According to the unrelenting conversation starters at Bovada.lv, a sports wagering engine, the Penguins were the favorites to win the Stanley Cup Friday at lunchtime. Their odds were 9-5 officially, slightly better than the St. Louis Blues at 2-1, while odds on the Tampa Bay Lighting were 17-4, slightly worse than the San Jose Sharks’ 4-1.

Then a hockey game got played.

And hockey games have a way of turning soft, speculative numbers into hard, urgent questions.

The No. 1 question facing Penguins coach Mike Sullivan and his staff after a 3-1 home loss to the Lightning in Game 1 translates roughly into “What’s the Maatta?”

Advertise with us

Perhaps you remember when defenseman Olli Maatta precociously and routinely strung multiple shifts together in which he looked like he knew what he was doing on the ice, but those mental images are fading quickly.

You think it would be obvious from a defenseman’s standpoint in this series to watch out for a head man pass from a guy named Hedman, but Maatta seemed perfectly oblivious to the possibility right up until the moment Victor Hedman lasered the puck from behind his own goal line to Alex Killorn near the far blue stripe. Maatta was on duty in that sector, but gave Killorn nothing but open ice all the way to Matt Murray and the first of Tampa Bay’s three consecutive goals.

“His positioning put him in a vulnerable circumstance because he allowed Killorn to get on the back side of him,” Sullivan said Saturday via conference call. “Something that we tried to make our team aware of going into this series is that anytime there’s any kind of separation from our forecheck, Tampa Bay likes to try and stretch the ice. They like to try and get behind our defense. And they have certain players that are more inclined to do it.

“We just have to have an awareness, especially the defensemen.”

For whatever set of reasons, some potentially related to his overall health, Maatta lacked that kind of awareness even before Washington’s Brooks Orpik knocked him senseless early in Round 2, and now, for his sake and the team’s, Olli needs to take a rest.

Advertise with us

But the Maatta question and Sullivan’s evident reluctance to subtract him from any defensive construct is only one variable that has tilted Tampa Bay’s way ahead of Game 2, which doesn’t come around until Monday night at Consol Energy Center.

Another is that two-day gap between games, the only one on the schedule for this series, and that gap gives Lightning head coach Jon Cooper and his staff an extra 24 hours to recalibrate the defensive posture in front of backup goaltender Andrei Vasilevskiy. Tactically speaking, the Lightning reacted brilliantly to the first-period exit via stretcher of starter Ben Bishop the other night, but that was partly due to an inexplicably flummoxed Penguins attack.

“We could have put more pressure on him early, right away, when he first took the net over,” Sullivan said. “I don’t think we grabbed a hold of the momentum as best as we could have or should have.”

A third tipping point, potentially, in Tampa Bay’s favor as a result of Game 1 comes courtesy of the league’s downright comically named Department of Player Safety, which had nothing to add to that five-minute major penalty Lightning forward Ryan Callahan drew for driving Kris Letang headfirst into the boards in the first period.

Callahan, who somehow escaped ejection from on-ice officials for the exact kind of action that begs for it, will now go unsuspended thanks to the NHL’s box-of-chocolates disciplinary blueprint, in which not only do you never know what you’re gonna get, you’re as likely to get something that endangers player safety as something that augments it.

Advertise with us

For all of those reasons, the erstwhile Stanley Cup betting favorites have problems, none of which are insurmountable. They needn’t overreach for solutions, but should rather start by reminding themselves of some defensive principles and of the merits of defenseman Justin Schultz, who needn’t have lost postseason ice time to Maatta.

“Where we have to get better is with the quality of chances that we gave up,” Sullivan said. “I don’t think we gave up a significant amount, but the quality of chances were very high. We have to do a better job of our positioning, of staying above people and on the right side of scrums. We need to make sure we have enough people on the right side of the puck. That was an area of our game where we’ve been very diligent, and we weren’t at our best [Friday] night.”

And as for Schultz:

“He’s a mobile guy; he sees the ice pretty well; he can make that first pass to get us out of our own zone; he’s pretty good on the power play; he can really shoot the puck from the blue line,” Sullivan said. “He provides all of those things for our team.”

All true. But only when he’s in uniform.

Gene Collier: gcollier@post-gazette.com and Twitter @genecollier.