Watching his glub-glubbing Pirates trying to tread water against the perfectly dreadful San Diego Padres for most of Tuesday night could not have been pleasant for Pirates manager Clint Hurdle, but then precious little about 2016 has been.
In fact, in his sixth summer in Pittsburgh, the contemporary Pirates are Hurdle’s most disappointing team to date in any serious appraising of the Jolly Roger, and it’s a team with a serious chance of becoming much worse before it gets much better.
Hurdle wasn’t likely to be part of this kind of appraisal, however, which is why I phrased the question as benignly as possible.
“In your first couple years you had teams that played really well into July, or through July, and then you had three really good teams,” this big looping question began. “Is it therefore fair to say that, in terms of challenges for you, in terms of trying to fix things, waiting for things to happen, that this is your most challenging team?”
No luck.
“I don’t know,” the manager said plaintively. “Umm, we’ve had to do things a different way this year. I think people that follow the game, the model starts with your pitching program, and it’s been just a different year for us with that. There’s been a different set of opportunities and a different set of challenges. We’ve had some offensive challenges as well. Those are things you just work on as you go.
“I haven’t given it enough thought [to say it’s the most challenging team], so I don’t want to just jump in to something just to try and a get an answer out there. It’s been a very unique year with a lot of challenges.”
No one would ever undersell the manager’s qualifications to talk about challenges. This is a guy who had to write Lyle Overbay, Jose Tabata and Ronny Cedeno’s names onto the lineup card consistently in his first go-round in 2011, and he had that team in first place as late as July 25. They lost 43 of the last 62. This is a guy who had to run Rod Barajas, Alex Presley and Gorkys Hernandez out there in 2012, and he had that team in first place on July 19. They lost 39 of their last 71.
The three postseason teams that followed ultimately disappointed, but because they ended a postseason drought that lasted more than 20 years, they shouldn’t be viewed as anything but successful.
This team is different; it’s a throbbing disappointment on multiple levels and a decent bet to chop a modest string of winning seasons at, um, three.
Even when it’s doing what’s expected, like scoring four times in an inning against a pitcher who came in with a 6.67 ERA, as San Diego’s Luis Perdomo did Tuesday night, it’s doing things in such ragged fashion that it’s practically inexcusable.
Searching for anything to spark a team that’s been sulking since the July 30 trade of closer Mark Melancon, Hurdle installed Gregory Polanco as his cleanup hitter Tuesday night for the first time in the young outfielder’s career. Polanco rode an 0-2 pitch from Perdomo to the seats in right-center field for the three-run missile that broke open a 2-2 game in the fifth, but when Francisco Cervelli cracked a double off the right-field wall three batters later, John Jaso got himself thrown out at home.
The Padres jumped ahead of rookie Chad Kuhl in the first on a bad play by Andrew McCutchen, who’s extending his bad year despite a three-day last-resort working vacation last week in Atlanta. Alex Dickerson lined Kuhl’s 0-2 pitch straight at McCutchen, who hesitated just long enough for it to tick off the top of his glove and on toward the warning track to score the first run, then Jabari Blash lashed an RBI single to make it 2-0. I’m not second-guessing the official scorer on the double, but that’s a ball that’s gotta be caught.
Hurdle was correct to start his unconsidered answer with starting pitching, because Francisco Liriano did more to undermine the 2016 Pirates than just leave them with 30,000 bobbleheads they have no idea what to do with, and because Gerrit Cole, who started this season complaining about his salary, has been anything but the stopper this limping rotation so desperately needs, but if starting pitching is Reason No. 1 for this worst Hurdle edition, McCutchen is Reason No. 1A.
Given the shaggy summers turned in by its star players, there’s little wonder that in this 20-game stretch against the eminently beatable Brewers, Phillies, Mariners, Braves, Reds and Padres, the club is 9-9 with two to play. Given a chance to make their move on some misbegotten wild-card fantasy, this team team has stood rock still. It’s a desultory look right now, and it’s so out of character for Hurdle’s Pirates teams. Last year’s 98-game winners had 11 walk-off wins. There were 10 the year before and nine the year before that. Even Hurdle’s first team, the 72-90 club in 2011, had six walk-off wins. This team might not get four.
And yet they drew 30,269 for a game with the Padres on a Tuesday night.
Not for long.
Gene Collier: gcollier@post-gazette.com and Twitter @genecollier.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.