you’re behind closed doors you have to be realistic about what you’re talking about. I knew [1993] was the start of a new era. Unfortunately, it took more than 20 years before they were .500 again. That’s a long time.”

Though the ‘93 Pirates would scratch their way to 75 wins, 21 fewer than the previous summer, the fans were predictably hesitant if not hostile. You know, like today. Even when Leyland’s team started 7-2, it returned from the West Coast to find 9,074 wounded souls rattling around Three Rivers Stadium to open a homestand.

Advertise with us

“Prospects were getting an opportunity — Kevin Young, Al Martin, Carlos Garcia — and I’d be lying if I didn’t tell you I was a little disappointed that these guys — all of whom I’d played with — were getting opportunities and I was wondering, ‘Why aren’t I getting an opportunity?’ “ remembered utility man John Wehner, now a club broadcaster as well. “I remember I was a little ticked off. Being a player, you think you still have a chance to win, but you’re not being realistic.

“I remember Leyland threw me into center field in the spring because he thought I could hit those lefties Andy Van Slyke wasn’t hitting, but all I found out was that I couldn’t hit them either. I went 5 for 35 and went back to [Class AA] Buffalo.”

Young, the first baseman who took over in the middle of the lineup for Bonds, remembers the difficulties acutely in a summer when he hit six homers and drove in 47 runs (Bonds’ last Pirate numbers were 34 and 103).

“It’s was just hard,” said Young from Pirate City in Bradenton, where he was stationed this week as the club’s special assistant for player development. “It was young players trying to navigate themselves through a major league season. Two things I can definitely say are different now though. Both teams had veteran managers, but Clint Hurdle has just signed on for four more years. Josh Bell has established himself as a hitter in this league. Jose Osuna is establishing himself. We have a young pitching staff with a year under its belt and that one year makes a major difference.”

No one is counting on the 2018 Pirates to snip a new skein of losing seasons at two, but not every forecast is ominous.

Advertise with us

“I don’t think the Pirates are a bad team; I think they have a pretty good team,” said Leyland. “I don’t see the doom and gloom a lot of people see and I’ve seen their club pretty often this spring. They’ve got one of the best closers in baseball [Felipe Rivero] and that makes up for a lot. If those young pitchers can get them to a bridge to the ninth inning, that’s pretty good. [Josh] Harrison is a good player and I think they’ve got a number of damned good players.

“The Pirates are nowhere near a rebuild. If [Starling] Marte and Bell and Harrison play to their capabilities, that’s a good team, and it’s got some depth. [Adam] Frazier is a good player, and Hurdle hasn’t gotten enough credit for the way he runs the game. He’s gotten credit for becoming a Pittsburgher and changing the culture and all that, but not enough credit as a game manager. I mean he’s pretty good.”

This Pirates season hinges on what newcomers Colin Moran and Corey Dickerson can add to an offense in which Marte and Polanco are somehow still discovering the game’s finer points, one of which is learning how to drive in runs rather than authoring the same mercurial swing in every situation. That and finding a couple of starting pitchers who can win more than 10 times, the maximum reached by starters who are still around (Ivan Nova).

“When you lose the face of your franchise, how do you fill that void? By paying attention to detail,” said Young. “We’re not going to have two guys who hit 30 homers and drive in 100. It’s an art form, learning how to hit with runners in scoring position. Everybody, one-through-nine in our lineup, has to be able to do something handling the bat.”

There are wildly different outcomes among this team’s general modest potentialities. But depending on where those fall, it says here, this 25th anniversary team will win between 72 and 82 games.

Advertise with us

If only there were a Will Pennyfeather feather duster night.

Gene Collier: gcollier@post-gazette.com.